I've talked before about my love for the Mission Log Podcast, and I'm going to say a bit more about it today. I just spent part of the day listening to their episode from January on the Deep Space 9 double episode from the second season, The Maquis.
I've been looking forward to it for a while. Since they started doing DS9, frankly. And all because of this scene:
I didn't see that scene when it first aired in the 90s, because I wasn't watching DS9 yet. But when I did see it on my first attempt at watching the whole series back in 2006 or thereabouts, I locked onto it because it articulated how I'd always felt about DS9 in comparison with other Star Trek shows.
Now, I grew up with Trek. Some of my earliest memories are of catching TOS reruns when I was three or four years old. Old videotapes my parents recorded for me of other TV shows had commercials for TNG, which at that time was airing in first-run. And in the 90s I was basically catching between 15 and 20 hours of Trek, new and in reruns, during the period when I'd discovered DS9 and Voyager and after TNG had ended.
I didn't expect to love DS9 so much, but it felt like a good corrective to the increasingly sterile and safe atmosphere of TNG and Voyager. Where Captain Picard and Captain Janeway were running around lecturing aliens and their crews on the Prime Directive and on Federation ideals more generally, Commander (and then Captain) Sisko was dealing one singular mess, week after week and year after year. He didn't have the luxury of flying away.
In part because whenever he tried, problems would come find him. In first run the episodes I remember that spoke to this were the two-parter of Homefront and Paradise Lost, where the suspicion of the Dominion infiltrating Earth causes the Federation to freak out and come close to imposing martial law. Maybe it says something weird about me, but I loved the show more for showing us that the Federation had feet of clay as well. And that's what I took along when I rewatched those episodes in 2006 and again in 2016.
Now Mission Log co-host Ken Ray doesn't love those aspects of DS9 as much as I do. He stressed in the episode recapping The Maquis that he's not bothered so much by the sentiments of Sisko's speech, as the fact that Sisko's the one delivering it. And when he puts it that way, I can't help but agree a little - it's disheartening that the captain, the freaking guy in charge of the Federation presence on Deep Space 9, is the one who's frustrated with the Federation and its high-minded ideals.
But on the other hand, what I love about the speech remains, at least in how I've always read it. If Star Trek maps onto Cold War-era views of the world, in which the Federation represents the United States, then the thing I loved about DS9 the most was that it questioned those aspects of Trek. Because America's role as a force for good in the world is always worth questioning... though not worth dismissing out of hand, because there are genuinely positive parts of it, even if US foreign policy kept many parts of the world under brutal dictatorships for decades because we were afraid of those countries falling to communism.
The way I read that scene, with Admiral Nechayev ordering Sisko to talk to the Maquis and make them see reason, fits into this ideal that America could go into a country, tell them what to do, and everything would be fine, because it's America saying it. Our interventions abroad have frequently followed this pattern, and we've gone awfully wrong in a lot of cases because of it - Iraq being only the most recent example.
When Captain Sisko says people on Earth look out the window and see paradise, the writers mean that people in America see paradise out their windows (remember this was the 90s, when things weren't as fucked up as they are now - and no, that's not a dig at the current occupant of the White House, but at the conditions that brought him to power). But seeing that paradise out their windows, the people of Earth think that all problems around the world can be solved the same way they did it themselves.
This isn't any sort of argument that democracy or freedom only works for certain types of people. Russia, China, the Middle East, and so forth, would be better off if they weren't being run by autocrats and gangsters. But equally it's not enough to tell them to just implement democratic and free-market reforms, and everything will be fine - that's exactly what Russia did in the early 90s, and we're paying the price for it now.
Worse, Homefront and Paradise Lost show how brittle that veneer of paradise is at home. But it's worth noting that in those episodes good prevails precisely because Sisko and his allies hold to their ideals, the ideals of the Federation and of Star Trek generally, and because the antagonists are just as devoted to the Federation's ideals (at least as they see it). Which is perhaps an instructive example for us now - that as we stick true to our proper ideals of respect, diversity and freedom, and don't compromise, we can still win out, even if it'll be difficult.
And that's a message that Trek has been giving us since the 60s, with the Original Series.
Sunday, 17 February 2019
Sunday, 10 February 2019
Re Collecting James Robinson's Starman
This is one I've been wanting to write for a while. After rereading my old Justice League and Legion of Superheroes books, I moved on to Starman, by James Robinson and Tony Harris (eventually Peter Snejbjerg), which was another big favorite when I was in high school and then again when I was finishing up college.
Unlike the Giffen/DeMatteis League or Giffen/Bierbaums Legion, I was there at the start for Starman, having picked up Issue 0 as part of the Zero Hour crossover that restructured the DC Universe (again) in 1994. It was one of the first books where I followed the writer from his previous work, because it was a followup to James Robinson's Elseworlds miniseries The Golden Age, though thinking back now I'm not sure what else exactly drew me to it.
Having just finished rereading the ten issues of Justice Society of America Vol. 2 by Len Strazewski and Mike Parobeck (et al), I seem to recall not knowing anything about the JSA before I picked up that series. Starman appears in maybe two issues, is mentioned in a third issue, and only has a speaking role in the final issue. If anything, the character I found most striking from that book was the Sandman (Wesley Dodds), who had an equally small role.
Regardless of what drew me to the book - and it may have just been Robinson, and an appreciation for the art and proposed storylines before it was released - I was hooked from the start. Everything about the book was different, from the design ethic based on Art Deco to the main character, Jack Knight, who was completely different from other superheroes. Even the letter column was different, with James Robinson answering the letters each month for the first year or so and insisting that he wanted people to tell him about what they were collecting - and not just comics.
Now, another thing that bolted me onto the book for years after was meeting Robinson (and inker Wade von Grawbadger) at Wonder-Con, back when it was still held in Oakland. I stuck to him all day, as I recall, asking him about all sorts of aspects about the book, and in the end he gave me his PO box address and told me to write. I did, but too late - when I saw him again two Wonder-Cons later he said he'd moved.
Anyway. Another neat thing was that he and von Grawbadger both drew little sketches of Starman for my autograph book, which still makes me quite happy (Golden Age Green Lantern creator Sheldon Moldoff and DC legend Dick Giordano are also in that little book of mine, btw).
I continued reading the book each month until I went to college, and then started up again a year or so later, so that I have most issues with just one large gap of about 11 issues, and a few smaller gaps after that. From there I kept up with it to the very end. And then I let it sit for almost twenty years without rereading it or even thinking very much about it.
Like anything that you revisit after so long, things look different when you come back. To get the big one out of the way first, I'm not sure it's aged as well as I'd like. Tony Harris's artwork is quite rough in the beginning, and there are some spots where his sense of proportion is off. Though I'll try and take the sting off this critique by noting that his compositions were always ambitious and kinetic, to a degree not always seen in books at the time, so the odd failure can be forgiven.
The writing doesn't always hold up completely, either. The big thing that struck me was the weird spots where Robinson puts emphasis in the dialogue: the words that he puts in bold break up the flow of how the characters would be speaking the sentences in real life, and it actually got really distracting. There were also parts that seemed a little self-indulgent, even back when I was 14. The one I've always remembered is a character beating another to death while talking about movie portrayals of Philip Marlowe; another I'd forgotten about was a sequence where a bunch of mobsters are talking about Sondheim musicals, before they all get gunned down.
But if there's a few things that don't hold up, there's lots that still does. I generally remembered big storylines from late in the series, like Stars My Destination and Grand Guignol, and so when Robinson alludes to them in the first few issues, I was left impressed at how intricately he plotted all 81 issues of the book, as well as the fact that he got to play out every one of those storylines he teased, even as early as issue #5.
He also does a great job of populating the setting, Opal City, with a fascinating supporting cast, starting with Golden Age villain the Shade (who becomes an amoral "good" guy here). Even the villains are fascinating, most importantly Nash, the daughter of the Golden Age Mist, who becomes Jack Knight's arch-nemesis (and the mother of his child) as a continuation of her father's feud with Jack's. She has an arc, just as surely as Jack or other characters, and at the end it's tragic but mostly satisfying.
