I'm currently reading the Uplift War, the third of David Brin's initial trilogy of Uplift books, in which the galaxy's sentient races are all "uplifted" by older and more technologically advanced races. All except humanity! Which is the main narrative engine of the books so far (he wrote a further trilogy in this setting, which I haven't yet gotten to).
The books are decent. I went through something of a David Brin phase in high school, around the time the film adaptation of his book the Postman came out. I knew about the Uplift books at the time, but didn't pick up the first of the series (Sundiver) until 2004 or so, and the second, Started Rising, a couple of years later.
I mention that to emphasize that because it's been so long since I read them, I don't actually remember much about the plots. So my thoughts are limited to what I'm currently reading in the Uplift War.
As I said, the main thrust of the story is that humans are the only known race (called wolflings) to have uplifted themselves, and to have uplifted pre-sentient races on Earth, in this case chimpanzees and dolphins. It's a neat idea, especially when the narrative examines the ethics of uplifting a race to sentience, asking whether any race even has the right to do that. Uplift tends to be portrayed as a form of indenture (or even slavery), an idea that drives the antagonists and the protagonists who want to avoid this fate.
What I find a little frustrating about all this is that every alien POV character, in each of their chapters, reflects on how freewheeling and clever and exceptional the humans are. They uplifted themselves, after all, before Galactic Civilization made contact with them. They allow their client races, the chimpanzees and dolphins, more leeway to question them than "older races" do. And they just don't abide by the stodgy old norms of Galactic Society, provoking annoyance in the more rigid races and admiration in others.
Leaving aside that this is kind of a "Where's Poochie?" dynamic, it's also hard not to see American exceptionalism in this. I'm aware that SF has a long history of equating humanity with American culture - it's sort of the whole guiding metaphor of Star Trek, for instance, though it goes back further than that. But it's a side of SF that's always sort of bothered me, and I think it's somehow more glaring here than in other SF novels I've read.
To be clear, I'm not surprised or annoyed that American SF does that, because British SF has its own weird tropes and I'm sure SF written in other languages does too. But because the majority of classic SF takes on this trope, it's fairly baked into the genre, and it can get excessive, as here.
It may also be a function of when Brin wrote the stories, of course. The Uplift War came out in 1987, when the US was winning the Cold War and its ideals were on the ascendant, as they haven't really been since 2001 or so. When he was writing, China was still in the first stages of opening up in the wake of Mao's worst excesses, while India was still the "Third World" and not on the radar of most Americans. The one real challenger to American power at the time would likely have been Japan.
So the dominant culture would naturally be the US, which I can understand, for that time. More recent works, like Ann Leckie's Ancillary Justice trilogy, certainly take more of their window dressing from what the West knows of Asian culture (like tea-drinking and despotism). But I find the idea that Earth/America is this vital, young society that will form an example for the stodgy, decadent, older races to be a little uncomfortable.
That is, after all, the reasoning behind the colonization and carving up of Asia in particular by Europe and the US (as opposed to the regions that were considered primitive). In the books, certain cultures get "tired" and get supplanted by more energetic ones - indeed, one extremely old race in the Uplift War is described as exclusively interested in ever-more esoteric forms of meditation, and expected to die out soon.
To be clear, I'm not claiming that David Brin's a giant racist, because politically he's aggressively centrist (yes, I know), and generally quite sensible. But even those who don't actively believe racist ideology can come out with inappropriate things from time to time, and I suspect that's the case here.
The other thing about it is that I wish the damn aliens would just shut up about how great the damn humans are. It's fair for older cultures to see something refreshing about newer cultures that do things a little better, but Brin's humans seem to be just about the best thing that's happened to the galaxy, which feels a little rich given how shittily we're comporting ourselves at the moment. The closest analogue for me is the Elves in Tolkien's world, a group that is described as so wonderful that after a few hundred pages of reading about how great all their stuff is I just wish he'd get back to talking about the hobbits or dwarves or someone more interesting.
I'm surely not the only one who gets a little tired of the author slobbering over one particular group in their books, where even their negative points are actually positives. And as I said, given where America is right now, and the fact that literally no one else in the world wants to follow our example, it just reads as limited. A much better contrast, from around the same time period, is the Keith Giffen and Tom & Mary Bierbaum "Five Years Later" Legion of Superheroes run. That series builds on the old idea that Earth is basically the US, but has been taken over by despotic aliens with the connivance of corrupt humans, and feels a lot more realistic. Not because I believe that's happening now, but simply because it can happen anywhere, and thus can happen here.
And therein lies my discomfort with American exceptionalism. For as much as I buy into the ideals of the US (too often unattained, alas), I also remain aware that the US is a country like many others, populated by people just like any other, and so susceptible to humanity's worst excesses. And that's something we really are seeing right now.
Sunday, 9 September 2018
Monday, 3 September 2018
Throwing a Ring around the World
I don't usually post about tech stuff on this blog. When I worked for Ovum, I kept this strictly separated from that stuff, in part because I could put opinion pieces on our work blog and get my tech-writing yah-yahs out that way. During the (brief) period I was freelancing, I kept that side of things over on my other blog. But sometimes an idea comes up that's good for either, so here we are:
I was thinking about Ring today. It's the smart doorbell manufacturer that got snapped up by Amazon for a billion dollars back in February, and a company I wrote about extensively for Ovum. The interest at the time was this upstart company that just kept attracting funding (including from Amazon's Alexa Fund back in 2016), and when it came onto my radar in early 2017 it had just picked up $109 million for its Series D, making it the most-funded smart home company on my old investment tracker.
That, and their range of products, made them a good target for us to write about, so I chatted with them a few times to prepare a research note, essentially introducing them to Ovum's clients. The thing that stuck with me, and that I was thinking about today, was their approach to the smart home camera sector. Instead of focusing on what was happening inside the home, they reasoned that a good way to make an individual home safer was by making the neighborhood around it safer.
So the Ring doorbell was intended to see what happened out in front of the house, including at other houses on the same street. After all, if someone broke into the house across the street from yours, it would be relevant because your own home could be next. They followed this concept up with smart outdoor lighting, which could help protect your yard, and so on.
As I said, this stuck with me, to the point that of all the companies I wrote about during that time, it's one of the most conceptually interesting ideas I came across. It's also affected my thinking in seemingly unrelated areas, like immigration and foreign policy. The way it applies there is, if a country wants to be safe from illegal immigration, human trafficking, the drug trade, and so forth, it's not enough to combat those things inside its own borders - it'll have to work with its neighbors to sort those problems out at the source.
