Just learned today that Scott Walker, the former singer of the Walker Brothers and architect of the most challenging avant garden pop I have, passed away at the age of 76.
I first learned about Walker from a muso friend, who gave me a look of withering disdain in 2003 or 2004 when he told me that this Walker guy had produced Pulp's latest album, and I said I didn't know who he was.
How could you blame me, though? As I discovered a year or so later, when I wandered into a New York record store and asked about Scott Walker's albums, the guy wasn't well known at all in the US in those days. Which is ironic because he was American, though he'd made his name as a 60s boy band icon, and then again as a critical darling in the 1980s for the succession of challenging albums that started with Climate of Hunter. I soon started reading Pitchfork's 100 albums lists, and Walker was all over those (as much as you could be releasing an album only every 11 years, that is).
And as I got more familiar with the history of British rock, I started seeing him get name-dropped again and again. He may not appear in official histories of the Beatles or the Rolling Stones, but Scott Walker was creating music, both with the Walker Brothers and on his own, that would be just as influential to the Britpop acts I would become obsessed with in high school.
When I got back to London in 2006, about the time Walker released his album The Drift, I caught a wave of interest in him, and so I picked up the essentials: Scott 1 through 4, and a greatest hits album featuring some of his best solo and Walker Brothers material. I also watched the shit out of a documentary about him and the recording of the Drift, called 30 Century Man. My flatmates at the time were bemused by this slavish attention to an artist they'd never heard of, but I've never shaken my love for Walker since.
I did pick up the challenging albums later, of course - I got the Drift a couple of years later, and Bish Bosh a few years after that, and for Christmas recently I got Climate of Hunter and Tilt. And more awesomely, in 2008 I saw Drifting and Tilting, a concert of Walker's music from those albums, played at the Barbican by an orchestra and sung by luminaries such as Blur's Damon Albarn and Pulp's Jarvis Cocker.
The music was impressive, for all its challenging nature, because it was just as much performance art piece as rock concert. Just as in the recording of the Drift, for the song Clara (about Mussolini's mistress Clara Petacci) the musicians wheeled out a side of pork onto the stage and had a boxer punch it to achieve the percussion sound from the album.
And of course, what was most impressive was turning round idly at one point during the concert and seeing the great man, Scott Walker himself, sitting at the production boards. That's as close as you could get to a live performance by him.
Thinking about him today, what struck me was that I got into his music at a very dark time for me personally. 2008 was a sucky year, full of job strife, discord with flatmates, bad health and existential angst over my dating life (even more than now, if you can believe it). I was so alone and afraid that I found myself having to go find a psychoanalyst, whom I saw for a year afterward.
Scott 1 through 4 played on fairly continuous loops during those days. "Two Weeks Since You've Gone", a mournful ballad from Scott 3, was what I was listening to one night as I lay in bed unable to sleep from the depression and the anxiety caused by my poor physical health (I was eating like shit and not exercising, and getting more depressed because of it). The string sections perfectly captured my feelings that dark night, and I remember being pleasantly weirded out not long after when I heard something similar-sounding in a Stella Artois commercial - a synchronicity that made sense because Belgian chansonnier Jacques Brel was a huge influence on Scott Walker.
It's been a fairly constant Scott Walker "moment" since he released the Drift, and since that documentary came out about him. Artist after artist has fallen over themselves in the last decade to talk about his influence on them, to the point that the frontman of the Arctic Monkeys even released his own Walker-influenced album, as the Last Shadow Puppets, to explore that influence on his music. It may not be a great album, but the words "influenced by Scott Walker" were enough to get me to plunk down money for it.
The Guardian ran the obituary today, of course, along with a number of testimonials from fans and collaborators. Some never met him, and some worked very closely with him, but all spoke movingly about him.
But the thing that sticks with me right now is a scene from the documentary, when the filmmakers interview Angela Morley (previously known as Wally Stott before undergoing gender reassignment surgery). Morley is telling about her experiences working with Walker, and they play Montague Terrace (In Blue) for her. And as the strings swell, and she hears again the music she helped commit to tape, she tears up - probably the most important moment in a movie aiming to pin down why exactly this one artist, who most people have never heard of, was so revered.
I'm just glad I did get to find out about him, before he passed. And that I got to see him, in real life, sharing the music he wrote, all those years ago.
Monday, 25 March 2019
Sunday, 17 March 2019
David Tennant Does a Podcast with...
It feels like a lot of recent blog posts have been about British stuff, and a venerable theme here on my blog is about what podcasts I'm listening to, so I thought I'd merge the two things together and talk about a new one I've only started listening to this past weekend: David Tennant Does A Podcast With...
It's new both in the sense that I only just discovered it, and that he's only been doing it for a couple of months. I think the first I heard about it was on Twitter, when he congratulated his former costar Olivia Colman for her Academy Award, and she linked back to the tweet about the episode she did of his show. So I followed the various tweets and links back to the source, and then discovered on the Apple Podcasts app that he's been interviewing a number of interesting folks since he started it.
In addition to Olivia Colman, he talked to his other Broadchurch costar (and Doctor Who successor) Jodie Whittaker, plus Whoopi Goldberg, Ian McKellen and (the one that, perversely, convinced me to just go ahead and download them all) former UK prime minister Gordon Brown, of all people.
Broadchurch, of course, was the initial hook for me listening to DT's show. That was my favorite new discovery of the last few months, even despite its sometimes overwrought acting and the sort of weird West Country accents Colman and Whittaker were putting on for their characters. And for those two episodes, I wasn't disappointed - not that they talked a lot about the show, but I liked hearing how Whittaker got the call-up to audition for the part of the Doctor (Broadchurch showrunner Chris Chibnall is now showrunning Doctor Who).
It also ties into something I wrote about a couple of years ago, when David Bowie and Alan Rickman (and so many others) passed away more or less suddenly. Reading Rickman's obituaries I was struck by the sense of the whole community of British actors, and his place in it - and this is a feeling that gets reinforced whenever I watch a British show or movie and find myself playing "spot the familiar face".
More than anything, though, what I responded to in the Olivia Colman and Jodie Whittaker episodes was the obvious joy they all took in each other's company. They may have worked together on one or two things, but the sense of a bunch of peers who know one another's careers and enjoy each other's work is fun to listen to.
He obviously doesn't have the same connection with Whoopi Goldberg or Ian McKellen, but David Tennant's a good enough host that the sense of pros talking shop really comes through, in the best way. Goldberg and McKellen have all this experience, but Tennant's an accomplished actor in his own right, so he knows what they're talking about in a way that some of the other podcast hosts I listen to, who aren't long-time actors, may not be able to do as well.