Jack's another thing that doesn't entirely hold up, but that's more because of the passage of time than because of any flaw in his characterization. What I think I liked about him then was his approach to crimefighting, and how it was portrayed alongside his normal life. DC specialized in stories like that in the 80s, which I still think was their greatest period. Ironically, one of the examples I always held out about this approach in DC's storytelling was the previous Starman series featuring a different and unrelated character who Robinson nevertheless brings into the narrative stretching back to the 1940s.
The reason Jack doesn't necessarily hold up, or hasn't aged well, is that he's a character that made a lot of sense then, but doesn't seem to anymore. Maybe it's because I'm less fascinated by old things, or I'm fascinated by different old things, but the idea of a quirky antiques shop owner as a superhero just seems so far from the norm today, when characters like Deadpool approach naturalistic storytelling in a very different way. And it doesn't help that his clothing, his sideburns, his tattoos and goatee all look like they belong in the medium-term past.
But again, I really loved rereading this book. I caught a lot of things on this second pass because I've now experienced many of them. The main thing that made me sit up in holy-shittedness was the last page of the first issue, where he's bleeding out from a fight and a bunch of rarities are flitting through his head - and among them is "Scott Walker albums on vinyl". I'd never heard of Scott Walker before then, but I sure did afterwards - and probably the real thing that separates now from 1994 is that Walker wasn't held up as a godlike genius yet back then. He was a faded pop idol from the 60s who'd disappeared after doing some really weird, avant garde music in his later career.
Back then Scott Walker in any format would have been a rarity - I remember in 2005 a record shop employee telling me his CDs were hard to find in the US. Now he's available on Spotify and anyone can listen to him. Just like you can probably find all of Jack Knight's stock of old clothes, old toys, old posters on Amazon or Ebay.
This was an interesting thought that struck me as I read it in the past couple of months. The internet means you can find most things and have them dispatched to you in no time, regardless of where you are or how old it is. The best example is a letter from early on in the series, where a man wrote in asking for help locating his father. Idly I went and googled the old man's name, and found him still living in Florida - which raises questions about whether the letter writer ever found his dad in these past 25 years.
Anyway, if we need another illustration of how much a product of another time James Robinson and Tony Harris's Starman series was, you just need to look at the publication month of the final issue: August 2001.
Unlike the Giffen/DeMatteis League or Giffen/Bierbaums Legion, I was there at the start for Starman, having picked up Issue 0 as part of the Zero Hour crossover that restructured the DC Universe (again) in 1994. It was one of the first books where I followed the writer from his previous work, because it was a followup to James Robinson's Elseworlds miniseries The Golden Age, though thinking back now I'm not sure what else exactly drew me to it.
Having just finished rereading the ten issues of Justice Society of America Vol. 2 by Len Strazewski and Mike Parobeck (et al), I seem to recall not knowing anything about the JSA before I picked up that series. Starman appears in maybe two issues, is mentioned in a third issue, and only has a speaking role in the final issue. If anything, the character I found most striking from that book was the Sandman (Wesley Dodds), who had an equally small role.
Regardless of what drew me to the book - and it may have just been Robinson, and an appreciation for the art and proposed storylines before it was released - I was hooked from the start. Everything about the book was different, from the design ethic based on Art Deco to the main character, Jack Knight, who was completely different from other superheroes. Even the letter column was different, with James Robinson answering the letters each month for the first year or so and insisting that he wanted people to tell him about what they were collecting - and not just comics.
Now, another thing that bolted me onto the book for years after was meeting Robinson (and inker Wade von Grawbadger) at Wonder-Con, back when it was still held in Oakland. I stuck to him all day, as I recall, asking him about all sorts of aspects about the book, and in the end he gave me his PO box address and told me to write. I did, but too late - when I saw him again two Wonder-Cons later he said he'd moved.
Anyway. Another neat thing was that he and von Grawbadger both drew little sketches of Starman for my autograph book, which still makes me quite happy (Golden Age Green Lantern creator Sheldon Moldoff and DC legend Dick Giordano are also in that little book of mine, btw).
I continued reading the book each month until I went to college, and then started up again a year or so later, so that I have most issues with just one large gap of about 11 issues, and a few smaller gaps after that. From there I kept up with it to the very end. And then I let it sit for almost twenty years without rereading it or even thinking very much about it.
Like anything that you revisit after so long, things look different when you come back. To get the big one out of the way first, I'm not sure it's aged as well as I'd like. Tony Harris's artwork is quite rough in the beginning, and there are some spots where his sense of proportion is off. Though I'll try and take the sting off this critique by noting that his compositions were always ambitious and kinetic, to a degree not always seen in books at the time, so the odd failure can be forgiven.
The writing doesn't always hold up completely, either. The big thing that struck me was the weird spots where Robinson puts emphasis in the dialogue: the words that he puts in bold break up the flow of how the characters would be speaking the sentences in real life, and it actually got really distracting. There were also parts that seemed a little self-indulgent, even back when I was 14. The one I've always remembered is a character beating another to death while talking about movie portrayals of Philip Marlowe; another I'd forgotten about was a sequence where a bunch of mobsters are talking about Sondheim musicals, before they all get gunned down.
But if there's a few things that don't hold up, there's lots that still does. I generally remembered big storylines from late in the series, like Stars My Destination and Grand Guignol, and so when Robinson alludes to them in the first few issues, I was left impressed at how intricately he plotted all 81 issues of the book, as well as the fact that he got to play out every one of those storylines he teased, even as early as issue #5.
He also does a great job of populating the setting, Opal City, with a fascinating supporting cast, starting with Golden Age villain the Shade (who becomes an amoral "good" guy here). Even the villains are fascinating, most importantly Nash, the daughter of the Golden Age Mist, who becomes Jack Knight's arch-nemesis (and the mother of his child) as a continuation of her father's feud with Jack's. She has an arc, just as surely as Jack or other characters, and at the end it's tragic but mostly satisfying.
Jack's another thing that doesn't entirely hold up, but that's more because of the passage of time than because of any flaw in his characterization. What I think I liked about him then was his approach to crimefighting, and how it was portrayed alongside his normal life. DC specialized in stories like that in the 80s, which I still think was their greatest period. Ironically, one of the examples I always held out about this approach in DC's storytelling was the previous Starman series featuring a different and unrelated character who Robinson nevertheless brings into the narrative stretching back to the 1940s.
The reason Jack doesn't necessarily hold up, or hasn't aged well, is that he's a character that made a lot of sense then, but doesn't seem to anymore. Maybe it's because I'm less fascinated by old things, or I'm fascinated by different old things, but the idea of a quirky antiques shop owner as a superhero just seems so far from the norm today, when characters like Deadpool approach naturalistic storytelling in a very different way. And it doesn't help that his clothing, his sideburns, his tattoos and goatee all look like they belong in the medium-term past.
But again, I really loved rereading this book. I caught a lot of things on this second pass because I've now experienced many of them. The main thing that made me sit up in holy-shittedness was the last page of the first issue, where he's bleeding out from a fight and a bunch of rarities are flitting through his head - and among them is "Scott Walker albums on vinyl". I'd never heard of Scott Walker before then, but I sure did afterwards - and probably the real thing that separates now from 1994 is that Walker wasn't held up as a godlike genius yet back then. He was a faded pop idol from the 60s who'd disappeared after doing some really weird, avant garde music in his later career.
Back then Scott Walker in any format would have been a rarity - I remember in 2005 a record shop employee telling me his CDs were hard to find in the US. Now he's available on Spotify and anyone can listen to him. Just like you can probably find all of Jack Knight's stock of old clothes, old toys, old posters on Amazon or Ebay.
This was an interesting thought that struck me as I read it in the past couple of months. The internet means you can find most things and have them dispatched to you in no time, regardless of where you are or how old it is. The best example is a letter from early on in the series, where a man wrote in asking for help locating his father. Idly I went and googled the old man's name, and found him still living in Florida - which raises questions about whether the letter writer ever found his dad in these past 25 years.