You can see it here at the US's southern border, where migrants are fleeing violence in their own countries (for example Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador). You can also see it in Europe, where Syrian refugees are fleeing the violence from their country's civil war and the depredations of Daesh/ISIS. In either case, the most enlightened and just policy has to include helping to make their home countries safer (in addition to not mistreating the ones who do arrive seeking asylum or simply a better life).
If you want to stick to tech, this concept is relevant to cybersecurity, and any number of other areas as well. One of the key complaints about smart home devices is the fact that security is often an afterthought, but securing the device, while necessary, is probably not sufficient. You want your network to not be compromised, which means that ideally your neighbors' Wi-Fi networks should be secure too. And so forth.
Amazon obviously bought Ring because its technology could be integrated with the Alexa suite of smart home devices, and because its technical expertise offers a different view on the home than the Echo device had. Also, I don't know Jamie Siminoff at all (I've never met him or spoken to him), but I presume he isn't a bleeding-heart leftie like me.
Still, it's reassuring to know that someone's successfully implemented technology that takes into account the inter-connectedness of communities, and that acknowledges that what's happening outside your house does affect you. This is a powerful but understated idea, and I'd love to see it take root in more of the tech industry - as well as in politics.
I was thinking about Ring today. It's the smart doorbell manufacturer that got snapped up by Amazon for a billion dollars back in February, and a company I wrote about extensively for Ovum. The interest at the time was this upstart company that just kept attracting funding (including from Amazon's Alexa Fund back in 2016), and when it came onto my radar in early 2017 it had just picked up $109 million for its Series D, making it the most-funded smart home company on my old investment tracker.
That, and their range of products, made them a good target for us to write about, so I chatted with them a few times to prepare a research note, essentially introducing them to Ovum's clients. The thing that stuck with me, and that I was thinking about today, was their approach to the smart home camera sector. Instead of focusing on what was happening inside the home, they reasoned that a good way to make an individual home safer was by making the neighborhood around it safer.
So the Ring doorbell was intended to see what happened out in front of the house, including at other houses on the same street. After all, if someone broke into the house across the street from yours, it would be relevant because your own home could be next. They followed this concept up with smart outdoor lighting, which could help protect your yard, and so on.
As I said, this stuck with me, to the point that of all the companies I wrote about during that time, it's one of the most conceptually interesting ideas I came across. It's also affected my thinking in seemingly unrelated areas, like immigration and foreign policy. The way it applies there is, if a country wants to be safe from illegal immigration, human trafficking, the drug trade, and so forth, it's not enough to combat those things inside its own borders - it'll have to work with its neighbors to sort those problems out at the source.
You can see it here at the US's southern border, where migrants are fleeing violence in their own countries (for example Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador). You can also see it in Europe, where Syrian refugees are fleeing the violence from their country's civil war and the depredations of Daesh/ISIS. In either case, the most enlightened and just policy has to include helping to make their home countries safer (in addition to not mistreating the ones who do arrive seeking asylum or simply a better life).
If you want to stick to tech, this concept is relevant to cybersecurity, and any number of other areas as well. One of the key complaints about smart home devices is the fact that security is often an afterthought, but securing the device, while necessary, is probably not sufficient. You want your network to not be compromised, which means that ideally your neighbors' Wi-Fi networks should be secure too. And so forth.
Amazon obviously bought Ring because its technology could be integrated with the Alexa suite of smart home devices, and because its technical expertise offers a different view on the home than the Echo device had. Also, I don't know Jamie Siminoff at all (I've never met him or spoken to him), but I presume he isn't a bleeding-heart leftie like me.
Still, it's reassuring to know that someone's successfully implemented technology that takes into account the inter-connectedness of communities, and that acknowledges that what's happening outside your house does affect you. This is a powerful but understated idea, and I'd love to see it take root in more of the tech industry - as well as in politics.
Thursday, 23 August 2018
Simon Schama's History of Britain
It's taken a while but I finally finished Volume 3 of Simon Schama's History of Britain this week, and the highest compliment I can pay it is that it made me want to keep delving into British history.
Admittedly that can be taken a number of ways, but as I say, it makes me want to know more, and it's just a shame that I can't get that "more" from him.
I started reading it a couple of years ago when I realized that what little I knew of British history was informed primarily by Blackadder. That's not actually such a bad foundation for understanding the historical sweep of Britain, ranging as it does from the Tudor era to the Regency and the First World War, with a bunch of notable stops in between. But while the first series pulls a bunch of dialogue from Shakespeare, I eventually found it worthwhile to find out more.
My dad suggested the books, but I actually knew about them from when I'd first moved over to Southend in 2002, as the show Schama did for the BBC in tandem with the books was on at that time. So I went and picked up a used copy of the first book from the late, lamented Bookbuyers in Mountain View, and made plans to get the next two volumes.
The second volume, covering the start of the Stuart dynasty, the Civil War and the Restoration, as well as the process of wars and conquests that created the Britain that lost its empire and pre-eminence, was devilishly hard to find, and it took a trip to London and a cool £25 to procure a copy. Volume 3, by contrast, cost even more, at £30, so I just got it from the library, two or three years after getting the first one.
Of the three, the third book was the most engaging for me. This is possibly because I thought I knew the most about the time period, from 1776 to 2000, which meant I was better able to follow along. The first was good, and did a fair job of explaining Roman Britain, but for some reason I really failed to engage with the second volume, to the point that I either need to read it again or need to pick up another book about that period.
(Incidentally, this illustrates the Marie Kondo method of procuring and disposing of books: she talks about only keeping things that "spark joy", which means only reading books when you buy them. I didn't with Volume 2, but did with Volume 3, which may explain why I liked it so much more)
As to the content, I can't compare it to any other histories of Britain, because I've never read any. But contrasted with some of the other histories I've read recently (such as on Italy, Spain and the World Wars), Schama's set is nicely complete and comprehensive. In Book 3, for example, he does a good job of anchoring chapters around a single personage, like Queen Victoria, Winston Churchill or George Orwell.
I contrast this approach with a history of Italy that I read last month, the Force of Destiny by Christopher Duggan, which omits a couple of important points in Italian history. The most egregious is the premature death of Count Cavour, who engineered the reunification under the Savoy dynasty and promptly dropped dead of exhaustion. Both are attempts to explore their respective countries through the cultural landscape and the writings of the time, but I suspect that Schama, with his greater space over three books, has room to do a better job.
Picking up the book at this time is probably also the outward expression of a newly formed homesickness for London. Between the months of unemployment/freelancing and adjusting to a new job, hanging around London as I did this winter seems more appealing. At the very least I was reading a lot more, thanks to my commute. So picking up these histories of Britain allowed me to get a bit of England-fix, of the kind that I usually get from re-reading Bill Bryson or something.