In a lot of ways, DTDAPW reminds me of the best stretches of the Nerdist Podcast (which I no longer listen to, for non-podcast reasons). Like that show, the guests are a good mix of Tennant's friends and peers, and Tennant shows a lot of enthusiasm for joking, chatting and turns out to be a good interviewer.
I've said before that I'm not much of a fan of Doctor Who, to the point that I have to remember to write "Doctor" out in full, but I'll be happy if he gets more of his former costars or even the other Doctors (Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi, or even Christopher Ecclestone) on the show. And I'll be happy to hear from folks who appeared with him in Jessica Jones, the only other show I've seen him in.
And yeah, circling back to that thing about Gordon Brown: that was the thing, as I said, that brought me on board. Brown has always fascinated me, because he was so clearly always going to be the nearly man, following a decade or so of Tony Blair's premiership. There were some less savory things I heard about him, like his refusal to concede the 2010 election until it was settled, and the fact that he was a bit of a martinet to his staff. But at the same time, he was being lauded for his response to the financial crisis (though a few of my friends blamed him for creating it).
Given everything that's happened since, it's hard not to think that if he could have just won a tiny bit more of the electorate, Britain would be such a different place now. So I really do want to hear what he has to say for himself.
The life of an actor is pretty hectic, so I'm expecting that there'll come a time when DT's got to put it on hiatus while he works on something else (something that pays!). But while he's got the bandwidth for it, I'll be ready to listen to whatever guest he's got.
It's new both in the sense that I only just discovered it, and that he's only been doing it for a couple of months. I think the first I heard about it was on Twitter, when he congratulated his former costar Olivia Colman for her Academy Award, and she linked back to the tweet about the episode she did of his show. So I followed the various tweets and links back to the source, and then discovered on the Apple Podcasts app that he's been interviewing a number of interesting folks since he started it.
In addition to Olivia Colman, he talked to his other Broadchurch costar (and Doctor Who successor) Jodie Whittaker, plus Whoopi Goldberg, Ian McKellen and (the one that, perversely, convinced me to just go ahead and download them all) former UK prime minister Gordon Brown, of all people.
Broadchurch, of course, was the initial hook for me listening to DT's show. That was my favorite new discovery of the last few months, even despite its sometimes overwrought acting and the sort of weird West Country accents Colman and Whittaker were putting on for their characters. And for those two episodes, I wasn't disappointed - not that they talked a lot about the show, but I liked hearing how Whittaker got the call-up to audition for the part of the Doctor (Broadchurch showrunner Chris Chibnall is now showrunning Doctor Who).
It also ties into something I wrote about a couple of years ago, when David Bowie and Alan Rickman (and so many others) passed away more or less suddenly. Reading Rickman's obituaries I was struck by the sense of the whole community of British actors, and his place in it - and this is a feeling that gets reinforced whenever I watch a British show or movie and find myself playing "spot the familiar face".
More than anything, though, what I responded to in the Olivia Colman and Jodie Whittaker episodes was the obvious joy they all took in each other's company. They may have worked together on one or two things, but the sense of a bunch of peers who know one another's careers and enjoy each other's work is fun to listen to.
He obviously doesn't have the same connection with Whoopi Goldberg or Ian McKellen, but David Tennant's a good enough host that the sense of pros talking shop really comes through, in the best way. Goldberg and McKellen have all this experience, but Tennant's an accomplished actor in his own right, so he knows what they're talking about in a way that some of the other podcast hosts I listen to, who aren't long-time actors, may not be able to do as well.
In a lot of ways, DTDAPW reminds me of the best stretches of the Nerdist Podcast (which I no longer listen to, for non-podcast reasons). Like that show, the guests are a good mix of Tennant's friends and peers, and Tennant shows a lot of enthusiasm for joking, chatting and turns out to be a good interviewer.
I've said before that I'm not much of a fan of Doctor Who, to the point that I have to remember to write "Doctor" out in full, but I'll be happy if he gets more of his former costars or even the other Doctors (Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi, or even Christopher Ecclestone) on the show. And I'll be happy to hear from folks who appeared with him in Jessica Jones, the only other show I've seen him in.
And yeah, circling back to that thing about Gordon Brown: that was the thing, as I said, that brought me on board. Brown has always fascinated me, because he was so clearly always going to be the nearly man, following a decade or so of Tony Blair's premiership. There were some less savory things I heard about him, like his refusal to concede the 2010 election until it was settled, and the fact that he was a bit of a martinet to his staff. But at the same time, he was being lauded for his response to the financial crisis (though a few of my friends blamed him for creating it
Given everything that's happened since, it's hard not to think that if he could have just won a tiny bit more of the electorate, Britain would be such a different place now. So I really do want to hear what he has to say for himself.
The life of an actor is pretty hectic, so I'm expecting that there'll come a time when DT's got to put it on hiatus while he works on something else (something that pays!). But while he's got the bandwidth for it, I'll be ready to listen to whatever guest he's got.
Sunday, 10 March 2019
Manhood and Manliness: Me vs. Chris Pratt in Jurassic World
What does being manly or masculine entail?
It's a thing I've been batting around in my mind for a while, but watching Jurassic Kingdom: Fallen World last night (or at least part of it) crystallized some of this thinking for me. Back in 2015 I watched the original Jurassic World, and while I didn't find any real fault with its leads, Bryce Dallas Howard and Chris Pratt, I mused at the time that it would have been neat if the roles had been reversed: have her be the two-fisted dino-wrangling badass, and have him be the administrator who needs to learn how to love.
It's been so long since I saw the first installment that I don't remember, but in Fallen Kingdom they really drive home that Chris Pratt's character is a MAN, man. When he first appears, he's building his own house, for god's sake, and then bragging to the nerdy systems analyst guy that he rides motorcycles and wrangles dinosaurs.
But again, I'm not criticizing the portrayal, or even the idea that men might do stuff like that. I'm interested in my own eye-rolling reaction to it, and the idea that I should be rolling my eyes at it.
Somewhere along the line, in the stew of self-toxic ideas that I've taken on and internalized, is the idea that I'm a different kind of masculine than guys like Chris Pratt's character, and that the types are both diametrically opposed and mutually exclusive. Beyond that, it's worth being clear that "different" also means "inferior" - as I said, it's a toxic stew of self-limiting beliefs, and so it's the idea that I'm less manly/masculine than dudes who put out oil fires and have cheerleader threesomes.
The other day I was telling someone about a bit that I saw once from British comedian Michael McIntyre. He was talking about shopping with his wife, and meeting a super-camp shop attendant. His reaction, in the bit, was to lower his voice and act all gruff and manly, when really what he wanted to do was camp it up along with the shop attendant. I joked to my friend that I could relate to this, but thinking about it today, I started questioning that.