Anyway, if we need another illustration of how much a product of another time James Robinson and Tony Harris's Starman series was, you just need to look at the publication month of the final issue: August 2001.
Sunday, 3 February 2019
The Long Strange Career of the Kinks
Just finished listening to basically every album by the Kinks a week or so ago. I get into these moods sometimes, where I go through an artist's entire discography, or through a Pitchfork top albums of whatever decade list, and a few weeks ago it occurred to me that what I needed in my life was to subject the Kinks to this treatment.
I'd say I have a healthy respect for them, borne of owning a couple of studio albums (including Village Green Preservation Society) and a greatest hits compilation. I may not hold them up quite as high as the Beatles in my ranking of British pop bands from the 60s, but they may have a more consistent oeuvre from that decade than The Who, which is another favorite and which is currently receiving the same whole-discography treatment.
Unlike the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, I didn't grow up with the Kinks being played all the time around me. I don't think I heard of them for the first time until Weird Al's parody of "Lola" or until the Britpop thing was underway, and that was mainly in reference to how Damon Albarn's songwriting was clearly indebted to Ray Davies's slice-of-life style. And somewhere in those years I started hearing more about them, until I decided I should just get a greatest hits album to find out what the fuss was all about.
The first thing I discovered was that I actually did know some of their music, since I'd heard songs like "You Really Got Me" over the years. I'd just never known it was them. The next thing was the diversity of their body of work from those years, since those early singles were very different indeed from the likes of "Waterloo Sunset" or "Dedicated Follower of Fashion".
From there I had to get a handle on the idea that the compilation I owned wasn't particularly comprehensive. While it had "Lola" on it, I soon learned that other albums like Village Green Preservation Society weren't represented. After college I went through an initial "music archeologist" phase, as a friend once called it, and gathered Village Green and Face to Face on CD, because they'd been mentioned on a few top British album lists I'd read.
The next thing I did was check out their discography on Allmusic, and that's where I discovered that they hadn't actually broken up until 1996, and had indeed continued making albums of varying quality throughout the years that, it seemed, no one was actually paying attention to them. I remained intrigued by this lost period, and haunted by the statement (I can't remember by whom) that if they'd broken up at the same time as the Beatles they'd have been legends.
So when I listened to all their albums on YouTube the aim was to fill in these gaps and see for myself how good those albums were. I also wanted to get the foundation, from their earliest albums, so that I could hear how their sound evolved from proto-hard rock to English-influenced gentility, and what that turned into.
The main thing I took away from the Allmusic history of the band was that the early 70s, when Ray Davies was insisting on concept albums around celebrity and whatever else, were a pretty terrible period for them. And I can confirm that this is the case, even if the albums aren't completely unlistenable.
What did surprise me was learning how much they improved in the latter half of the decade. Sleepwalkers, their first straight-ahead rock album since the early ones, isn't necessarily a classic (and has a pretty crap cover) but was surprisingly enjoyable. It and its follow ups sounded like the work of a guy in his thirties figuring out again what he's good at and going with that. The other thing that surprised me was that they were all clearly Kinks songs, with Davies's voice and songwriting keeping a line of continuity with some of the best of the 60s, even as they turned into a sort of cut-price Rolling Stones (and I have to admit that I'm both looking forward to and dreading going through that discography) in the 80s.
It's true that by the time they released Phobia, their final album of all original songs, they were sounding pretty tired, though even that album has some high points. But it was so interesting as I listened to those albums to consider what was happening around them in music. While they went for a more traditional English pastoral sound, other British bands were getting louder and heavier.
Later on, Sleepwalkers and Misfits don't make much reference to what was happening in punk, while the albums of the 80s occupy a different universe than the post-punk and synth-pop that was coming out of that decade. And the greatest irony of all is that they broke up just as the British music scene was starting to rediscover them. Phobia came out the same year that Blur released Modern Life is Rubbish, their own foray into British iconography, and the Kinks broke up completely in 1996, the year that Britpop was at its height.
Throughout it all, I was most intrigued by what Ray Davies was thinking as he and the band wrote, recorded and released each of their albums after their heyday. Clearly people were still buying the albums, even if only out of deference to the band's history, but it must have been odd to be so firmly out of the musical zeitgeist. Though it's also fair to say that their music always went counter to the trends being set by the Beatles, Stones or Who in the 60s and 70s.
Thinking back to the idea that they'd have been legends if they'd broken up after Muswell Hillbillies, it's probably true. Albums like Preservation Acts 1 and 2, Everybody's in Showbiz, and Schoolboys in Disgrace are just silly and indulgent (and have some of the worst covers ever). But even if they never again hit the heights of Village Green Preservation Society, it was rewarding discovering those albums when they changed direction toward hard rock. They may not deserve to be in your iTunes collection, but they deserve a listen.
I'd say I have a healthy respect for them, borne of owning a couple of studio albums (including Village Green Preservation Society) and a greatest hits compilation. I may not hold them up quite as high as the Beatles in my ranking of British pop bands from the 60s, but they may have a more consistent oeuvre from that decade than The Who, which is another favorite and which is currently receiving the same whole-discography treatment.
Unlike the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, I didn't grow up with the Kinks being played all the time around me. I don't think I heard of them for the first time until Weird Al's parody of "Lola" or until the Britpop thing was underway, and that was mainly in reference to how Damon Albarn's songwriting was clearly indebted to Ray Davies's slice-of-life style. And somewhere in those years I started hearing more about them, until I decided I should just get a greatest hits album to find out what the fuss was all about.
The first thing I discovered was that I actually did know some of their music, since I'd heard songs like "You Really Got Me" over the years. I'd just never known it was them. The next thing was the diversity of their body of work from those years, since those early singles were very different indeed from the likes of "Waterloo Sunset" or "Dedicated Follower of Fashion".
From there I had to get a handle on the idea that the compilation I owned wasn't particularly comprehensive. While it had "Lola" on it, I soon learned that other albums like Village Green Preservation Society weren't represented. After college I went through an initial "music archeologist" phase, as a friend once called it, and gathered Village Green and Face to Face on CD, because they'd been mentioned on a few top British album lists I'd read.
The next thing I did was check out their discography on Allmusic, and that's where I discovered that they hadn't actually broken up until 1996, and had indeed continued making albums of varying quality throughout the years that, it seemed, no one was actually paying attention to them. I remained intrigued by this lost period, and haunted by the statement (I can't remember by whom) that if they'd broken up at the same time as the Beatles they'd have been legends.
So when I listened to all their albums on YouTube the aim was to fill in these gaps and see for myself how good those albums were. I also wanted to get the foundation, from their earliest albums, so that I could hear how their sound evolved from proto-hard rock to English-influenced gentility, and what that turned into.
The main thing I took away from the Allmusic history of the band was that the early 70s, when Ray Davies was insisting on concept albums around celebrity and whatever else, were a pretty terrible period for them. And I can confirm that this is the case, even if the albums aren't completely unlistenable.
What did surprise me was learning how much they improved in the latter half of the decade. Sleepwalkers, their first straight-ahead rock album since the early ones, isn't necessarily a classic (and has a pretty crap cover) but was surprisingly enjoyable. It and its follow ups sounded like the work of a guy in his thirties figuring out again what he's good at and going with that. The other thing that surprised me was that they were all clearly Kinks songs, with Davies's voice and songwriting keeping a line of continuity with some of the best of the 60s, even as they turned into a sort of cut-price Rolling Stones (and I have to admit that I'm both looking forward to and dreading going through that discography) in the 80s.
It's true that by the time they released Phobia, their final album of all original songs, they were sounding pretty tired, though even that album has some high points. But it was so interesting as I listened to those albums to consider what was happening around them in music. While they went for a more traditional English pastoral sound, other British bands were getting louder and heavier.