In any case, I do have another history of Britain on my bookshelf, The Story of Britain by Rebecca Fraser, which is so Tory that the cover's even a deep shade of blue. I've also been eyeing up other library books, potentially even ones focusing specifically on other parts of the British Isles than England - if there's a criticism to level at Schama, it's that he focuses very little on Scotland or Wales (though he does a great job in Volume 3 of drawing a parallel between the causes of the Republican movement in Ireland and the drive for Indian independence).
And now that I've finally seen the selection at the library, I can feel good about going back and delving further into this section, particularly the books that spark joy (and thus have to be returned in four weeks).
Admittedly that can be taken a number of ways, but as I say, it makes me want to know more, and it's just a shame that I can't get that "more" from him.
I started reading it a couple of years ago when I realized that what little I knew of British history was informed primarily by Blackadder. That's not actually such a bad foundation for understanding the historical sweep of Britain, ranging as it does from the Tudor era to the Regency and the First World War, with a bunch of notable stops in between. But while the first series pulls a bunch of dialogue from Shakespeare, I eventually found it worthwhile to find out more.
My dad suggested the books, but I actually knew about them from when I'd first moved over to Southend in 2002, as the show Schama did for the BBC in tandem with the books was on at that time. So I went and picked up a used copy of the first book from the late, lamented Bookbuyers in Mountain View, and made plans to get the next two volumes.
The second volume, covering the start of the Stuart dynasty, the Civil War and the Restoration, as well as the process of wars and conquests that created the Britain that lost its empire and pre-eminence, was devilishly hard to find, and it took a trip to London and a cool £25 to procure a copy. Volume 3, by contrast, cost even more, at £30, so I just got it from the library, two or three years after getting the first one.
Of the three, the third book was the most engaging for me. This is possibly because I thought I knew the most about the time period, from 1776 to 2000, which meant I was better able to follow along. The first was good, and did a fair job of explaining Roman Britain, but for some reason I really failed to engage with the second volume, to the point that I either need to read it again or need to pick up another book about that period.
(Incidentally, this illustrates the Marie Kondo method of procuring and disposing of books: she talks about only keeping things that "spark joy", which means only reading books when you buy them. I didn't with Volume 2, but did with Volume 3, which may explain why I liked it so much more)
As to the content, I can't compare it to any other histories of Britain, because I've never read any. But contrasted with some of the other histories I've read recently (such as on Italy, Spain and the World Wars), Schama's set is nicely complete and comprehensive. In Book 3, for example, he does a good job of anchoring chapters around a single personage, like Queen Victoria, Winston Churchill or George Orwell.
I contrast this approach with a history of Italy that I read last month, the Force of Destiny by Christopher Duggan, which omits a couple of important points in Italian history. The most egregious is the premature death of Count Cavour, who engineered the reunification under the Savoy dynasty and promptly dropped dead of exhaustion. Both are attempts to explore their respective countries through the cultural landscape and the writings of the time, but I suspect that Schama, with his greater space over three books, has room to do a better job.
Picking up the book at this time is probably also the outward expression of a newly formed homesickness for London. Between the months of unemployment/freelancing and adjusting to a new job, hanging around London as I did this winter seems more appealing. At the very least I was reading a lot more, thanks to my commute. So picking up these histories of Britain allowed me to get a bit of England-fix, of the kind that I usually get from re-reading Bill Bryson or something.
In any case, I do have another history of Britain on my bookshelf, The Story of Britain by Rebecca Fraser, which is so Tory that the cover's even a deep shade of blue. I've also been eyeing up other library books, potentially even ones focusing specifically on other parts of the British Isles than England - if there's a criticism to level at Schama, it's that he focuses very little on Scotland or Wales (though he does a great job in Volume 3 of drawing a parallel between the causes of the Republican movement in Ireland and the drive for Indian independence).
And now that I've finally seen the selection at the library, I can feel good about going back and delving further into this section, particularly the books that spark joy (and thus have to be returned in four weeks).
Sunday, 5 August 2018
Thoughts on Starting a New Job
Tomorrow I start my new job, one that will (at least theoretically) be permanent and long-term and full-time. Eight months since being unceremoniously laid off by my previous company, and three-and-a-half months since wrapping up my three-month contract in London.
I can't deny it's a bit scary. The first thing is the usual point of, will I be good at it, will it last, and so forth. I don't know if I suffer from imposter syndrome, or at least none of the descriptions of it have ever really resonated with me. But my mind is always open to the possibility that I may not be up to a particular set of tasks for which I would be paid. This has happened before, specifically with journalism, so it's not a completely idle fancy.
Whenever I consider this point I always remember that I'm starting a new job, not the army - if it's really terrible, I can always quit and go back to my freelance work.
The other apprehension is less serious, but it's an interesting point. I'll be completely office-based again for the first time in years, which is actually a relief but is also a bit weird because I'll be giving up an entire routine that's sustained me since about May 2016. I'd get up early-ish, shower and shave and have breakfast, do my Khan Academy and Duolingo, and then work until 8 hours were up, whenever that might be. I'd take breaks to go for walks, and to grab lunch, and if I was really stressed I'd nap for a few minutes to clear my head (I sense I'm going to miss this one in particular). During my lunch breaks, I'd watch Netflix, in part because being at home all the time is lonely, and it's nice to hear human speech.
These things are all going away, though I know in certain ways they're being replaced by other stuff. When I was working in London this winter, I fell into a nice routine of coming to the office early to grab a seat, have my breakfast and then do Khan Academy until it was time to start at 8.30. At their best routines can be adaptable to circumstances.
It's been a pretty chaotic year, from losing my job on 1 December, to kicking the can down the road for three months in London, to getting my freelance and contract work lined up in May, June and July. The routines I've set up, or maintained, in that time, have helped shield me a bit from the existential dread that creeps up when you don't know if things are going to work out.
This blog post started from the idea of considering how my life's going to change from being gainfully employed and working in an office again, but it's morphed into thoughts on routines, in part because I keep seeing a former coworker's posts on Facebook and Instagram about how glad he is that he doesn't stick to a routine, because it lets him travel the world and discover new things and all that stuff.
I remain a bit jealous of his digital nomad ways, because I like that rush of discovering new places, but I also don't envy the complete lack of structure or the way that constantly being on the road cuts you off from intimacy. Not to go down too dark a road, but this lack of intimacy has been bandied about as one of the factors in Anthony Bourdain's suicide last month (I've got him in mind too because I've been catching up with Parts Unknown on Netflix).
A routine may seem stifling to some, but to me it provides the structure that allows me to really find out where I can be free, and to exploit those weak spots. So in a way I'm already thinking about the basic routine of my life from here on in, which will be driving to work in the mornings and home in the evenings. I'm lucky enough to have found a job in my own town, so the commute shouldn't be too hellish, and this means that commute can become something to look forward to.