Or rather, I can relate to wanting to just be myself, for whatever that means, and not having to play at seeming like one thing or another. But being myself doesn't mean being particularly gruff or camp - I'd rather just be as taciturn and surly as I am in any situation...
Another place that questioned different types of masculinity/maleness was the first season of True Detective. The AV Club's recaps contrasted Woody Harrelson's character's traditional male anti-hero behaviors (drinking, adultery, corruption) with those of Matthew McConaughey's character, who's full of mysterious utterances and smirks about the rubes surrounding him. The reviewer pointed out Cohle's notebook and the way he collected evidence in it as a particularly male way of doing it, which I found interesting.
Without wanting to add to the self-criticism, and aware that I'm in danger of rambling out of control, I guess the answer (as always) is... not to worry about this stuff so much? On one level, perhaps the most important lesson I've learned is not to adjust my behavior or thinking to what I think people want from me. On another, worrying about whether I'm being the "right" kind of manly, or the "right" kind of manly for me, is just a waste of my mental resources: I'll appeal to some people, and I won't appeal to others. Real men, whether they're Chris Pratt, Matthew McConaughey or Michael McIntyre, probably have better things to worry about.
It's a thing I've been batting around in my mind for a while, but watching Jurassic Kingdom: Fallen World last night (or at least part of it) crystallized some of this thinking for me. Back in 2015 I watched the original Jurassic World, and while I didn't find any real fault with its leads, Bryce Dallas Howard and Chris Pratt, I mused at the time that it would have been neat if the roles had been reversed: have her be the two-fisted dino-wrangling badass, and have him be the administrator who needs to learn how to love.
It's been so long since I saw the first installment that I don't remember, but in Fallen Kingdom they really drive home that Chris Pratt's character is a MAN, man. When he first appears, he's building his own house, for god's sake, and then bragging to the nerdy systems analyst guy that he rides motorcycles and wrangles dinosaurs.
But again, I'm not criticizing the portrayal, or even the idea that men might do stuff like that. I'm interested in my own eye-rolling reaction to it, and the idea that I should be rolling my eyes at it.
Somewhere along the line, in the stew of self-toxic ideas that I've taken on and internalized, is the idea that I'm a different kind of masculine than guys like Chris Pratt's character, and that the types are both diametrically opposed and mutually exclusive. Beyond that, it's worth being clear that "different" also means "inferior" - as I said, it's a toxic stew of self-limiting beliefs, and so it's the idea that I'm less manly/masculine than dudes who put out oil fires and have cheerleader threesomes.
The other day I was telling someone about a bit that I saw once from British comedian Michael McIntyre. He was talking about shopping with his wife, and meeting a super-camp shop attendant. His reaction, in the bit, was to lower his voice and act all gruff and manly, when really what he wanted to do was camp it up along with the shop attendant. I joked to my friend that I could relate to this, but thinking about it today, I started questioning that.
Or rather, I can relate to wanting to just be myself, for whatever that means, and not having to play at seeming like one thing or another. But being myself doesn't mean being particularly gruff or camp - I'd rather just be as taciturn and surly as I am in any situation...
Another place that questioned different types of masculinity/maleness was the first season of True Detective. The AV Club's recaps contrasted Woody Harrelson's character's traditional male anti-hero behaviors (drinking, adultery, corruption) with those of Matthew McConaughey's character, who's full of mysterious utterances and smirks about the rubes surrounding him. The reviewer pointed out Cohle's notebook and the way he collected evidence in it as a particularly male way of doing it, which I found interesting.
Without wanting to add to the self-criticism, and aware that I'm in danger of rambling out of control, I guess the answer (as always) is... not to worry about this stuff so much? On one level, perhaps the most important lesson I've learned is not to adjust my behavior or thinking to what I think people want from me. On another, worrying about whether I'm being the "right" kind of manly, or the "right" kind of manly for me, is just a waste of my mental resources: I'll appeal to some people, and I won't appeal to others. Real men, whether they're Chris Pratt, Matthew McConaughey or Michael McIntyre, probably have better things to worry about.
Sunday, 3 March 2019
In Praise of the Golazzo Podcast
Over a year ago I found myself faced with an impossible conundrum. James Richardson had just announced his departure from the Guardian's Football Weekly podcast, which he'd been hosting since around 2006, to join a new company called Muddy Knees Media and host a new show, the Totally Football Show.
The question was, did I have time for two podcasts each week, both dropping on the same day each week, and which both talked about the same thing? Totally Football had James and a number of former Guardian writers, like Raphael Hönigstein and James Horncastle, but Football Weekly had Barry Glendenning's world-weary cynicism, and how could you do better than that? My choice was sealed when Barry recited the theme song to the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air during the Guardian's coverage of the 2018 World Cup, and I've since left Totally Football as the backup or a supplement to when huge things happen in the Premier League.
But then I started to hear rumors of a new podcast from Muddy Knees Media. It was called Golazzo, and it was about Italian football. There was an interview with Nathaniel Chalobah, following his time playing in Italy, and when I listened to that I started to hear about other topics they were taking on.
So I downloaded one episode, and then another, and pretty soon Golazzo had entered my weekly rotation as a must-listen show every Wednesday. This way I got my fix of James Richardson and his puns, as well as James Horncastle's knowledge of Italian football and Italo-American-accented journalist Gabriele Marcotti (who also happens to be a fellow Columbia J-School alum), while also learning more about the recent history of Serie A and getting a rundown of what's happening in the Italian league each week.
What makes it great to listen to is that when I was working in London last year I finally picked up John Foot's magisterial history of Italian football, Calcio, so I understood some of the broad strokes of the game in Italy. But whereas Calcio had necessarily to devote most of its pages to the farther history of Serie A, Golazzo relies mostly on stories and characters from the last 20 years or so of the Italian game - the days when Serie A was the most glamorous league in the world and James Richardson himself hosted the Football Italia show for Channel 4.
The other thing that makes stories from the 90s and 00s so appealing to me is that I was starting to pay attention to football at that time. I get to hear more about the players who were current then, from how they got their starts to what they did later on in their careers. I just missed Football Italia as it ended and a non-terrestrial channel got the Serie A rights, so ironically once I moved to the UK it became harder for me to keep up with the game in Italy.
And beyond that, it's just nice to hear people talking knowledgeably about my home country. It's not really a side of myself I get to express very often, given that I don't have any Italian friends here in the Bay Area, but I do like being Italian and having this side of my personality that has nothing to do with my daily life. Usually I only get this feeling, of being quite far away from my American life, when I'm out in Turin with my cousins, but lately I've been getting it from Golazzo, too.