Later on, Sleepwalkers and Misfits don't make much reference to what was happening in punk, while the albums of the 80s occupy a different universe than the post-punk and synth-pop that was coming out of that decade. And the greatest irony of all is that they broke up just as the British music scene was starting to rediscover them. Phobia came out the same year that Blur released Modern Life is Rubbish, their own foray into British iconography, and the Kinks broke up completely in 1996, the year that Britpop was at its height.
Throughout it all, I was most intrigued by what Ray Davies was thinking as he and the band wrote, recorded and released each of their albums after their heyday. Clearly people were still buying the albums, even if only out of deference to the band's history, but it must have been odd to be so firmly out of the musical zeitgeist. Though it's also fair to say that their music always went counter to the trends being set by the Beatles, Stones or Who in the 60s and 70s.
Thinking back to the idea that they'd have been legends if they'd broken up after Muswell Hillbillies, it's probably true. Albums like Preservation Acts 1 and 2, Everybody's in Showbiz, and Schoolboys in Disgrace are just silly and indulgent (and have some of the worst covers ever). But even if they never again hit the heights of Village Green Preservation Society, it was rewarding discovering those albums when they changed direction toward hard rock. They may not deserve to be in your iTunes collection, but they deserve a listen.
Sunday, 27 January 2019
Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels
Well, since I can't seem to shut up about British stuff at the moment, here's a few thoughts on Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, which I just rewatched on Netflix last night.
The first thing to say is that I'm not 100% sure it holds up. This is not to say it's a bad movie or anything, but it looks and sounds really raw, and the line readings and acting aren't always as great as they could be. Part of this is because a lot of the characters are played by non-actors - for a couple of them it was their first time in a movie, and others were definitely at the beginning of their careers.
Guy Ritchie also tries to be a little too clever sometimes with his cinematography. The spot where it really works is the start of the movie, where Eddy loses the card game and kicks off the chain of events that make up the plot. The camera focuses tight on his face, following him as he walks out and blurring or doubling shots of him to give that impression of drunken what-the-fuckness that I can relate to.
Not that I've ever lost £500,000 to East End gangsters in an underground poker game, but Ritchie does a good job of capturing that body-blow type of feeling.
He's a little less successful in a few other spots, like when they're celebrating having pulled off their heist, or when Big Chris (as played by Vinnie Jones) is beating Dog to death with a car door for having threatened his son. In the first case, it looks too staged, while in the second it's kind of obvious - of course Big Chris is enraged at his son being endangered, so I wonder if shooting that more matter-of-factly would have worked better than slow-motion.
Though it should be noted that I was super impressed with that scene when I was seventeen.
But about that there Vinnie Jones: was there ever a role better suited to a human being than that? Maybe I say it because I don't know Jones as a footballer, and because this film was the first I ever saw of him. But with twenty years of seeing Jones in other roles, and learning more about British gangster films, I have to appreciate how well he inhabits the role - after all, there's not many footballers I'd believe in the role of an East End enforcer.
Casting is uniformly pretty good in the movie, at least in terms of how the actors look. The main characters all look like petty criminal losers, the weed growers look like a bunch of middle-class stoners out of their element (I'm always a bit surprised to remember that Winston is not, in fact, played by Blur singer Damon Albarn, but he could have been), and the real criminals all look like real criminals.
As I said, sometimes the line readings aren't great, which might be because the actors aren't great at line readings, or because the lines aren't easy to read in the first place. But very little of it takes you out of the movie.
Two other casting choices I want to single out. First is Sting, as JD, Eddy's father. I always forget he's in this movie, and I have to say that for a tantric-sex-having, lute-playing former punk rocker he's actually fairly believable as a bar owner and basically the one honest man who's not affected by the shenanigans going on around him. The scene where Vinnie Jones comes to tell him he's going to have to give up the bar in a week, and Sting tells him to tell his boss to go fuck himself, is really fun and the two actors play off against each other really well.
The other one is Jason Statham, who like Vinnie Jones used this movie to launch his movie career. But where Jones has played essentially the same character for the past twenty years, Statham starts out here as a very different character from what he plays in the Transporter or the Fast & Furious movies. Actually, the first scene, where he's shilling stolen goods in an alley in London and giving it the wideboy patter (to use the Brits' own term of art) makes him pop like a firecracker. You can believe him in the role, even knowing what a badass he gets typecast as all these years later. Go rewatch that scene and enjoy an actor reveling in a role.
What else is there? The music, of course, though perhaps the most memorable thing is the use of Ocean Colour Scene's "100 Mile High City". Britpop was kind of over by then, but the movie still manages to catch that zeitgeist in a way that feels right. Most impressive to me was the use of "Fools Gold" by the Stone Roses as the end of the plot unfolds, with all the bad guys dead and the heroes walking away with whatever riches they've found. I love the song, and it's a nice revelation to see it crop up here.
So yeah, flawed movie and all, rough around the edges with the acting and scripting and cinematography, but you can't deny that the movie's fun and eye-catching and well-cast. Despite the presence of Jones and Statham, who went on to big success in Hollywood, it's not chock-full of other British actors that you recognize, so that you can just go on enjoying the movie without going, "What? John Simm, Doctor Who's the Master, as New Order guitarist Bernard Sumner?" To pull out an example at complete random.
Lock, Stock and its successor Snatch are the only two Guy Ritchie films I've seen. I don't know if I'm feeling the lack, but taken together they're a fun indicator of what British gangster movies were doing back then. They also got copied by a bunch of other movies, which also shows how people responded to them. Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels is where it started, and it's a nice way to spend a couple of hours - so go check it out on Netflix asap.
The first thing to say is that I'm not 100% sure it holds up. This is not to say it's a bad movie or anything, but it looks and sounds really raw, and the line readings and acting aren't always as great as they could be. Part of this is because a lot of the characters are played by non-actors - for a couple of them it was their first time in a movie, and others were definitely at the beginning of their careers.
Guy Ritchie also tries to be a little too clever sometimes with his cinematography. The spot where it really works is the start of the movie, where Eddy loses the card game and kicks off the chain of events that make up the plot. The camera focuses tight on his face, following him as he walks out and blurring or doubling shots of him to give that impression of drunken what-the-fuckness that I can relate to.
Not that I've ever lost £500,000 to East End gangsters in an underground poker game, but Ritchie does a good job of capturing that body-blow type of feeling.
He's a little less successful in a few other spots, like when they're celebrating having pulled off their heist, or when Big Chris (as played by Vinnie Jones) is beating Dog to death with a car door for having threatened his son. In the first case, it looks too staged, while in the second it's kind of obvious - of course Big Chris is enraged at his son being endangered, so I wonder if shooting that more matter-of-factly would have worked better than slow-motion.
Though it should be noted that I was super impressed with that scene when I was seventeen.
But about that there Vinnie Jones: was there ever a role better suited to a human being than that? Maybe I say it because I don't know Jones as a footballer, and because this film was the first I ever saw of him. But with twenty years of seeing Jones in other roles, and learning more about British gangster films, I have to appreciate how well he inhabits the role - after all, there's not many footballers I'd believe in the role of an East End enforcer.
Casting is uniformly pretty good in the movie, at least in terms of how the actors look. The main characters all look like petty criminal losers, the weed growers look like a bunch of middle-class stoners out of their element (I'm always a bit surprised to remember that Winston is not, in fact, played by Blur singer Damon Albarn, but he could have been), and the real criminals all look like real criminals.
As I said, sometimes the line readings aren't great, which might be because the actors aren't great at line readings, or because the lines aren't easy to read in the first place. But very little of it takes you out of the movie.
Two other casting choices I want to single out. First is Sting, as JD, Eddy's father. I always forget he's in this movie, and I have to say that for a tantric-sex-having, lute-playing former punk rocker he's actually fairly believable as a bar owner and basically the one honest man who's not affected by the shenanigans going on around him. The scene where Vinnie Jones comes to tell him he's going to have to give up the bar in a week, and Sting tells him to tell his boss to go fuck himself, is really fun and the two actors play off against each other really well.