This is all a bit ramble-y, and I've touched on Anthony Bourdain, digital nomads, imposter syndrome and job losses, so it might be worth wrapping up here. But again, I'd like to stress that a significant part of me is looking forward to starting this new gig up and seeing where it takes me. And for the other part of me that's a little worried, I keep reminding it that I can quit if I need to, and restart the freelance thing.
Here's to new beginnings, in any case...
I can't deny it's a bit scary. The first thing is the usual point of, will I be good at it, will it last, and so forth. I don't know if I suffer from imposter syndrome, or at least none of the descriptions of it have ever really resonated with me. But my mind is always open to the possibility that I may not be up to a particular set of tasks for which I would be paid. This has happened before, specifically with journalism, so it's not a completely idle fancy.
Whenever I consider this point I always remember that I'm starting a new job, not the army - if it's really terrible, I can always quit and go back to my freelance work.
The other apprehension is less serious, but it's an interesting point. I'll be completely office-based again for the first time in years, which is actually a relief but is also a bit weird because I'll be giving up an entire routine that's sustained me since about May 2016. I'd get up early-ish, shower and shave and have breakfast, do my Khan Academy and Duolingo, and then work until 8 hours were up, whenever that might be. I'd take breaks to go for walks, and to grab lunch, and if I was really stressed I'd nap for a few minutes to clear my head (I sense I'm going to miss this one in particular). During my lunch breaks, I'd watch Netflix, in part because being at home all the time is lonely, and it's nice to hear human speech.
These things are all going away, though I know in certain ways they're being replaced by other stuff. When I was working in London this winter, I fell into a nice routine of coming to the office early to grab a seat, have my breakfast and then do Khan Academy until it was time to start at 8.30. At their best routines can be adaptable to circumstances.
It's been a pretty chaotic year, from losing my job on 1 December, to kicking the can down the road for three months in London, to getting my freelance and contract work lined up in May, June and July. The routines I've set up, or maintained, in that time, have helped shield me a bit from the existential dread that creeps up when you don't know if things are going to work out.
This blog post started from the idea of considering how my life's going to change from being gainfully employed and working in an office again, but it's morphed into thoughts on routines, in part because I keep seeing a former coworker's posts on Facebook and Instagram about how glad he is that he doesn't stick to a routine, because it lets him travel the world and discover new things and all that stuff.
I remain a bit jealous of his digital nomad ways, because I like that rush of discovering new places, but I also don't envy the complete lack of structure or the way that constantly being on the road cuts you off from intimacy. Not to go down too dark a road, but this lack of intimacy has been bandied about as one of the factors in Anthony Bourdain's suicide last month (I've got him in mind too because I've been catching up with Parts Unknown on Netflix).
A routine may seem stifling to some, but to me it provides the structure that allows me to really find out where I can be free, and to exploit those weak spots. So in a way I'm already thinking about the basic routine of my life from here on in, which will be driving to work in the mornings and home in the evenings. I'm lucky enough to have found a job in my own town, so the commute shouldn't be too hellish, and this means that commute can become something to look forward to.
This is all a bit ramble-y, and I've touched on Anthony Bourdain, digital nomads, imposter syndrome and job losses, so it might be worth wrapping up here. But again, I'd like to stress that a significant part of me is looking forward to starting this new gig up and seeing where it takes me. And for the other part of me that's a little worried, I keep reminding it that I can quit if I need to, and restart the freelance thing.
Here's to new beginnings, in any case...
Sunday, 22 July 2018
How Lovely Southern Oregon Is
Last weekend, in among watching the World Cup final and the third-place playoff, I was with my dad for a road trip up through southern Oregon and the northern coast of California. He'd been to Crater Lake before, and wanted to take me along, so we dutifully packed up the car with sunscreen, bug spray and water bottles, and set out.
We slept in a different town each night, and took in a variety of places on the way. The itinerary, roughly, was Ashland, Medford, Crater Lake, Roseburg and the Oregon Caves, all in Oregon; then Crescent City, California; back to Oregon for a quick wander around the one redwood grove growing outside of California; then back down through the Avenue of the Giants to Willits; and finally stops in Healdsburg and San Francisco.
I'm proud to report that the car got put through its paces, covering about a thousand miles on the trip, but held up great. This is notable because it's 21 years old, and the family keeps predicting that it's on its last legs, but it keeps managing these nice long trips. My secret is taking it in for scheduled maintenance pretty religiously, and opting for short commutes - since the middle of 2016, its most intense action (apart from these periodic trips with my dad) has been a single drive per week up to SF's financial district. Other than that I used it to drive to the gym or to lunch most days.
But back to what we saw. In terms of towns we saw, the highlight for me was Ashland. I'd been hearing about the place for ages, because of the Shakespeare Festival, but never got the chance to pass through until now. To be honest, after a day's driving in epic heat, it was like stumbling into an oasis, albeit a very hot oasis. We strolled through the center of town for a bit, checked out Lithia Park with its bandstand (which was preparing for a show that evening), and stopped for dinner at a sushi place near the park.
It all seemed extraordinarily genteel, well-kept and pleasantly laid out, and I'll be honest, if life were to send me to Ashland for an extended period I think I'd be pretty pleased. Even the 100+ degree heat was kind of welcome, because my head was getting scrambled by all the AC on the drive up. More than anything, though, it was the sight of the bandstand filling up for the evening, with locals of all ages staking out spots on the grass to listen to music - it felt a million miles away from anything here in the Bay Area.
Crater Lake was probably the natural high point. We got there the following day, after staying the night in Medford. My dad and I went for a look at the East Rim of the crater, and then went for a walk to Mt. Garfield, one of the highest peaks there, and got some amazing views not only of the lake itself, but also the hilly countryside behind it - it was easy to see where Ansel Adams got his inspiration from. And the neatest part was that even though it was about 95 degrees there that day, there were still a few lumps of snow lying around.
The plan the next day was to head to Coos Bay and check out the Oregon Coast, but a navigational failure meant that we drove for a couple of hours south before realizing we'd have had to double back about halfway to Roseburg to get there. So instead we drove to the Oregon Caves, another national park, and got the hour-long tour of some amazing cave systems. Beyond the geological wonder of the place, it was interesting seeing the effect humans have had on the cave system, with a number of trails and chambers hacked out at different times by Victorian and New Deal-era administrators. It's a long drive up a number of winding country roads, but worth a visit for all that.
That evening we got to Crescent Bay, and the weather turned cool for the rest of the trip, because Crescent City is right on the Pacific and so bedeviled by fog most of the time. It was under this kind of weather that we drove up again into Oregon the next morning to check out the Oregon Redwood Trail.