I sometimes wonder if other immigrants feel this way about their home country and their adopted country - the way your life in one doesn't really impinge on your life in the other, but that things in your home country just pick up where you left off from the last time you were there. Certainly traveling through eight or nine time zones and then speaking a different language at the end of it helps in separating the two places.
Oddly the immigrant experience is not one I've thought about much as it relates to my own life. I'm the first to admit I'm Americanized as fuck, but as time passes I become more interested in how coming here from a different culture has affected my perception of being American, and my desire to be American. Though I think that desire was stoked more by my time living in Britain, where feeling Italian was paradoxically even farther off than it is here, in many ways.
In any case, that's where the pleasure of Golazzo lies for me: getting closer to my roots and my home country at a time when that feels quite far away. Long may it last, or as they same in some parts of Italy: cent'anni!
The question was, did I have time for two podcasts each week, both dropping on the same day each week, and which both talked about the same thing? Totally Football had James and a number of former Guardian writers, like Raphael Hönigstein and James Horncastle, but Football Weekly had Barry Glendenning's world-weary cynicism, and how could you do better than that? My choice was sealed when Barry recited the theme song to the Fresh Prince of Bel-Air during the Guardian's coverage of the 2018 World Cup, and I've since left Totally Football as the backup or a supplement to when huge things happen in the Premier League.
But then I started to hear rumors of a new podcast from Muddy Knees Media. It was called Golazzo, and it was about Italian football. There was an interview with Nathaniel Chalobah, following his time playing in Italy, and when I listened to that I started to hear about other topics they were taking on.
So I downloaded one episode, and then another, and pretty soon Golazzo had entered my weekly rotation as a must-listen show every Wednesday. This way I got my fix of James Richardson and his puns, as well as James Horncastle's knowledge of Italian football and Italo-American-accented journalist Gabriele Marcotti (who also happens to be a fellow Columbia J-School alum), while also learning more about the recent history of Serie A and getting a rundown of what's happening in the Italian league each week.
What makes it great to listen to is that when I was working in London last year I finally picked up John Foot's magisterial history of Italian football, Calcio, so I understood some of the broad strokes of the game in Italy. But whereas Calcio had necessarily to devote most of its pages to the farther history of Serie A, Golazzo relies mostly on stories and characters from the last 20 years or so of the Italian game - the days when Serie A was the most glamorous league in the world and James Richardson himself hosted the Football Italia show for Channel 4.
The other thing that makes stories from the 90s and 00s so appealing to me is that I was starting to pay attention to football at that time. I get to hear more about the players who were current then, from how they got their starts to what they did later on in their careers. I just missed Football Italia as it ended and a non-terrestrial channel got the Serie A rights, so ironically once I moved to the UK it became harder for me to keep up with the game in Italy.
And beyond that, it's just nice to hear people talking knowledgeably about my home country. It's not really a side of myself I get to express very often, given that I don't have any Italian friends here in the Bay Area, but I do like being Italian and having this side of my personality that has nothing to do with my daily life. Usually I only get this feeling, of being quite far away from my American life, when I'm out in Turin with my cousins, but lately I've been getting it from Golazzo, too.
I sometimes wonder if other immigrants feel this way about their home country and their adopted country - the way your life in one doesn't really impinge on your life in the other, but that things in your home country just pick up where you left off from the last time you were there. Certainly traveling through eight or nine time zones and then speaking a different language at the end of it helps in separating the two places.
Oddly the immigrant experience is not one I've thought about much as it relates to my own life. I'm the first to admit I'm Americanized as fuck, but as time passes I become more interested in how coming here from a different culture has affected my perception of being American, and my desire to be American. Though I think that desire was stoked more by my time living in Britain, where feeling Italian was paradoxically even farther off than it is here, in many ways.
In any case, that's where the pleasure of Golazzo lies for me: getting closer to my roots and my home country at a time when that feels quite far away. Long may it last, or as they same in some parts of Italy: cent'anni!
Sunday, 17 February 2019
It's Easy to Be a Saint in Paradise: Star Trek and American Foreign Policy
I've talked before about my love for the Mission Log Podcast, and I'm going to say a bit more about it today. I just spent part of the day listening to their episode from January on the Deep Space 9 double episode from the second season, The Maquis.
I've been looking forward to it for a while. Since they started doing DS9, frankly. And all because of this scene:
I didn't see that scene when it first aired in the 90s, because I wasn't watching DS9 yet. But when I did see it on my first attempt at watching the whole series back in 2006 or thereabouts, I locked onto it because it articulated how I'd always felt about DS9 in comparison with other Star Trek shows.
Now, I grew up with Trek. Some of my earliest memories are of catching TOS reruns when I was three or four years old. Old videotapes my parents recorded for me of other TV shows had commercials for TNG, which at that time was airing in first-run. And in the 90s I was basically catching between 15 and 20 hours of Trek, new and in reruns, during the period when I'd discovered DS9 and Voyager and after TNG had ended.
I didn't expect to love DS9 so much, but it felt like a good corrective to the increasingly sterile and safe atmosphere of TNG and Voyager. Where Captain Picard and Captain Janeway were running around lecturing aliens and their crews on the Prime Directive and on Federation ideals more generally, Commander (and then Captain) Sisko was dealing one singular mess, week after week and year after year. He didn't have the luxury of flying away.
In part because whenever he tried, problems would come find him. In first run the episodes I remember that spoke to this were the two-parter of Homefront and Paradise Lost, where the suspicion of the Dominion infiltrating Earth causes the Federation to freak out and come close to imposing martial law. Maybe it says something weird about me, but I loved the show more for showing us that the Federation had feet of clay as well. And that's what I took along when I rewatched those episodes in 2006 and again in 2016.
Now Mission Log co-host Ken Ray doesn't love those aspects of DS9 as much as I do. He stressed in the episode recapping The Maquis that he's not bothered so much by the sentiments of Sisko's speech, as the fact that Sisko's the one delivering it. And when he puts it that way, I can't help but agree a little - it's disheartening that the captain, the freaking guy in charge of the Federation presence on Deep Space 9, is the one who's frustrated with the Federation and its high-minded ideals.
But on the other hand, what I love about the speech remains, at least in how I've always read it. If Star Trek maps onto Cold War-era views of the world, in which the Federation represents the United States, then the thing I loved about DS9 the most was that it questioned those aspects of Trek. Because America's role as a force for good in the world is always worth questioning... though not worth dismissing out of hand, because there are genuinely positive parts of it, even if US foreign policy kept many parts of the world under brutal dictatorships for decades because we were afraid of those countries falling to communism.