The other one is Jason Statham, who like Vinnie Jones used this movie to launch his movie career. But where Jones has played essentially the same character for the past twenty years, Statham starts out here as a very different character from what he plays in the Transporter or the Fast & Furious movies. Actually, the first scene, where he's shilling stolen goods in an alley in London and giving it the wideboy patter (to use the Brits' own term of art) makes him pop like a firecracker. You can believe him in the role, even knowing what a badass he gets typecast as all these years later. Go rewatch that scene and enjoy an actor reveling in a role.
What else is there? The music, of course, though perhaps the most memorable thing is the use of Ocean Colour Scene's "100 Mile High City". Britpop was kind of over by then, but the movie still manages to catch that zeitgeist in a way that feels right. Most impressive to me was the use of "Fools Gold" by the Stone Roses as the end of the plot unfolds, with all the bad guys dead and the heroes walking away with whatever riches they've found. I love the song, and it's a nice revelation to see it crop up here.
So yeah, flawed movie and all, rough around the edges with the acting and scripting and cinematography, but you can't deny that the movie's fun and eye-catching and well-cast. Despite the presence of Jones and Statham, who went on to big success in Hollywood, it's not chock-full of other British actors that you recognize, so that you can just go on enjoying the movie without going, "What? John Simm, Doctor Who's the Master, as New Order guitarist Bernard Sumner?" To pull out an example at complete random.
Lock, Stock and its successor Snatch are the only two Guy Ritchie films I've seen. I don't know if I'm feeling the lack, but taken together they're a fun indicator of what British gangster movies were doing back then. They also got copied by a bunch of other movies, which also shows how people responded to them. Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels is where it started, and it's a nice way to spend a couple of hours - so go check it out on Netflix asap.
Sunday, 20 January 2019
English Football Managers: An Endangered Species
I've already written of my pleasure at Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's appointment as Manchester United manager. That was with three matches of him in charge, all of which he'd won. And now we're at seven, across both the Premier League and the FA Cup, and he's still got that perfect record. So talk is naturally turning to whether or not he should be offered the job on a permanent basis.
Some people (by which I mean Guardian football writers, since I get most of my footballing news and insights from there) would say yes, and others think it should go to another manager, perhaps one with more pedigree in winning stuff. The big name thrown about is Tottenham's Mauricio Pochettino, who's helped turn Spurs into title contenders (though not winners). The other one that's cropped up is Zinedine Zidane, who's available after his shock resignation from Real Madrid following their third Champions League victory.
I'm sure other names will crop up as the season draws to a close. There are plenty of innovative young managers (and not so young ones) all across the continent - I'm sure Thomas Tuchel would get a look in, and potentially Massimiliano Allegri, or any number of others. I've also heard Gareth Southgate mooted, though not without reservation.
Notably, though, he's the only English manager whose name comes up in these sorts of discussions, and that's only because he led England to the semi-finals in this most recent World Cup. He wasn't in the frame for discussions of who should get the Arsenal job or the Chelsea job when those came vacant at the end of last season.
But then, why would an owner of one of the top six sides select an English manager to lead their team, when they could just cherry-pick one of the best (or second-best) managers from Spain, Italy, Germany or France? And it's not just the top six sides who are a little scared of hiring Englishmen: in the whole Premier League, there are only five English managers (or six, if you count Chris Hughton, who's considered Irish because that's where he played internationally).
It wasn't always like this. In the Premier League's very first season, out of 22 managers, all but 16 managers in the division were English, with one Irishman and the rest all Scots. That trend held until the 1996-97 season, when Arsene Wenger joined Arsenal. At the end of that season English managers accounted for 55% of all managers in the league, whereas the year before they'd hit a never-to-be-achieved-again high of 80% (or 17 out of 20).
The number stuck around 50-55% until 2010, when it dropped to 25%. Despite climbing up as high as 45% again in 2015, though, the number's stuck at around 20% ever since, or an average of 27% across the last ten seasons.
These numbers are slightly skewed by the fact that they only count the managers in place at the end of the season, and in the case of 2019 they're in real-time, which is to say that they represent whoever's in charge at that moment. That means that I've just updated my spreadsheet to reflect that Mark Hudson has taken over as caretaker at Huddersfield Town following the resignation of David Wagner (American/German), and that I haven't counted Mark Hughes (Welsh) because he left Southampton before I created the spreadsheet.
One of my favorite facts is that no English manager has won the English top division since it became the Premier League. I'm not discounting the achievements of Alex Ferguson or Kenny Dalgliesh when their teams have won it, but they're Scottish, not English, and so despite having the same passport as Gareth Southgate or whoever, they don't count for the purposes of this blog. And Ferguson's success slightly distorts matters, as that means that only two Britons have won the league in the past 26 years.
That's a pretty long time for a country's managers not to have any success in winning league titles. If we take Spain as a counter-example, Spanish managers have won the title 12 times, of which four Castilian-speaking managers have won it seven times between them, with two Catalans and one Basque taking the rest.
Spain is a good example here, because like the UK, it has much sharper cultural differences between its regions than other European countries. There may not be an official Catalan or Basque or Galician national team, but those areas consider themselves separate, not least because of language, to a degree that you wouldn't find in Germany or Italy, or indeed even the UK itself.
Italy, by the way, has the opposite problem. The majority of managers are Italian, and there was a point this season where all 20 teams were managed by Italians. The last foreigner to win the title there was Jose Mourinho, with Inter, and each season since then has crowned either Antonio Conte or Max Allegri as the winning manager.
But back to England. The popularity of hiring English, or more generally British, managers has collapsed since the 90s. Any analysis of why that should be is likely to be incomplete, so let me attempt it anyway, so I can have it picked apart by people smarter than me.
The main cause is probably the division between the elite clubs in England and the rest - the ones who fall between seventh and seventeenth place. As the gap has widened between the buying power of Chelsea or Manchester City on the one hand, and Watford or Everton on the other, the bigger clubs have set their sights on larger prizes than just the league. They aim for the Champions League. And if no English manager has won the Premier League, certainly no English manager has won the Champions League during the period, from 2005 to 2012, when English sides dominated by getting to the final almost every year.
So the first strike against English managers is that they aren't proven Champions League winners. The next point is that they aren't proven trophy-winners of any sort, or at least any sort that matters to a top-flight team's owner. The likes of Eddie Howe (Bournemouth), Sean Dyche (Burnley) or Neil Warnock (Cardiff City) may have won second division trophies and steered their clubs to promotion into the Premier League, but they've won no other trophies of note, certainly not during their tenures in the top flight.
In fact, the only English manager currently in the EPL to have won any trophies at all is Roy Hodgson, at Crystal Palace, who's won an impressive eight top-flight leagues abroad, and two national cups in other countries. And in fairness he had a crack at a top EPL team, when he managed Liverpool, but that wasn't what you'd call a total success.
You could say that this reluctance to hire English managers is also down to the fact that their placing each season means they can't even realistically plan to win trophies. Some teams place high enough to participate in the Champions League or the Europa League, while others do badly enough that they drop into the Championship, but for those teams ranked 7 to 17, there's nothing to play for after a certain point. The winners of the league tend to emerge fairly early, and so do the candidates for relegation, so everyone else can basically coast.
An extreme example is last season's Burnley team, which got as high as seventh at one point and then embarked on a losing streak of something like 11 games, which saw their position dip not at all. If all a manager has to do is coast and avoid the kind of catastrophe that sees them relegated, that doesn't exactly indicate ground-breaking tactical nous.
The one example of someone who tried to bridge the gap is Everton's David Moyes (Scottish), who was handpicked by Alex Ferguson to take over at Manchester United in 2013. He was anointed on the basis of strong performances by Everton in the preceding years, which saw them nearly reach the Champions League. But Moyes's style proved unsuited to United's, and in a lot of ways the club has still not recovered from the tailspin caused by his 10 months in charge. Nor has his own reputation recovered quickly - he had shitty spells at Real Sociedad in Spain, and at Sunderland (which in recent years has become the graveyard of many a manager's career), before rescuing himself somewhat by keeping West Ham from being relegated last season.