That's a state park, and not a very well-known one, judging from the effort it took to get there. We got lost a couple of times and then, when we found the way, drove for about four miles up an unpaved road to get to it. Without taking too much away from it, you don't go to see huge trees, although there were a few impressive specimens there. But the spot is notable for being home to the northernmost trees of a network that stretches all the way down to Monterey, California. It was early in the morning, at least as far as day trippers are concerned, so we had the place mostly to ourselves for our quick amble through the groves.
The other highlight for that day was the Avenue of the Giants. This was a special bit for me, because it's probably the first time I've introduced an outdoorsy spot to my dad, rather than him showing one to me. But I'd been there before for a half-marathon, so I knew to look out for it, and was pleased to see he was really impressed by it.
One thing to note about the trip is that the hotels got worse and worse each night. We didn't spend a lot of time looking for cute inns or B&Bs to stay in, so we opted for the national chains and some of them were pretty basic. The best was the Quality Inn in Medford on the first night, and the worst was the Redwood Inn in Willits, which is about a hundred miles south of the Avenue of the Giants. They ended up being fine for our needs, particularly as related to watching World Cup games, but we agreed that we could probably have just stayed in Quality Inns in each place. Or driven back down to Medford for a second night after Crater Lake.
On a more positive note we managed to find a local brewery each night (except in Willits), and passed the evenings in an even more convivial fashion. The highlight was probably Seaquake Brewing in Crescent City, which looked like the hoppingest place in town on the Saturday night that we were there.
This leads into the other aspect of Crescent City, and a number of other places we passed through on the trip. Apart from Ashland, most of these towns were pretty down-at-heel, reflecting the loss of jobs and industry in the region. Places along the Avenue of the Giants are still sustained by logging, but Crescent City in particular seemed to hold a lot more ramshackle houses and people who looked pretty down on their luck. Adding to the miasma were the ever-present gun shops (including an army surplus in Medford offering full SWAT gear for the budding white supremacist) and the signs advocating for the "state of Jefferson", which the northern counties of California want to secede into.
On the positive side, people were super friendly, there and north of the state line. One lady in the Crescent City Safeway struck up a conversation with me and my dad while we waited in the checkout line, which seems unlikely to happen in Palo Alto.
One of the things that always strikes me about California is how diverse the landscapes are. Since moving back I've been all over the state, including Yosemite, Mono Lake and other outdoor spots, and I just can't get enough of it. I also can't recommend it highly enough.
| Mount Shasta, driving up on the first day |
I'm proud to report that the car got put through its paces, covering about a thousand miles on the trip, but held up great. This is notable because it's 21 years old, and the family keeps predicting that it's on its last legs, but it keeps managing these nice long trips. My secret is taking it in for scheduled maintenance pretty religiously, and opting for short commutes - since the middle of 2016, its most intense action (apart from these periodic trips with my dad) has been a single drive per week up to SF's financial district. Other than that I used it to drive to the gym or to lunch most days.
But back to what we saw. In terms of towns we saw, the highlight for me was Ashland. I'd been hearing about the place for ages, because of the Shakespeare Festival, but never got the chance to pass through until now. To be honest, after a day's driving in epic heat, it was like stumbling into an oasis, albeit a very hot oasis. We strolled through the center of town for a bit, checked out Lithia Park with its bandstand (which was preparing for a show that evening), and stopped for dinner at a sushi place near the park.
It all seemed extraordinarily genteel, well-kept and pleasantly laid out, and I'll be honest, if life were to send me to Ashland for an extended period I think I'd be pretty pleased. Even the 100+ degree heat was kind of welcome, because my head was getting scrambled by all the AC on the drive up. More than anything, though, it was the sight of the bandstand filling up for the evening, with locals of all ages staking out spots on the grass to listen to music - it felt a million miles away from anything here in the Bay Area.
Crater Lake was probably the natural high point. We got there the following day, after staying the night in Medford. My dad and I went for a look at the East Rim of the crater, and then went for a walk to Mt. Garfield, one of the highest peaks there, and got some amazing views not only of the lake itself, but also the hilly countryside behind it - it was easy to see where Ansel Adams got his inspiration from. And the neatest part was that even though it was about 95 degrees there that day, there were still a few lumps of snow lying around.
| Crater Lake from the Watchman Overlook |
That evening we got to Crescent Bay, and the weather turned cool for the rest of the trip, because Crescent City is right on the Pacific and so bedeviled by fog most of the time. It was under this kind of weather that we drove up again into Oregon the next morning to check out the Oregon Redwood Trail.
That's a state park, and not a very well-known one, judging from the effort it took to get there. We got lost a couple of times and then, when we found the way, drove for about four miles up an unpaved road to get to it. Without taking too much away from it, you don't go to see huge trees, although there were a few impressive specimens there. But the spot is notable for being home to the northernmost trees of a network that stretches all the way down to Monterey, California. It was early in the morning, at least as far as day trippers are concerned, so we had the place mostly to ourselves for our quick amble through the groves.
| Near Crater Lake |
One thing to note about the trip is that the hotels got worse and worse each night. We didn't spend a lot of time looking for cute inns or B&Bs to stay in, so we opted for the national chains and some of them were pretty basic. The best was the Quality Inn in Medford on the first night, and the worst was the Redwood Inn in Willits, which is about a hundred miles south of the Avenue of the Giants. They ended up being fine for our needs, particularly as related to watching World Cup games, but we agreed that we could probably have just stayed in Quality Inns in each place. Or driven back down to Medford for a second night after Crater Lake.
On a more positive note we managed to find a local brewery each night (except in Willits), and passed the evenings in an even more convivial fashion. The highlight was probably Seaquake Brewing in Crescent City, which looked like the hoppingest place in town on the Saturday night that we were there.
This leads into the other aspect of Crescent City, and a number of other places we passed through on the trip. Apart from Ashland, most of these towns were pretty down-at-heel, reflecting the loss of jobs and industry in the region. Places along the Avenue of the Giants are still sustained by logging, but Crescent City in particular seemed to hold a lot more ramshackle houses and people who looked pretty down on their luck. Adding to the miasma were the ever-present gun shops (including an army surplus in Medford offering full SWAT gear for the budding white supremacist) and the signs advocating for the "state of Jefferson", which the northern counties of California want to secede into.
On the positive side, people were super friendly, there and north of the state line. One lady in the Crescent City Safeway struck up a conversation with me and my dad while we waited in the checkout line, which seems unlikely to happen in Palo Alto.
One of the things that always strikes me about California is how diverse the landscapes are. Since moving back I've been all over the state, including Yosemite, Mono Lake and other outdoor spots, and I just can't get enough of it. I also can't recommend it highly enough.