The way I read that scene, with Admiral Nechayev ordering Sisko to talk to the Maquis and make them see reason, fits into this ideal that America could go into a country, tell them what to do, and everything would be fine, because it's America saying it. Our interventions abroad have frequently followed this pattern, and we've gone awfully wrong in a lot of cases because of it - Iraq being only the most recent example.
When Captain Sisko says people on Earth look out the window and see paradise, the writers mean that people in America see paradise out their windows (remember this was the 90s, when things weren't as fucked up as they are now - and no, that's not a dig at the current occupant of the White House, but at the conditions that brought him to power). But seeing that paradise out their windows, the people of Earth think that all problems around the world can be solved the same way they did it themselves.
This isn't any sort of argument that democracy or freedom only works for certain types of people. Russia, China, the Middle East, and so forth, would be better off if they weren't being run by autocrats and gangsters. But equally it's not enough to tell them to just implement democratic and free-market reforms, and everything will be fine - that's exactly what Russia did in the early 90s, and we're paying the price for it now.
Worse, Homefront and Paradise Lost show how brittle that veneer of paradise is at home. But it's worth noting that in those episodes good prevails precisely because Sisko and his allies hold to their ideals, the ideals of the Federation and of Star Trek generally, and because the antagonists are just as devoted to the Federation's ideals (at least as they see it). Which is perhaps an instructive example for us now - that as we stick true to our proper ideals of respect, diversity and freedom, and don't compromise, we can still win out, even if it'll be difficult.
And that's a message that Trek has been giving us since the 60s, with the Original Series.
I've been looking forward to it for a while. Since they started doing DS9, frankly. And all because of this scene:
I didn't see that scene when it first aired in the 90s, because I wasn't watching DS9 yet. But when I did see it on my first attempt at watching the whole series back in 2006 or thereabouts, I locked onto it because it articulated how I'd always felt about DS9 in comparison with other Star Trek shows.
Now, I grew up with Trek. Some of my earliest memories are of catching TOS reruns when I was three or four years old. Old videotapes my parents recorded for me of other TV shows had commercials for TNG, which at that time was airing in first-run. And in the 90s I was basically catching between 15 and 20 hours of Trek, new and in reruns, during the period when I'd discovered DS9 and Voyager and after TNG had ended.
I didn't expect to love DS9 so much, but it felt like a good corrective to the increasingly sterile and safe atmosphere of TNG and Voyager. Where Captain Picard and Captain Janeway were running around lecturing aliens and their crews on the Prime Directive and on Federation ideals more generally, Commander (and then Captain) Sisko was dealing one singular mess, week after week and year after year. He didn't have the luxury of flying away.
In part because whenever he tried, problems would come find him. In first run the episodes I remember that spoke to this were the two-parter of Homefront and Paradise Lost, where the suspicion of the Dominion infiltrating Earth causes the Federation to freak out and come close to imposing martial law. Maybe it says something weird about me, but I loved the show more for showing us that the Federation had feet of clay as well. And that's what I took along when I rewatched those episodes in 2006 and again in 2016.
Now Mission Log co-host Ken Ray doesn't love those aspects of DS9 as much as I do. He stressed in the episode recapping The Maquis that he's not bothered so much by the sentiments of Sisko's speech, as the fact that Sisko's the one delivering it. And when he puts it that way, I can't help but agree a little - it's disheartening that the captain, the freaking guy in charge of the Federation presence on Deep Space 9, is the one who's frustrated with the Federation and its high-minded ideals.
But on the other hand, what I love about the speech remains, at least in how I've always read it. If Star Trek maps onto Cold War-era views of the world, in which the Federation represents the United States, then the thing I loved about DS9 the most was that it questioned those aspects of Trek. Because America's role as a force for good in the world is always worth questioning... though not worth dismissing out of hand, because there are genuinely positive parts of it, even if US foreign policy kept many parts of the world under brutal dictatorships for decades because we were afraid of those countries falling to communism.
The way I read that scene, with Admiral Nechayev ordering Sisko to talk to the Maquis and make them see reason, fits into this ideal that America could go into a country, tell them what to do, and everything would be fine, because it's America saying it. Our interventions abroad have frequently followed this pattern, and we've gone awfully wrong in a lot of cases because of it - Iraq being only the most recent example.
When Captain Sisko says people on Earth look out the window and see paradise, the writers mean that people in America see paradise out their windows (remember this was the 90s, when things weren't as fucked up as they are now - and no, that's not a dig at the current occupant of the White House, but at the conditions that brought him to power). But seeing that paradise out their windows, the people of Earth think that all problems around the world can be solved the same way they did it themselves.
This isn't any sort of argument that democracy or freedom only works for certain types of people. Russia, China, the Middle East, and so forth, would be better off if they weren't being run by autocrats and gangsters. But equally it's not enough to tell them to just implement democratic and free-market reforms, and everything will be fine - that's exactly what Russia did in the early 90s, and we're paying the price for it now.
Worse, Homefront and Paradise Lost show how brittle that veneer of paradise is at home. But it's worth noting that in those episodes good prevails precisely because Sisko and his allies hold to their ideals, the ideals of the Federation and of Star Trek generally, and because the antagonists are just as devoted to the Federation's ideals (at least as they see it). Which is perhaps an instructive example for us now - that as we stick true to our proper ideals of respect, diversity and freedom, and don't compromise, we can still win out, even if it'll be difficult.
And that's a message that Trek has been giving us since the 60s, with the Original Series.
Sunday, 10 February 2019
Re Collecting James Robinson's Starman
This is one I've been wanting to write for a while. After rereading my old Justice League and Legion of Superheroes books, I moved on to Starman, by James Robinson and Tony Harris (eventually Peter Snejbjerg), which was another big favorite when I was in high school and then again when I was finishing up college.
Unlike the Giffen/DeMatteis League or Giffen/Bierbaums Legion, I was there at the start for Starman, having picked up Issue 0 as part of the Zero Hour crossover that restructured the DC Universe (again) in 1994. It was one of the first books where I followed the writer from his previous work, because it was a followup to James Robinson's Elseworlds miniseries The Golden Age, though thinking back now I'm not sure what else exactly drew me to it.
Having just finished rereading the ten issues of Justice Society of America Vol. 2 by Len Strazewski and Mike Parobeck (et al), I seem to recall not knowing anything about the JSA before I picked up that series. Starman appears in maybe two issues, is mentioned in a third issue, and only has a speaking role in the final issue. If anything, the character I found most striking from that book was the Sandman (Wesley Dodds), who had an equally small role.