You could argue that winning a European trophy would be a good way for an English manager to make a mark, and you might be right. Except that again, you run into the problem of the gap between the richest clubs and the middle class. The example here is Burnley this season. After last season's heroics they qualified for the Europa League, but because those games take place on a Thursday night, and typically require longer trips than Champions League away legs, the players have less time to recover. And Burnley's results have shown that. They currently sit 16th, on 22 points, with a -20 goal difference.
And to be fair, playing in the Champions League is already plenty tough for the richest clubs, which can afford larger squads to rotate in and out for those types of matches. What hope do smaller, less well-off clubs like Burnley have?
Let me leave you with a thought on how to resurrect the English manager, though. There was a time when English managers (and players) would crop up abroad and do exciting things out there. Terry Venables won La Liga with Barcelona in 1984-85, and Welshman John Toshack won it with Real Madrid five seasons later. Venables later led the English national team to the semi-finals in Euro 96, on home soil, making him one of the most successful national managers since 1966. Bobby Robson also had spells abroad, in Spain and Portugal and the Netherlands, and also led England to the semi-finals in the 1990 World Cup.
There may not actually be a correlation there, but it's worth exploring. More English managers should take postings abroad, so they can learn what's happening in other leagues and bring it back to England. Other countries' coaches have been introducing innovations to the EPL, so why shouldn't the English? There's a little promise here, as young English players like Jadon Sancho are suddenly becoming in vogue in Germany - if that continues, they could eventually become the managers who land elite jobs in England by having won big in Europe.
Some people (by which I mean Guardian football writers, since I get most of my footballing news and insights from there) would say yes, and others think it should go to another manager, perhaps one with more pedigree in winning stuff. The big name thrown about is Tottenham's Mauricio Pochettino, who's helped turn Spurs into title contenders (though not winners). The other one that's cropped up is Zinedine Zidane, who's available after his shock resignation from Real Madrid following their third Champions League victory.
I'm sure other names will crop up as the season draws to a close. There are plenty of innovative young managers (and not so young ones) all across the continent - I'm sure Thomas Tuchel would get a look in, and potentially Massimiliano Allegri, or any number of others. I've also heard Gareth Southgate mooted, though not without reservation.
Notably, though, he's the only English manager whose name comes up in these sorts of discussions, and that's only because he led England to the semi-finals in this most recent World Cup. He wasn't in the frame for discussions of who should get the Arsenal job or the Chelsea job when those came vacant at the end of last season.
But then, why would an owner of one of the top six sides select an English manager to lead their team, when they could just cherry-pick one of the best (or second-best) managers from Spain, Italy, Germany or France? And it's not just the top six sides who are a little scared of hiring Englishmen: in the whole Premier League, there are only five English managers (or six, if you count Chris Hughton, who's considered Irish because that's where he played internationally).
It wasn't always like this. In the Premier League's very first season, out of 22 managers, all but 16 managers in the division were English, with one Irishman and the rest all Scots. That trend held until the 1996-97 season, when Arsene Wenger joined Arsenal. At the end of that season English managers accounted for 55% of all managers in the league, whereas the year before they'd hit a never-to-be-achieved-again high of 80% (or 17 out of 20).
The number stuck around 50-55% until 2010, when it dropped to 25%. Despite climbing up as high as 45% again in 2015, though, the number's stuck at around 20% ever since, or an average of 27% across the last ten seasons.
These numbers are slightly skewed by the fact that they only count the managers in place at the end of the season, and in the case of 2019 they're in real-time, which is to say that they represent whoever's in charge at that moment. That means that I've just updated my spreadsheet to reflect that Mark Hudson has taken over as caretaker at Huddersfield Town following the resignation of David Wagner (American/German), and that I haven't counted Mark Hughes (Welsh) because he left Southampton before I created the spreadsheet.
One of my favorite facts is that no English manager has won the English top division since it became the Premier League. I'm not discounting the achievements of Alex Ferguson or Kenny Dalgliesh when their teams have won it, but they're Scottish, not English, and so despite having the same passport as Gareth Southgate or whoever, they don't count for the purposes of this blog. And Ferguson's success slightly distorts matters, as that means that only two Britons have won the league in the past 26 years.
That's a pretty long time for a country's managers not to have any success in winning league titles. If we take Spain as a counter-example, Spanish managers have won the title 12 times, of which four Castilian-speaking managers have won it seven times between them, with two Catalans and one Basque taking the rest.
Spain is a good example here, because like the UK, it has much sharper cultural differences between its regions than other European countries. There may not be an official Catalan or Basque or Galician national team, but those areas consider themselves separate, not least because of language, to a degree that you wouldn't find in Germany or Italy, or indeed even the UK itself.
Italy, by the way, has the opposite problem. The majority of managers are Italian, and there was a point this season where all 20 teams were managed by Italians. The last foreigner to win the title there was Jose Mourinho, with Inter, and each season since then has crowned either Antonio Conte or Max Allegri as the winning manager.
But back to England. The popularity of hiring English, or more generally British, managers has collapsed since the 90s. Any analysis of why that should be is likely to be incomplete, so let me attempt it anyway, so I can have it picked apart by people smarter than me.
The main cause is probably the division between the elite clubs in England and the rest - the ones who fall between seventh and seventeenth place. As the gap has widened between the buying power of Chelsea or Manchester City on the one hand, and Watford or Everton on the other, the bigger clubs have set their sights on larger prizes than just the league. They aim for the Champions League. And if no English manager has won the Premier League, certainly no English manager has won the Champions League during the period, from 2005 to 2012, when English sides dominated by getting to the final almost every year.
So the first strike against English managers is that they aren't proven Champions League winners. The next point is that they aren't proven trophy-winners of any sort, or at least any sort that matters to a top-flight team's owner. The likes of Eddie Howe (Bournemouth), Sean Dyche (Burnley) or Neil Warnock (Cardiff City) may have won second division trophies and steered their clubs to promotion into the Premier League, but they've won no other trophies of note, certainly not during their tenures in the top flight.
In fact, the only English manager currently in the EPL to have won any trophies at all is Roy Hodgson, at Crystal Palace, who's won an impressive eight top-flight leagues abroad, and two national cups in other countries. And in fairness he had a crack at a top EPL team, when he managed Liverpool, but that wasn't what you'd call a total success.
You could say that this reluctance to hire English managers is also down to the fact that their placing each season means they can't even realistically plan to win trophies. Some teams place high enough to participate in the Champions League or the Europa League, while others do badly enough that they drop into the Championship, but for those teams ranked 7 to 17, there's nothing to play for after a certain point. The winners of the league tend to emerge fairly early, and so do the candidates for relegation, so everyone else can basically coast.
An extreme example is last season's Burnley team, which got as high as seventh at one point and then embarked on a losing streak of something like 11 games, which saw their position dip not at all. If all a manager has to do is coast and avoid the kind of catastrophe that sees them relegated, that doesn't exactly indicate ground-breaking tactical nous.
The one example of someone who tried to bridge the gap is Everton's David Moyes (Scottish), who was handpicked by Alex Ferguson to take over at Manchester United in 2013. He was anointed on the basis of strong performances by Everton in the preceding years, which saw them nearly reach the Champions League. But Moyes's style proved unsuited to United's, and in a lot of ways the club has still not recovered from the tailspin caused by his 10 months in charge. Nor has his own reputation recovered quickly - he had shitty spells at Real Sociedad in Spain, and at Sunderland (which in recent years has become the graveyard of many a manager's career), before rescuing himself somewhat by keeping West Ham from being relegated last season.
You could argue that winning a European trophy would be a good way for an English manager to make a mark, and you might be right. Except that again, you run into the problem of the gap between the richest clubs and the middle class. The example here is Burnley this season. After last season's heroics they qualified for the Europa League, but because those games take place on a Thursday night, and typically require longer trips than Champions League away legs, the players have less time to recover. And Burnley's results have shown that. They currently sit 16th, on 22 points, with a -20 goal difference.
And to be fair, playing in the Champions League is already plenty tough for the richest clubs, which can afford larger squads to rotate in and out for those types of matches. What hope do smaller, less well-off clubs like Burnley have?