Tuesday, 17 July 2018
World Cup 2018: New Year's Day and the Holiday Season is Over
That's that, then.
Another World Cup, done and dusted. The French have been crowned champions, the narratives have all tied themselves up, and the trophies are all handed out. In addition, the podcasts making sense of what happened have been recorded, so we're officially done with soccer for the next three weeks or so. I'm a little sad that I'm going to have to find new topics to write about here in the blog, but such is life, I suppose.
The Guardian's Football Daily, the Totally Football Show, and Game of Our Lives have all given their thoughts on the action on and off the pitch, but I wanted to reflect on the passing of another tournament.
This is my seventh World Cup, and my sixth that I've watched from start to finish (I came late to 1994 despite it being held in the US). Much like Ted Mosby's triennial rewatch of the Star Wars trilogy in How I Met Your Mother, it becomes a useful way of marking the passage of time.
In 1994, I'd just finished my first year of high school, and glimpsing how the Italian fans celebrated getting to the finalist me on a path of fascination with Europe, which would lead to me living there several times as an adult. It also made me fall in love with football, and all the pageantry and silliness surrounding the World Cup.
In 1998, I was finishing my first year of college, and still on a number of paths I'd started down four years earlier: for example, my German teacher indulged my interest and told me I should be supporting her hometown team, Eintracht Frankfurt (and to this day, I do check their results in the Bundesliga every week).
When 2002 rolled around I was a few months into my first job, and my first stint living in Britain, hired because I could speak German. I watched the final in a pub in London with the brother of an Irish friend I'd known in Germany.
For 2006, I'd just started my second job, and stint in London - quite literally, as the tournament started on the first Friday after I began the job. That's a particularly sweet memory not just because Italy won it, beating France on penalties, but also because I thought I'd sold a story (it turned out not to be, because the publisher was weird and dodgy). I guess that's a metaphor for how Italy did afterwards, as I don't know that the promise of those early days of June 2006 bore out, either in football, my personal life or my professional life.
In 2010 I was still in the same job, but a little stalled, on all fronts. Yet there were the stirrings of some progress, which would bear out the following year when I switched to my new job in telecoms. The other abiding memory is being in Bordeaux with friends during the group stage, and seeing the French national team implode, even as Italy could barely muster a draw with New Zealand. I remember being so unsatisfied with the final, both the level of play and the quality of Spain as winners.
For 2014 I was once again embarking on a new chapter in my life, having just transferred over to California with work and discovering the joy of streaming matches on my computer at work. I watched the final at my mom's house, enjoying my stepdad's pleasure at seeing Germany win, but my clearest memory of that tournament is rather the Brazil-Germany semifinal, which I watched in an Irish pub on Castro Street in Mountain View with a British friend. The best thing was how the Brazilians in the pub, shellshocked from their team's humiliating defeat, started singing and dancing and generally having a party - since they were all there anyway.
And this year? 2018 was marked by my job loss at the end of the previous year, and my departure to London for a few months. It's also marked by my having found a new job while the tournament was going on, including being greeted at my interview by the hiring manager who said he'd been watching the group stage match between England and Belgium. The final I watched in a hotel room in Crescent City, CA, during a road trip of a few days with my dad where we took in Oregon and northern California.
So where will I be in 2022? Going by previous years, it wouldn't be inappropriate to guess I'll be embarking on whatever my next step is going to be after this one, but who knows? I expect I won't be anywhere near Qatar, unless I move to Europe again at some point in the meantime. And as for who wins, there's no basis for it but I might as well guess now that France won't defend its title, and nor will Croatia get to the final again (Brazil is the last team to reach consecutive finals, win or lose, in 1994, 1998 and 2002).
Looking at my final World Cup post from four years ago, I held out hope that 2022 would be stripped from Qatar and given to the US, but now that NAFTA is set to hold the 2026 tournament, it's unlikely to get taken away from the Qataris, so it'll be interesting to see how that all turns out.
The last thought here is sadness that the tournament's over, but a little relief too, as I get to go back to normal life (such as that is, given that I'm having to start turning down freelance jobs as well). It might seem strange, but I'm glad the World Cup doesn't come along more often, as the large gap between each one lets me better take stock of what's changed and what hasn't. Rituals like this, which let you mark the passage of time, are important and good ways to chart how the rest of the world has changed too - after all, in 2014, I don't think I'd have expected the political situation we have now.
So roll on World Cups every four years, and European Championships in between. And in the meantime I'll be consoling myself with the Champions League and club football. After all, the Premier League starts on 10 August, so less than a month to go!
Another World Cup, done and dusted. The French have been crowned champions, the narratives have all tied themselves up, and the trophies are all handed out. In addition, the podcasts making sense of what happened have been recorded, so we're officially done with soccer for the next three weeks or so. I'm a little sad that I'm going to have to find new topics to write about here in the blog, but such is life, I suppose.
The Guardian's Football Daily, the Totally Football Show, and Game of Our Lives have all given their thoughts on the action on and off the pitch, but I wanted to reflect on the passing of another tournament.
This is my seventh World Cup, and my sixth that I've watched from start to finish (I came late to 1994 despite it being held in the US). Much like Ted Mosby's triennial rewatch of the Star Wars trilogy in How I Met Your Mother, it becomes a useful way of marking the passage of time.
In 1994, I'd just finished my first year of high school, and glimpsing how the Italian fans celebrated getting to the finalist me on a path of fascination with Europe, which would lead to me living there several times as an adult. It also made me fall in love with football, and all the pageantry and silliness surrounding the World Cup.
In 1998, I was finishing my first year of college, and still on a number of paths I'd started down four years earlier: for example, my German teacher indulged my interest and told me I should be supporting her hometown team, Eintracht Frankfurt (and to this day, I do check their results in the Bundesliga every week).
When 2002 rolled around I was a few months into my first job, and my first stint living in Britain, hired because I could speak German. I watched the final in a pub in London with the brother of an Irish friend I'd known in Germany.
For 2006, I'd just started my second job, and stint in London - quite literally, as the tournament started on the first Friday after I began the job. That's a particularly sweet memory not just because Italy won it, beating France on penalties, but also because I thought I'd sold a story (it turned out not to be, because the publisher was weird and dodgy). I guess that's a metaphor for how Italy did afterwards, as I don't know that the promise of those early days of June 2006 bore out, either in football, my personal life or my professional life.
In 2010 I was still in the same job, but a little stalled, on all fronts. Yet there were the stirrings of some progress, which would bear out the following year when I switched to my new job in telecoms. The other abiding memory is being in Bordeaux with friends during the group stage, and seeing the French national team implode, even as Italy could barely muster a draw with New Zealand. I remember being so unsatisfied with the final, both the level of play and the quality of Spain as winners.