Regardless of what drew me to the book - and it may have just been Robinson, and an appreciation for the art and proposed storylines before it was released - I was hooked from the start. Everything about the book was different, from the design ethic based on Art Deco to the main character, Jack Knight, who was completely different from other superheroes. Even the letter column was different, with James Robinson answering the letters each month for the first year or so and insisting that he wanted people to tell him about what they were collecting - and not just comics.
Now, another thing that bolted me onto the book for years after was meeting Robinson (and inker Wade von Grawbadger) at Wonder-Con, back when it was still held in Oakland. I stuck to him all day, as I recall, asking him about all sorts of aspects about the book, and in the end he gave me his PO box address and told me to write. I did, but too late - when I saw him again two Wonder-Cons later he said he'd moved.
Anyway. Another neat thing was that he and von Grawbadger both drew little sketches of Starman for my autograph book, which still makes me quite happy (Golden Age Green Lantern creator Sheldon Moldoff and DC legend Dick Giordano are also in that little book of mine, btw).
I continued reading the book each month until I went to college, and then started up again a year or so later, so that I have most issues with just one large gap of about 11 issues, and a few smaller gaps after that. From there I kept up with it to the very end. And then I let it sit for almost twenty years without rereading it or even thinking very much about it.
Like anything that you revisit after so long, things look different when you come back. To get the big one out of the way first, I'm not sure it's aged as well as I'd like. Tony Harris's artwork is quite rough in the beginning, and there are some spots where his sense of proportion is off. Though I'll try and take the sting off this critique by noting that his compositions were always ambitious and kinetic, to a degree not always seen in books at the time, so the odd failure can be forgiven.
The writing doesn't always hold up completely, either. The big thing that struck me was the weird spots where Robinson puts emphasis in the dialogue: the words that he puts in bold break up the flow of how the characters would be speaking the sentences in real life, and it actually got really distracting. There were also parts that seemed a little self-indulgent, even back when I was 14. The one I've always remembered is a character beating another to death while talking about movie portrayals of Philip Marlowe; another I'd forgotten about was a sequence where a bunch of mobsters are talking about Sondheim musicals, before they all get gunned down.
But if there's a few things that don't hold up, there's lots that still does. I generally remembered big storylines from late in the series, like Stars My Destination and Grand Guignol, and so when Robinson alludes to them in the first few issues, I was left impressed at how intricately he plotted all 81 issues of the book, as well as the fact that he got to play out every one of those storylines he teased, even as early as issue #5.
He also does a great job of populating the setting, Opal City, with a fascinating supporting cast, starting with Golden Age villain the Shade (who becomes an amoral "good" guy here). Even the villains are fascinating, most importantly Nash, the daughter of the Golden Age Mist, who becomes Jack Knight's arch-nemesis (and the mother of his child) as a continuation of her father's feud with Jack's. She has an arc, just as surely as Jack or other characters, and at the end it's tragic but mostly satisfying.
Jack's another thing that doesn't entirely hold up, but that's more because of the passage of time than because of any flaw in his characterization. What I think I liked about him then was his approach to crimefighting, and how it was portrayed alongside his normal life. DC specialized in stories like that in the 80s, which I still think was their greatest period. Ironically, one of the examples I always held out about this approach in DC's storytelling was the previous Starman series featuring a different and unrelated character who Robinson nevertheless brings into the narrative stretching back to the 1940s.
The reason Jack doesn't necessarily hold up, or hasn't aged well, is that he's a character that made a lot of sense then, but doesn't seem to anymore. Maybe it's because I'm less fascinated by old things, or I'm fascinated by different old things, but the idea of a quirky antiques shop owner as a superhero just seems so far from the norm today, when characters like Deadpool approach naturalistic storytelling in a very different way. And it doesn't help that his clothing, his sideburns, his tattoos and goatee all look like they belong in the medium-term past.
But again, I really loved rereading this book. I caught a lot of things on this second pass because I've now experienced many of them. The main thing that made me sit up in holy-shittedness was the last page of the first issue, where he's bleeding out from a fight and a bunch of rarities are flitting through his head - and among them is "Scott Walker albums on vinyl". I'd never heard of Scott Walker before then, but I sure did afterwards - and probably the real thing that separates now from 1994 is that Walker wasn't held up as a godlike genius yet back then. He was a faded pop idol from the 60s who'd disappeared after doing some really weird, avant garde music in his later career.
Back then Scott Walker in any format would have been a rarity - I remember in 2005 a record shop employee telling me his CDs were hard to find in the US. Now he's available on Spotify and anyone can listen to him. Just like you can probably find all of Jack Knight's stock of old clothes, old toys, old posters on Amazon or Ebay.
This was an interesting thought that struck me as I read it in the past couple of months. The internet means you can find most things and have them dispatched to you in no time, regardless of where you are or how old it is. The best example is a letter from early on in the series, where a man wrote in asking for help locating his father. Idly I went and googled the old man's name, and found him still living in Florida - which raises questions about whether the letter writer ever found his dad in these past 25 years.
Anyway, if we need another illustration of how much a product of another time James Robinson and Tony Harris's Starman series was, you just need to look at the publication month of the final issue: August 2001.
Unlike the Giffen/DeMatteis League or Giffen/Bierbaums Legion, I was there at the start for Starman, having picked up Issue 0 as part of the Zero Hour crossover that restructured the DC Universe (again) in 1994. It was one of the first books where I followed the writer from his previous work, because it was a followup to James Robinson's Elseworlds miniseries The Golden Age, though thinking back now I'm not sure what else exactly drew me to it.
Having just finished rereading the ten issues of Justice Society of America Vol. 2 by Len Strazewski and Mike Parobeck (et al), I seem to recall not knowing anything about the JSA before I picked up that series. Starman appears in maybe two issues, is mentioned in a third issue, and only has a speaking role in the final issue. If anything, the character I found most striking from that book was the Sandman (Wesley Dodds), who had an equally small role.
Regardless of what drew me to the book - and it may have just been Robinson, and an appreciation for the art and proposed storylines before it was released - I was hooked from the start. Everything about the book was different, from the design ethic based on Art Deco to the main character, Jack Knight, who was completely different from other superheroes. Even the letter column was different, with James Robinson answering the letters each month for the first year or so and insisting that he wanted people to tell him about what they were collecting - and not just comics.
Now, another thing that bolted me onto the book for years after was meeting Robinson (and inker Wade von Grawbadger) at Wonder-Con, back when it was still held in Oakland. I stuck to him all day, as I recall, asking him about all sorts of aspects about the book, and in the end he gave me his PO box address and told me to write. I did, but too late - when I saw him again two Wonder-Cons later he said he'd moved.
