Pages

Sunday, 28 July 2019

Wondering About Amazon Prime's The Boys

I've been seeing ads for Amazon's new show The Boys, based on the Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson comic from Dynamite Studios (and previously Wildstorm, which I just learned about reading the Wikipedia page a moment ago). It looks fairly well done, but I'm not totally sure how I feel about it, especially given this review on the AV Club, which I also read just a few minutes ago.

I guess the issue I have is the source material - Garth Ennis has long reveled in nihilism, and while it was entertaining when I was reading Preacher or Hitman, I wonder if it's not gotten out of hand, even for him?

He's one of that cohort of British comics writers who came up in the 80s and 90s on stuff like 2000AD, and then made their way to the US via Vertigo, and from there ended up in superhero comics. But whereas someone like Grant Morrison loves superhero comics and has continued working in the genre, Ennis went on a similar route to Warren Ellis and turned his back on superheroes as soon as he could.

I don't entirely blame him, since I think that most superhero books are basically the same now as they were 20-30 years ago, if a little more gross and intense. But what I've seen of his work since Preacher has lacked heart, for lack of a better term.

It might have been the switch to Marvel in the early 2000s that precipitated it. Preacher was graphic, extreme and sometimes all you could do was laugh in horror (cf. the Meat Woman), but you could see he held affection for characters like Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy, or even Arseface. It was so thematically rich that it actually got me into Western movies, especially John Wayne and Clint Eastwood. Even now I don't think I can name a more perfect comics series, other than Ennis's run on Hellblazer or Neil Gaiman's Sandman.

And it seemed like he was onto something similar with War Stories, the one-shots he did for Vertigo after Preacher, about wars (mainly World War 2, one of his favorite themes). But then he went for Marvel's MAX line, and I think his worst instincts got the better of him. Mainly in the final issue of his Fury mini-series, where Nick Fury (pre Samuel L Jackson) strangles the main villain with his own intestines. Apparently George Clooney had been attached to play Fury, but was put off by that book.

From there Ennis went on to the Punisher, first under Marvel Knights and then MAX. His first storyline was fun, in a back-to-basics way, but the impression I get of some of the MAX issues is that he was just there to rack up as much of a body count as possible. This is notwithstanding my pleasure at seeing his fingerprints all over Punisher War Zone, of course, but I can't deny that those stories aren't really his absolute best.

Another one that I dip into from time to time is Crossed, which he did for Avatar. Crossed is basically just gross and disturbing, a version of zombies where instead of the mindless walking dead, the zombies are maniacal rapists and murderers acting out their civilized selves' worst impulses. There's room for thematically rich stuff there, which is why I have a look every once in a while, but for the most part it's unrelentingly brutal.

The Boys is kind of in this vein, from what I've seen. The first image of the series, essentially, is the crushed, armless corpse of the main character's girlfriend, a hapless victim of collateral damage during a superhero fight. I do think the story plays well with one of Ennis's best-loved themes, which is the ease with which the people in charge of society get subverted into immorality, but I guess my experience has been that he's more concerned with grossing out the reader than giving us characters to care about.

Maybe that's unfair - Wee Hughie is a pretty good character, but somehow I've never connected enough with the book to buy the trade paperbacks, even having skipped ahead a few collections to the end, where things go pretty crazy.

It might just be that, overall, I'm tired with all the relentless negativity and nihilism of media at the moment. I've talked about it on Star Trek Discovery (though my complaint there is more the writing than the tone), and it's present in a number of other shows and comics at the moment. The problem is that nihilism is also present in the real world, much more so than in 2006 when Ennis and Robertson started The Boys, and it gets a little tiring to see that kind of thing even in the places I go to escape from the real world.

Now, I should point out one other, slightly contradictory thing, which is that I'm pleased for him and Darick Robertson that they've had the show optioned, and are getting paid well for it (I presume). I think he's one of those writers whose work deserves more recognition - I just wish it was for some of his better work. I know Preacher's on AMC, but I also don't get the sense it's taken off the way other AMC shows have... and that's a real shame.

Tuesday, 23 July 2019

At Last

Just felt like an appropriate thing to post, given how stuff at home is going:


Sunday, 7 July 2019

Thoughts on the Women's World Cup

So another Women's World Cup ends with the US taking the trophy home. With my limited knowledge of the women's game, I guess I'm not surprised, since all I really knew about women's football before this tournament started was the 1999 tournament, with the now-iconic team that won their second trophy on penalties and, properly, for the first time, put soccer front and center here in the US in ways that the men's team hasn't been able to.

It may sound bad but I wasn't really planning on paying much attention when it all started last month. It was a little more top of mind for me than it might have been if I didn't religiously read the Guardian's football coverage every day, and their Football Weekly podcast has done a decent job in the regular season of mentioning the doings in women's football. I'd been sort of looking forward to a break, but then it all started and I found myself swept along in the excitement.