For 2014 I was once again embarking on a new chapter in my life, having just transferred over to California with work and discovering the joy of streaming matches on my computer at work. I watched the final at my mom's house, enjoying my stepdad's pleasure at seeing Germany win, but my clearest memory of that tournament is rather the Brazil-Germany semifinal, which I watched in an Irish pub on Castro Street in Mountain View with a British friend. The best thing was how the Brazilians in the pub, shellshocked from their team's humiliating defeat, started singing and dancing and generally having a party - since they were all there anyway.
And this year? 2018 was marked by my job loss at the end of the previous year, and my departure to London for a few months. It's also marked by my having found a new job while the tournament was going on, including being greeted at my interview by the hiring manager who said he'd been watching the group stage match between England and Belgium. The final I watched in a hotel room in Crescent City, CA, during a road trip of a few days with my dad where we took in Oregon and northern California.
So where will I be in 2022? Going by previous years, it wouldn't be inappropriate to guess I'll be embarking on whatever my next step is going to be after this one, but who knows? I expect I won't be anywhere near Qatar, unless I move to Europe again at some point in the meantime. And as for who wins, there's no basis for it but I might as well guess now that France won't defend its title, and nor will Croatia get to the final again (Brazil is the last team to reach consecutive finals, win or lose, in 1994, 1998 and 2002).
Looking at my final World Cup post from four years ago, I held out hope that 2022 would be stripped from Qatar and given to the US, but now that NAFTA is set to hold the 2026 tournament, it's unlikely to get taken away from the Qataris, so it'll be interesting to see how that all turns out.
The last thought here is sadness that the tournament's over, but a little relief too, as I get to go back to normal life (such as that is, given that I'm having to start turning down freelance jobs as well). It might seem strange, but I'm glad the World Cup doesn't come along more often, as the large gap between each one lets me better take stock of what's changed and what hasn't. Rituals like this, which let you mark the passage of time, are important and good ways to chart how the rest of the world has changed too - after all, in 2014, I don't think I'd have expected the political situation we have now.
So roll on World Cups every four years, and European Championships in between. And in the meantime I'll be consoling myself with the Champions League and club football. After all, the Premier League starts on 10 August, so less than a month to go!
Wednesday, 11 July 2018
World Cup 2018: It's Going Home, or, 1996 and all that
So despite my previous post, I'm not in much of a gloating mood to see England go out. As I said, I have complicated feelings about them, and so while I can't properly get excited to see them win, I also can't get too depressed to see them go out. And I have to give them credit for getting this far, after years of, to be honest, rank underachievement.
It's funny that the Lightning Seeds song, Three Lions, was dusted off and resurrected for this World Cup campaign, as not only does it date from the last tournament in which England reached a semi-final, but it's also from the first tournament where I followed England. Those are names to conjure with, you know: Paul Gascoigne, Alan Shearer, Teddy Sheringham, David Seaman... maybe not as revered as the Class of 1966, but still recent enough that they haven't faded into history as untouchable icons the way Jack and Bobby Charlton have, or Sir Bobby Moore, or Geoff Hurst...
That's also the first (and last) time I saw London completely spellbound by the national team, to the point of knowing how the game was going by the sounds I heard as I walked outside on the street. I'm sure it would have been like that this year, although I get the sense that the mode of celebrating wins and goals this time around has been communally, at pubs, and throwing all your beers in the air when something good happens.
From there England became a quarter-finals team. That's the stage at which they left the next three World Cups, in 1998, 2002 and 2006. They had slightly more mixed fortunes in the European championships, going out of the group stage in 2000, losing in the quarter-final to France in 2004, and not even qualifying for 2008.
1998 is my other abiding memory of that England team of the 90s, capped by watching their 2-2 draw against Argentina at my friend Sean's house, a game that still resonates in the English psyche now. Michael Owen's run to score a wonderful individual goal, David Beckham's tussle with Diego Simeone and his sending-off, Sol Campbell's disallowed header that would have put them through...
Somehow, something changed in the squad with the turn of the millennium. Gascoigne and Shearer and the like were stars, but they weren't STARS, the way Beckham became, and it's possible the players started to believe their own hype too much. In my last post I mentioned an incident, which occurred in the 2006 quarter-final against Portugal, where David Beckham and Wayne Rooney both left the pitch in tears, wound up to the back teeth by Cristiano Ronaldo's play-acting and the Portuguese gamesmanship more generally - but also a sense that they weren't being allowed to play as they wanted.
Even now, 12 years later, I look back on that display with distaste. Not because of the crying, per se, but because those were spoiled children's tears. Paul Gascoigne's tears in the 1990 semi-final were an emotional outpouring at being denied a spot in the final (and one that I didn't see, as I wasn't following football back then) - Beckham and Rooney were crying because things didn't go their way.
But even before then, I remember how cock-sure England and its fans were in the run-up to the tournament. Mars bars changed their names to "Believe", and Michael Owen confidently predicted he'd pick up the golden boot, despite not scoring and tearing his ACL less than a minute into the third group match against Sweden, which ended his tournament. After England went out, a shell-shocked friend confessed he'd really thought they could do it this time, which always mystified me - it didn't look that different a squad than the one I'd previously seen in 2004.
But enough about the past - what about this England? I don't know if they played that amazingly well this year, thinking about it objectively. They were deadly on set pieces, and Harry Kane is well-positioned to bring home the golden boot (the first English player to do so since Gary Lineker in 1986), which speaks for itself, but in the games I saw, they never looked that incisive in front of goal. Which isn't necessarily a criticism of England, because I think a lot of teams struggled with that, but it's a clear weakness to be addressed.
By the way, I'm aware of the 6-1 drubbing of Panama, and know that logically it can't have only consisted of penalties and set-piece goals. But without taking anything away from England, Panama was a terrible, terrible team, and England has always benefited from these early mismatches.
Which is, incidentally, the other point worth highlighting about this team, as opposed to previous tournaments. Between 2002 and 2016 there was always something a bit ponderous and yet still lackadaisical about them. The worst example was (again) 2006, where the team came in with high expectations from themselves and their fans, bolstered in particular by the famous 5-1 victory against Germany in Munich, but were dull, plodding and not at all fun to watch in the first two matches against Paraguay and Trinidad & Tobago.
I remember at the first game the embarrassed looks on the faces of Gary Lineker and the rest of the BBC commentators when the cameras cut to them at half-time. England had looked so bad, so unlike the swashbuckling heroes that they always fancy themselves, that it was as if a team of ringers from a local pub had somehow infiltrated the England camp and made it onto the field at Frankfurt - that was probably the moment that the next ten years were decided for the team.