Anyway. Another neat thing was that he and von Grawbadger both drew little sketches of Starman for my autograph book, which still makes me quite happy (Golden Age Green Lantern creator Sheldon Moldoff and DC legend Dick Giordano are also in that little book of mine, btw).
I continued reading the book each month until I went to college, and then started up again a year or so later, so that I have most issues with just one large gap of about 11 issues, and a few smaller gaps after that. From there I kept up with it to the very end. And then I let it sit for almost twenty years without rereading it or even thinking very much about it.
Like anything that you revisit after so long, things look different when you come back. To get the big one out of the way first, I'm not sure it's aged as well as I'd like. Tony Harris's artwork is quite rough in the beginning, and there are some spots where his sense of proportion is off. Though I'll try and take the sting off this critique by noting that his compositions were always ambitious and kinetic, to a degree not always seen in books at the time, so the odd failure can be forgiven.
The writing doesn't always hold up completely, either. The big thing that struck me was the weird spots where Robinson puts emphasis in the dialogue: the words that he puts in bold break up the flow of how the characters would be speaking the sentences in real life, and it actually got really distracting. There were also parts that seemed a little self-indulgent, even back when I was 14. The one I've always remembered is a character beating another to death while talking about movie portrayals of Philip Marlowe; another I'd forgotten about was a sequence where a bunch of mobsters are talking about Sondheim musicals, before they all get gunned down.
But if there's a few things that don't hold up, there's lots that still does. I generally remembered big storylines from late in the series, like Stars My Destination and Grand Guignol, and so when Robinson alludes to them in the first few issues, I was left impressed at how intricately he plotted all 81 issues of the book, as well as the fact that he got to play out every one of those storylines he teased, even as early as issue #5.
He also does a great job of populating the setting, Opal City, with a fascinating supporting cast, starting with Golden Age villain the Shade (who becomes an amoral "good" guy here). Even the villains are fascinating, most importantly Nash, the daughter of the Golden Age Mist, who becomes Jack Knight's arch-nemesis (and the mother of his child) as a continuation of her father's feud with Jack's. She has an arc, just as surely as Jack or other characters, and at the end it's tragic but mostly satisfying.
Jack's another thing that doesn't entirely hold up, but that's more because of the passage of time than because of any flaw in his characterization. What I think I liked about him then was his approach to crimefighting, and how it was portrayed alongside his normal life. DC specialized in stories like that in the 80s, which I still think was their greatest period. Ironically, one of the examples I always held out about this approach in DC's storytelling was the previous Starman series featuring a different and unrelated character who Robinson nevertheless brings into the narrative stretching back to the 1940s.
The reason Jack doesn't necessarily hold up, or hasn't aged well, is that he's a character that made a lot of sense then, but doesn't seem to anymore. Maybe it's because I'm less fascinated by old things, or I'm fascinated by different old things, but the idea of a quirky antiques shop owner as a superhero just seems so far from the norm today, when characters like Deadpool approach naturalistic storytelling in a very different way. And it doesn't help that his clothing, his sideburns, his tattoos and goatee all look like they belong in the medium-term past.
But again, I really loved rereading this book. I caught a lot of things on this second pass because I've now experienced many of them. The main thing that made me sit up in holy-shittedness was the last page of the first issue, where he's bleeding out from a fight and a bunch of rarities are flitting through his head - and among them is "Scott Walker albums on vinyl". I'd never heard of Scott Walker before then, but I sure did afterwards - and probably the real thing that separates now from 1994 is that Walker wasn't held up as a godlike genius yet back then. He was a faded pop idol from the 60s who'd disappeared after doing some really weird, avant garde music in his later career.
Back then Scott Walker in any format would have been a rarity - I remember in 2005 a record shop employee telling me his CDs were hard to find in the US. Now he's available on Spotify and anyone can listen to him. Just like you can probably find all of Jack Knight's stock of old clothes, old toys, old posters on Amazon or Ebay.
This was an interesting thought that struck me as I read it in the past couple of months. The internet means you can find most things and have them dispatched to you in no time, regardless of where you are or how old it is. The best example is a letter from early on in the series, where a man wrote in asking for help locating his father. Idly I went and googled the old man's name, and found him still living in Florida - which raises questions about whether the letter writer ever found his dad in these past 25 years.
Anyway, if we need another illustration of how much a product of another time James Robinson and Tony Harris's Starman series was, you just need to look at the publication month of the final issue: August 2001.
Sunday, 3 February 2019
The Long Strange Career of the Kinks
Just finished listening to basically every album by the Kinks a week or so ago. I get into these moods sometimes, where I go through an artist's entire discography, or through a Pitchfork top albums of whatever decade list, and a few weeks ago it occurred to me that what I needed in my life was to subject the Kinks to this treatment.
I'd say I have a healthy respect for them, borne of owning a couple of studio albums (including Village Green Preservation Society) and a greatest hits compilation. I may not hold them up quite as high as the Beatles in my ranking of British pop bands from the 60s, but they may have a more consistent oeuvre from that decade than The Who, which is another favorite and which is currently receiving the same whole-discography treatment.
Unlike the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, I didn't grow up with the Kinks being played all the time around me. I don't think I heard of them for the first time until Weird Al's parody of "Lola" or until the Britpop thing was underway, and that was mainly in reference to how Damon Albarn's songwriting was clearly indebted to Ray Davies's slice-of-life style. And somewhere in those years I started hearing more about them, until I decided I should just get a greatest hits album to find out what the fuss was all about.
The first thing I discovered was that I actually did know some of their music, since I'd heard songs like "You Really Got Me" over the years. I'd just never known it was them. The next thing was the diversity of their body of work from those years, since those early singles were very different indeed from the likes of "Waterloo Sunset" or "Dedicated Follower of Fashion".
From there I had to get a handle on the idea that the compilation I owned wasn't particularly comprehensive. While it had "Lola" on it, I soon learned that other albums like Village Green Preservation Society weren't represented. After college I went through an initial "music archeologist" phase, as a friend once called it, and gathered Village Green and Face to Face on CD, because they'd been mentioned on a few top British album lists I'd read.
The next thing I did was check out their discography on Allmusic, and that's where I discovered that they hadn't actually broken up until 1996, and had indeed continued making albums of varying quality throughout the years that, it seemed, no one was actually paying attention to them. I remained intrigued by this lost period, and haunted by the statement (I can't remember by whom) that if they'd broken up at the same time as the Beatles they'd have been legends.
So when I listened to all their albums on YouTube the aim was to fill in these gaps and see for myself how good those albums were. I also wanted to get the foundation, from their earliest albums, so that I could hear how their sound evolved from proto-hard rock to English-influenced gentility, and what that turned into.