Let me leave you with a thought on how to resurrect the English manager, though. There was a time when English managers (and players) would crop up abroad and do exciting things out there. Terry Venables won La Liga with Barcelona in 1984-85, and Welshman John Toshack won it with Real Madrid five seasons later. Venables later led the English national team to the semi-finals in Euro 96, on home soil, making him one of the most successful national managers since 1966. Bobby Robson also had spells abroad, in Spain and Portugal and the Netherlands, and also led England to the semi-finals in the 1990 World Cup.
There may not actually be a correlation there, but it's worth exploring. More English managers should take postings abroad, so they can learn what's happening in other leagues and bring it back to England. Other countries' coaches have been introducing innovations to the EPL, so why shouldn't the English? There's a little promise here, as young English players like Jadon Sancho are suddenly becoming in vogue in Germany - if that continues, they could eventually become the managers who land elite jobs in England by having won big in Europe.
Sunday, 13 January 2019
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse Is a Damn Delight
It's been a week since I managed to hoodwink my dad into going to see Into the Spider-Verse, and if he hated it, I'm happy to say that it fulfilled all my expectations, and on top of that was a great exploration of decades of Spider-Man history. Perhaps unsurprisingly, since they share some behind the scenes folk, it's up there for me with Lego Batman as a humorous but expansive take on a superhero's mythos.
I think the last time I regularly read new Spider-Man comics was around 2000 or 2001, when J Michael Straczynski was writing the character (pretty damn well, as I recall) and 9/11 happened. So I've missed out on a whole hell of a lot of continuity, not least the idea that there might be a bunch of different Spider-folk running around.
I had an idea of Miles Morales, of course, and of Spider-Gwen, so it was nice getting acquainted with those characters properly. And it was cool to see other takes, including Nicolas Cage's wonderful portrayal of Spider-Man Noir. I happen to love alternate versions of characters, especially from different time periods, so that really made me want to check out the Noir stories.
Not only that, the animation was really well-done, to the point that it looked like rotoscoping at points. Though my one complaint was that some stuff out of the main focus of most shots (and sometimes within the main focus) was weirdly doubled, as if it was meant to be a 3D movie. I kept having to check the other viewers with me in the theater to see if they were wearing those special glasses.
But to get back to the Lego Batman comparison: the thing I loved about that movie was that all 80 or so years of Batman's continuity were fair game, and the filmmakers made reference to lots of the most important parts of that continuity.
Into the Spider-Verse did something similar, though it told a more straight-forwardly serious story, which also meant that it had to keep its references relevant to the story (except for the post-credits scene). That generally worked, even when they threw in references to Spider-Man 3 and Tobey Maguire's dance moves.
But overall, it showed that the animated versions of comic book movies are light years ahead of the live action versions in terms of inventiveness, humor and fan service (if that's not a dirty word). Lego Batman, Teen Titans Go to the Movies, and Into the Spider-Verse are able to do a lot more with the characters than The Dark Knight or Spider-Man: Homecoming, because the expectations are probably lower and the studio probably expects fewer people to go see them. So they can throw in stuff like Stan Lee cameos (yep, even in Teen Titans), references to Earth-616 (which I've only recently learned is the standard Earth of Marvel continuity) and dumb jokes that really only appeal to comic book geeks like me.
So it was a really fun movie, a really beautifully shot movie, and if you haven't seen it yet you should check it out. Fandom may be at a level of toxicity where you can't give Miles Morales a live-action movie starring Donald Glover, but this is somehow better, because the filmmakers can use a bigger canvas to tell their story. And I'm looking forward to seeing what's next, whether for these animators or for these characters.
I think the last time I regularly read new Spider-Man comics was around 2000 or 2001, when J Michael Straczynski was writing the character (pretty damn well, as I recall) and 9/11 happened. So I've missed out on a whole hell of a lot of continuity, not least the idea that there might be a bunch of different Spider-folk running around.
I had an idea of Miles Morales, of course, and of Spider-Gwen, so it was nice getting acquainted with those characters properly. And it was cool to see other takes, including Nicolas Cage's wonderful portrayal of Spider-Man Noir. I happen to love alternate versions of characters, especially from different time periods, so that really made me want to check out the Noir stories.
Not only that, the animation was really well-done, to the point that it looked like rotoscoping at points. Though my one complaint was that some stuff out of the main focus of most shots (and sometimes within the main focus) was weirdly doubled, as if it was meant to be a 3D movie. I kept having to check the other viewers with me in the theater to see if they were wearing those special glasses.
But to get back to the Lego Batman comparison: the thing I loved about that movie was that all 80 or so years of Batman's continuity were fair game, and the filmmakers made reference to lots of the most important parts of that continuity.
Into the Spider-Verse did something similar, though it told a more straight-forwardly serious story, which also meant that it had to keep its references relevant to the story (except for the post-credits scene). That generally worked, even when they threw in references to Spider-Man 3 and Tobey Maguire's dance moves.
But overall, it showed that the animated versions of comic book movies are light years ahead of the live action versions in terms of inventiveness, humor and fan service (if that's not a dirty word). Lego Batman, Teen Titans Go to the Movies, and Into the Spider-Verse are able to do a lot more with the characters than The Dark Knight or Spider-Man: Homecoming, because the expectations are probably lower and the studio probably expects fewer people to go see them. So they can throw in stuff like Stan Lee cameos (yep, even in Teen Titans), references to Earth-616 (which I've only recently learned is the standard Earth of Marvel continuity) and dumb jokes that really only appeal to comic book geeks like me.
So it was a really fun movie, a really beautifully shot movie, and if you haven't seen it yet you should check it out. Fandom may be at a level of toxicity where you can't give Miles Morales a live-action movie starring Donald Glover, but this is somehow better, because the filmmakers can use a bigger canvas to tell their story. And I'm looking forward to seeing what's next, whether for these animators or for these characters.
Sunday, 30 December 2018
Making Manchester United Again
#sorrynotsorry
I wanted to write this post a week or so ago, when Manchester United put us all out of our collective misery and fired Jose Mourinho, but now that we've seen how United's done under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as interim manager, I have a little more information to work with. And after watching them demolish Bournemouth this morning, it's fair to say that the change in management has perked the team up significantly.
I've long been ambivalent about Mourinho. He obviously led Chelsea to their greatest period of success back in the last decade, and before that, at Porto, claimed the last Champions League title for a team outside the Big Four countries in 2004. But his teams are frequently boring, and he's long had a knack for making great players look ordinary. Add to that his tendency to flame out in his third season at any club, and he looks more like an expensive gamble than a real option for a club to regain its former glory.
And maybe it's only that I've paid a lot more attention to him the past few years, because I've been playing Fantasy Premier League during that time, but he's also seemed worse this time around. His first season at United doesn't bring up any particular memories, but last season he kicked up his feuds with his own players, such that it was surprising to see how well Paul Pogba played in winning the World Cup this summer. And the start of this season saw him kick that feuding into high gear, even stripping Pogba of the captaincy and benching him completely for the last couple of games before he got the sack.
But then he was gone. The most mystifying thing for me was how much I cared - Manchester United has been one of the teams I've most loved to hate since about 1999, when they knocked Juventus out of the Champions League and then snatched it dramatically in the last five minutes of the final against Bayern Munich. Yet, oddly, seeing Mourinho go filled me with a weird excitement, a need to see what happened next and whether it meant United would finally challenge for the title again.
(Although there was also a perverse desire to see just how bad things could get - at some point would even United get relegated?)
That excitement rose when they announced that they'd be hiring Solskjaer as their interim manager for the rest of the season. Solskjaer obviously is the guy who scored the winning goal in that 1999 Champions League final, and despite not being associated with the club in the same way as David Beckham, Gary Neville, Ryan Giggs or Paul Scholes, is legitimately a club legend. He's even 45, the exact same age as Alex Ferguson when he took over in 1986, though I'll admit that's stretching analogies a bit too far - Ferguson had already had a certain amount of success as a manager in Scotland before getting the United job, whereas Solskjaer's previous managerial experience in the Premier League was an ill-starred stint where he took Cardiff City down to relegation.