So, to come back to this England squad, I have to single out in particular Gareth Southgate for praise. He's done a good job of building on the good work done by his predecessor Roy Hodgson (and his one-game predecessor Sam Allardyce), but seems to have also done a good job of creating a cohesive team, rather than stuffing it with all the big names and egos - after all, one of the criticisms leveled at Hodgson was his seeming inability to stand up to star players who were probably past it, like Wayne Rooney in 2016.
And I have to give special credit to Southgate for preparing England for its first World Cup penalty shootout win. He is, after all, the man who missed the decisive penalty back in 1996, so it makes sense that he'd have them train on that specific aspect of the game.
I found myself consoling a friend after the match today, one of the ones who was insisting I get on the England bandwagon. Not wanting to gloat, I instead suggested that he look at this as a great achievement (which it is) and as a chance for England to build into a team that really can challenge in the years to come (which is also true). In fact, as I was talking to him I was reminded of another team from 2006, one that seemed to burst out of nowhere with feats of athleticism and team cohesion. I'm referring to Germany, of course, which made it to the semi-finals that year and in 2010 before winning in 2014.
That's not a bad template to follow, and if England can replicate that run of form, then it really will be coming home.
(To be followed by a humiliating group stage exit four years later, but hey...)
It's funny that the Lightning Seeds song, Three Lions, was dusted off and resurrected for this World Cup campaign, as not only does it date from the last tournament in which England reached a semi-final, but it's also from the first tournament where I followed England. Those are names to conjure with, you know: Paul Gascoigne, Alan Shearer, Teddy Sheringham, David Seaman... maybe not as revered as the Class of 1966, but still recent enough that they haven't faded into history as untouchable icons the way Jack and Bobby Charlton have, or Sir Bobby Moore, or Geoff Hurst...
That's also the first (and last) time I saw London completely spellbound by the national team, to the point of knowing how the game was going by the sounds I heard as I walked outside on the street. I'm sure it would have been like that this year, although I get the sense that the mode of celebrating wins and goals this time around has been communally, at pubs, and throwing all your beers in the air when something good happens.
From there England became a quarter-finals team. That's the stage at which they left the next three World Cups, in 1998, 2002 and 2006. They had slightly more mixed fortunes in the European championships, going out of the group stage in 2000, losing in the quarter-final to France in 2004, and not even qualifying for 2008.
1998 is my other abiding memory of that England team of the 90s, capped by watching their 2-2 draw against Argentina at my friend Sean's house, a game that still resonates in the English psyche now. Michael Owen's run to score a wonderful individual goal, David Beckham's tussle with Diego Simeone and his sending-off, Sol Campbell's disallowed header that would have put them through...
Somehow, something changed in the squad with the turn of the millennium. Gascoigne and Shearer and the like were stars, but they weren't STARS, the way Beckham became, and it's possible the players started to believe their own hype too much. In my last post I mentioned an incident, which occurred in the 2006 quarter-final against Portugal, where David Beckham and Wayne Rooney both left the pitch in tears, wound up to the back teeth by Cristiano Ronaldo's play-acting and the Portuguese gamesmanship more generally - but also a sense that they weren't being allowed to play as they wanted.
Even now, 12 years later, I look back on that display with distaste. Not because of the crying, per se, but because those were spoiled children's tears. Paul Gascoigne's tears in the 1990 semi-final were an emotional outpouring at being denied a spot in the final (and one that I didn't see, as I wasn't following football back then) - Beckham and Rooney were crying because things didn't go their way.
But even before then, I remember how cock-sure England and its fans were in the run-up to the tournament. Mars bars changed their names to "Believe", and Michael Owen confidently predicted he'd pick up the golden boot, despite not scoring and tearing his ACL less than a minute into the third group match against Sweden, which ended his tournament. After England went out, a shell-shocked friend confessed he'd really thought they could do it this time, which always mystified me - it didn't look that different a squad than the one I'd previously seen in 2004.
But enough about the past - what about this England? I don't know if they played that amazingly well this year, thinking about it objectively. They were deadly on set pieces, and Harry Kane is well-positioned to bring home the golden boot (the first English player to do so since Gary Lineker in 1986), which speaks for itself, but in the games I saw, they never looked that incisive in front of goal. Which isn't necessarily a criticism of England, because I think a lot of teams struggled with that, but it's a clear weakness to be addressed.
By the way, I'm aware of the 6-1 drubbing of Panama, and know that logically it can't have only consisted of penalties and set-piece goals. But without taking anything away from England, Panama was a terrible, terrible team, and England has always benefited from these early mismatches.
Which is, incidentally, the other point worth highlighting about this team, as opposed to previous tournaments. Between 2002 and 2016 there was always something a bit ponderous and yet still lackadaisical about them. The worst example was (again) 2006, where the team came in with high expectations from themselves and their fans, bolstered in particular by the famous 5-1 victory against Germany in Munich, but were dull, plodding and not at all fun to watch in the first two matches against Paraguay and Trinidad & Tobago.
I remember at the first game the embarrassed looks on the faces of Gary Lineker and the rest of the BBC commentators when the cameras cut to them at half-time. England had looked so bad, so unlike the swashbuckling heroes that they always fancy themselves, that it was as if a team of ringers from a local pub had somehow infiltrated the England camp and made it onto the field at Frankfurt - that was probably the moment that the next ten years were decided for the team.
So, to come back to this England squad, I have to single out in particular Gareth Southgate for praise. He's done a good job of building on the good work done by his predecessor Roy Hodgson (and his one-game predecessor Sam Allardyce), but seems to have also done a good job of creating a cohesive team, rather than stuffing it with all the big names and egos - after all, one of the criticisms leveled at Hodgson was his seeming inability to stand up to star players who were probably past it, like Wayne Rooney in 2016.
And I have to give special credit to Southgate for preparing England for its first World Cup penalty shootout win. He is, after all, the man who missed the decisive penalty back in 1996, so it makes sense that he'd have them train on that specific aspect of the game.
I found myself consoling a friend after the match today, one of the ones who was insisting I get on the England bandwagon. Not wanting to gloat, I instead suggested that he look at this as a great achievement (which it is) and as a chance for England to build into a team that really can challenge in the years to come (which is also true). In fact, as I was talking to him I was reminded of another team from 2006, one that seemed to burst out of nowhere with feats of athleticism and team cohesion. I'm referring to Germany, of course, which made it to the semi-finals that year and in 2010 before winning in 2014.
That's not a bad template to follow, and if England can replicate that run of form, then it really will be coming home.
(To be followed by a humiliating group stage exit four years later, but hey...)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)