The main thing I took away from the Allmusic history of the band was that the early 70s, when Ray Davies was insisting on concept albums around celebrity and whatever else, were a pretty terrible period for them. And I can confirm that this is the case, even if the albums aren't completely unlistenable.
What did surprise me was learning how much they improved in the latter half of the decade. Sleepwalkers, their first straight-ahead rock album since the early ones, isn't necessarily a classic (and has a pretty crap cover) but was surprisingly enjoyable. It and its follow ups sounded like the work of a guy in his thirties figuring out again what he's good at and going with that. The other thing that surprised me was that they were all clearly Kinks songs, with Davies's voice and songwriting keeping a line of continuity with some of the best of the 60s, even as they turned into a sort of cut-price Rolling Stones (and I have to admit that I'm both looking forward to and dreading going through that discography) in the 80s.
It's true that by the time they released Phobia, their final album of all original songs, they were sounding pretty tired, though even that album has some high points. But it was so interesting as I listened to those albums to consider what was happening around them in music. While they went for a more traditional English pastoral sound, other British bands were getting louder and heavier.
Later on, Sleepwalkers and Misfits don't make much reference to what was happening in punk, while the albums of the 80s occupy a different universe than the post-punk and synth-pop that was coming out of that decade. And the greatest irony of all is that they broke up just as the British music scene was starting to rediscover them. Phobia came out the same year that Blur released Modern Life is Rubbish, their own foray into British iconography, and the Kinks broke up completely in 1996, the year that Britpop was at its height.
Throughout it all, I was most intrigued by what Ray Davies was thinking as he and the band wrote, recorded and released each of their albums after their heyday. Clearly people were still buying the albums, even if only out of deference to the band's history, but it must have been odd to be so firmly out of the musical zeitgeist. Though it's also fair to say that their music always went counter to the trends being set by the Beatles, Stones or Who in the 60s and 70s.
Thinking back to the idea that they'd have been legends if they'd broken up after Muswell Hillbillies, it's probably true. Albums like Preservation Acts 1 and 2, Everybody's in Showbiz, and Schoolboys in Disgrace are just silly and indulgent (and have some of the worst covers ever). But even if they never again hit the heights of Village Green Preservation Society, it was rewarding discovering those albums when they changed direction toward hard rock. They may not deserve to be in your iTunes collection, but they deserve a listen.
I'd say I have a healthy respect for them, borne of owning a couple of studio albums (including Village Green Preservation Society) and a greatest hits compilation. I may not hold them up quite as high as the Beatles in my ranking of British pop bands from the 60s, but they may have a more consistent oeuvre from that decade than The Who, which is another favorite and which is currently receiving the same whole-discography treatment.
Unlike the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, I didn't grow up with the Kinks being played all the time around me. I don't think I heard of them for the first time until Weird Al's parody of "Lola" or until the Britpop thing was underway, and that was mainly in reference to how Damon Albarn's songwriting was clearly indebted to Ray Davies's slice-of-life style. And somewhere in those years I started hearing more about them, until I decided I should just get a greatest hits album to find out what the fuss was all about.
The first thing I discovered was that I actually did know some of their music, since I'd heard songs like "You Really Got Me" over the years. I'd just never known it was them. The next thing was the diversity of their body of work from those years, since those early singles were very different indeed from the likes of "Waterloo Sunset" or "Dedicated Follower of Fashion".
From there I had to get a handle on the idea that the compilation I owned wasn't particularly comprehensive. While it had "Lola" on it, I soon learned that other albums like Village Green Preservation Society weren't represented. After college I went through an initial "music archeologist" phase, as a friend once called it, and gathered Village Green and Face to Face on CD, because they'd been mentioned on a few top British album lists I'd read.
The next thing I did was check out their discography on Allmusic, and that's where I discovered that they hadn't actually broken up until 1996, and had indeed continued making albums of varying quality throughout the years that, it seemed, no one was actually paying attention to them. I remained intrigued by this lost period, and haunted by the statement (I can't remember by whom) that if they'd broken up at the same time as the Beatles they'd have been legends.
So when I listened to all their albums on YouTube the aim was to fill in these gaps and see for myself how good those albums were. I also wanted to get the foundation, from their earliest albums, so that I could hear how their sound evolved from proto-hard rock to English-influenced gentility, and what that turned into.
The main thing I took away from the Allmusic history of the band was that the early 70s, when Ray Davies was insisting on concept albums around celebrity and whatever else, were a pretty terrible period for them. And I can confirm that this is the case, even if the albums aren't completely unlistenable.
What did surprise me was learning how much they improved in the latter half of the decade. Sleepwalkers, their first straight-ahead rock album since the early ones, isn't necessarily a classic (and has a pretty crap cover) but was surprisingly enjoyable. It and its follow ups sounded like the work of a guy in his thirties figuring out again what he's good at and going with that. The other thing that surprised me was that they were all clearly Kinks songs, with Davies's voice and songwriting keeping a line of continuity with some of the best of the 60s, even as they turned into a sort of cut-price Rolling Stones (and I have to admit that I'm both looking forward to and dreading going through that discography) in the 80s.
It's true that by the time they released Phobia, their final album of all original songs, they were sounding pretty tired, though even that album has some high points. But it was so interesting as I listened to those albums to consider what was happening around them in music. While they went for a more traditional English pastoral sound, other British bands were getting louder and heavier.
Later on, Sleepwalkers and Misfits don't make much reference to what was happening in punk, while the albums of the 80s occupy a different universe than the post-punk and synth-pop that was coming out of that decade. And the greatest irony of all is that they broke up just as the British music scene was starting to rediscover them. Phobia came out the same year that Blur released Modern Life is Rubbish, their own foray into British iconography, and the Kinks broke up completely in 1996, the year that Britpop was at its height.
Throughout it all, I was most intrigued by what Ray Davies was thinking as he and the band wrote, recorded and released each of their albums after their heyday. Clearly people were still buying the albums, even if only out of deference to the band's history, but it must have been odd to be so firmly out of the musical zeitgeist. Though it's also fair to say that their music always went counter to the trends being set by the Beatles, Stones or Who in the 60s and 70s.
Thinking back to the idea that they'd have been legends if they'd broken up after Muswell Hillbillies, it's probably true. Albums like Preservation Acts 1 and 2, Everybody's in Showbiz, and Schoolboys in Disgrace are just silly and indulgent (and have some of the worst covers ever). But even if they never again hit the heights of Village Green Preservation Society, it was rewarding discovering those albums when they changed direction toward hard rock. They may not deserve to be in your iTunes collection, but they deserve a listen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)