And yet, as of today he's now overseen three successive wins in his first three games, something only Matt Busby and Jose Mourinho himself achieved. The other number people have been throwing around is the five goals his United team scored against Cardiff in his first game in charge - since that was the first time United had scored five in one match since Ferguson's last game in charge in 2013.
Generally it's not good to draw too many conclusions from this run, since these three matches have all been against decidedly weaker teams, two of whom were promoted in the last two years, and all of whom are in decidedly poor runs of form at the moment. In addition, Man United line up next against Newcastle United, who are also in their own difficulties at the moment, so Solskjaer's skills won't be properly tested against a top 6 side (Spurs) until 13 January.
But I come once again to the game I was watching this morning. United looked fluid, free-flowing, deadly - stringing together passes and rushing into danger areas where they were well placed to score against Bournemouth. Pogba was particularly deadly, pulling back the first two goals and creating another later on. Whatever Solskjaer's skills as a coach or the hands-on-ness of his approach, the evidence is right there in performances against opposition that the Mourinho team would have struggled against. It's also hard not to assume that he's trying to stamp on this United team the style of football he learned under Ferguson.
The other question is what happens at the end of the season. If Solskjaer continues like this, he'll surely be in the running for the job on a permanent basis, with Spurs manager Mauricio Pochettino the other likely candidate (unless he gets lured away to Real Madrid, who are also looking for a permanent coach but haven't made as charmed an appointment). It'd be interesting to see, if Solskjaer does get the job, what he'll be able to make of it, and whether this really does herald a change in fortunes for the team, rather than a dead-cat bounce.
This all brings us back to the question of why I care so much. As I mentioned, United has long been the team I loved to hate. They almost always got the players that helped put them head and shoulders above the competition, including a very young Cristiano Ronaldo, and they had the swagger and arrogance that came with dominating the game throughout the 1990s.
But I suspect my current nostalgia for the 90s is what's behind my excitement - Solskjaer is part of the team that I learned about when I first got into football, which is also when the UK in general, and Manchester in particular, was the cultural epicenter of everything I was into. Seeing them come back into that kind of form would be a nice throwback to days that were, if not happier, then not as marked by darkness (as evidenced by the title I came up with for this post).
When United was winning everything in sight, we were still years off from invasions of Iraq, wars on terror and rising xenophobia. Not to mention that the UK didn't seem likely to ditch the EU anytime soon, even if they did complain about it a whole lot.
In any case, it'll be fun to watch how United develops under Solskjaer. In particular, it'll be interesting to see whether Pogba's run of form continues, given the promise that attached itself to him with his £89 million price tag when United bought him from Juventus (and, um, when he won the fucking World Cup). United may not have the best team, but in Pogba it may have the best player, Mohamed Salah notwithstanding.
So for the first time in twenty years, and with shame in my heart, I think I may find myself rooting for Manchester United soon...
I wanted to write this post a week or so ago, when Manchester United put us all out of our collective misery and fired Jose Mourinho, but now that we've seen how United's done under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as interim manager, I have a little more information to work with. And after watching them demolish Bournemouth this morning, it's fair to say that the change in management has perked the team up significantly.
I've long been ambivalent about Mourinho. He obviously led Chelsea to their greatest period of success back in the last decade, and before that, at Porto, claimed the last Champions League title for a team outside the Big Four countries in 2004. But his teams are frequently boring, and he's long had a knack for making great players look ordinary. Add to that his tendency to flame out in his third season at any club, and he looks more like an expensive gamble than a real option for a club to regain its former glory.
And maybe it's only that I've paid a lot more attention to him the past few years, because I've been playing Fantasy Premier League during that time, but he's also seemed worse this time around. His first season at United doesn't bring up any particular memories, but last season he kicked up his feuds with his own players, such that it was surprising to see how well Paul Pogba played in winning the World Cup this summer. And the start of this season saw him kick that feuding into high gear, even stripping Pogba of the captaincy and benching him completely for the last couple of games before he got the sack.
But then he was gone. The most mystifying thing for me was how much I cared - Manchester United has been one of the teams I've most loved to hate since about 1999, when they knocked Juventus out of the Champions League and then snatched it dramatically in the last five minutes of the final against Bayern Munich. Yet, oddly, seeing Mourinho go filled me with a weird excitement, a need to see what happened next and whether it meant United would finally challenge for the title again.
(Although there was also a perverse desire to see just how bad things could get - at some point would even United get relegated?)
That excitement rose when they announced that they'd be hiring Solskjaer as their interim manager for the rest of the season. Solskjaer obviously is the guy who scored the winning goal in that 1999 Champions League final, and despite not being associated with the club in the same way as David Beckham, Gary Neville, Ryan Giggs or Paul Scholes, is legitimately a club legend. He's even 45, the exact same age as Alex Ferguson when he took over in 1986, though I'll admit that's stretching analogies a bit too far - Ferguson had already had a certain amount of success as a manager in Scotland before getting the United job, whereas Solskjaer's previous managerial experience in the Premier League was an ill-starred stint where he took Cardiff City down to relegation.
And yet, as of today he's now overseen three successive wins in his first three games, something only Matt Busby and Jose Mourinho himself achieved. The other number people have been throwing around is the five goals his United team scored against Cardiff in his first game in charge - since that was the first time United had scored five in one match since Ferguson's last game in charge in 2013.
Generally it's not good to draw too many conclusions from this run, since these three matches have all been against decidedly weaker teams, two of whom were promoted in the last two years, and all of whom are in decidedly poor runs of form at the moment. In addition, Man United line up next against Newcastle United, who are also in their own difficulties at the moment, so Solskjaer's skills won't be properly tested against a top 6 side (Spurs) until 13 January.
But I come once again to the game I was watching this morning. United looked fluid, free-flowing, deadly - stringing together passes and rushing into danger areas where they were well placed to score against Bournemouth. Pogba was particularly deadly, pulling back the first two goals and creating another later on. Whatever Solskjaer's skills as a coach or the hands-on-ness of his approach, the evidence is right there in performances against opposition that the Mourinho team would have struggled against. It's also hard not to assume that he's trying to stamp on this United team the style of football he learned under Ferguson.
The other question is what happens at the end of the season. If Solskjaer continues like this, he'll surely be in the running for the job on a permanent basis, with Spurs manager Mauricio Pochettino the other likely candidate (unless he gets lured away to Real Madrid, who are also looking for a permanent coach but haven't made as charmed an appointment). It'd be interesting to see, if Solskjaer does get the job, what he'll be able to make of it, and whether this really does herald a change in fortunes for the team, rather than a dead-cat bounce.
This all brings us back to the question of why I care so much. As I mentioned, United has long been the team I loved to hate. They almost always got the players that helped put them head and shoulders above the competition, including a very young Cristiano Ronaldo, and they had the swagger and arrogance that came with dominating the game throughout the 1990s.
But I suspect my current nostalgia for the 90s is what's behind my excitement - Solskjaer is part of the team that I learned about when I first got into football, which is also when the UK in general, and Manchester in particular, was the cultural epicenter of everything I was into. Seeing them come back into that kind of form would be a nice throwback to days that were, if not happier, then not as marked by darkness (as evidenced by the title I came up with for this post).
When United was winning everything in sight, we were still years off from invasions of Iraq, wars on terror and rising xenophobia. Not to mention that the UK didn't seem likely to ditch the EU anytime soon, even if they did complain about it a whole lot.
In any case, it'll be fun to watch how United develops under Solskjaer. In particular, it'll be interesting to see whether Pogba's run of form continues, given the promise that attached itself to him with his £89 million price tag when United bought him from Juventus (and, um, when he won the fucking World Cup). United may not have the best team, but in Pogba it may have the best player, Mohamed Salah notwithstanding.
So for the first time in twenty years, and with shame in my heart, I think I may find myself rooting for Manchester United soon...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)