I remember listening to the Football Weekly that went out the day before it started, and getting a sense of excitement from the correspondents, and I think that's what made me want to keep up. But the thing that really got my attention was seeing Italy unexpectedly beat Australia.

As an Italy fan, I think it's fair to call myself "long-suffering". I still have fond memories of Italy's 2006 triumph (in the men's tournament), but since then the World Cup has been one disaster after another, and the European Championships have been only a bit better. To be honest I didn't even know the women hadn't qualified for the last couple of tournaments, so seeing this unfancied team come out of the blocks was impressive. Even more impressive was the 5-0 against Jamaica that essentially guaranteed progression to the round of 16. And if Italy went out in the quarterfinal to eventual finalists the Netherlands, well, it was at least a good run, which was needed after so many years of the men doing so badly.

The other thing I enjoyed about the tournament was the mirror-universe quality to it all. Some teams that are nowhere in the men's game qualified for this tournament (like Thailand), or were even considered strong contenders (like Canada). Even China and Japan got to the knockout rounds, which is a big feat for Asian teams on the men's side.

Probably the biggest example of this quality, though, is the position of the US. By winning today the US takes home its fourth trophy, making it the most successful women's team on this stage, whereas the men didn't qualify for Russia 2018 either. I was struck by the narrative surrounding their progress as the team everybody loved to hate, especially given how they kicked off their tournament with that 13-0 demolition of Thailand.

But I also got into the narratives around Megan Rapinoe and her ongoing spat with both Donald Trump and with the US Soccer Federation, as well as how the women's team overall has taken the federation to court to achieve parity with the men in terms of pay. Given their success internationally, it's hard to argue, especially when you read the analysis of how little they earn compared to the men.

All of a sudden, not only could I not avoid profiles of Rapinoe or Everybody's Favorite, Alex Morgan, but I couldn't get enough of them myself, especially given how outspoken Morgan is on this pay gap question. The profiles on her talk about how marketable she is (which I take as a euphemism for "attractive"), so it's more notable how willing she is to speak bluntly about pay, her goal celebrations or even backing up Rapinoe on not visiting the White House.

I also can't help contrasting Morgan with Neymar Jr. on the subject of diving and drawing fouls. Both are key players who score a lot of goals and therefore get the stuffing knocked out of them regularly. And if Morgan has started to incorporate diving into her own repertoire, it's still a far cry from the theatrics that Neymar engages in when he gets fouled - to the point that he's probably damaged his own reputation every time he pounds the turf while rolling about.

Morgan gets bowled over, makes maybe some kind of meal of it, but then she's back on her feet and drawing more fouls, with a lot less complaining than him.

Or another example that I loved: in the Sweden-Netherlands semi-final Kosovare Asllani took a ball to the face that left her getting stretchered off at the end of the match, and going to the hospital for scans. Yet she recovered fast enough to play again in the third-place playoff a few days later, and even scored the first goal. 

I'd say it's those kinds of stories that made me glad I've watched a fair chunk of this tournament. I just hope I'll be able to keep up with this side of the game as it develops, though with luck a true female equivalent to Neymar's playacting is still a few years off.

Sunday, 23 June 2019

Radical Kindness or Just Plain Being Nice?

We were having a conversation in the office the other day about the recent Mr. Rogers documentary, Won't You Be My Neighbor, and it got me thinking about the buzz that surrounded the movie when it was out. I seem to remember posts here and there on Facebook where people were raving about it, and elsewhere on the internet people were talking about how much it made them cry.

At the same time I thought I saw an increase in memes relating to Mr. Rogers, and the various kindnesses and wise sayings he doled out in his years on TV. The main one is about seeing people at disasters who are helping, and to always look for the helpers - which I think is very good advice at any time.

I'm old enough to remember watching Mr. Rogers on TV, though I think as a whippersnapper I preferred Sesame Street, which was funnier and fairly anarchic for TV aimed at kids aged three and up. I thought I remembered when he went off the air, though that and his passing (in 2001 and 2003, respectively) turn out to have happened later than I had imagined.

But what got me thinking after the movie came out, and after that conversation in the office, was how the niceness of Fred Rogers seems to have taken on a political undertone.

This shouldn't be surprising, in these weirdly polarized times, when certain (*cough* rightwing *cough*) groups find depictions of the Statue of Liberty to be provocatively liberal. But when I say "political" I don't mean that the Mr. Rogers ethos has been adopted by the left - more that the need for being nice and tolerant in a quiet and low-key way seems to have become a reaction against the prevailing current of American society, which just feels more polarized along any metric or ideal you could care to mention.

So I call it radical kindness - I don't think I came up with the term, but whoever it belongs to, I take it to mean a clear attempt to be kind and friendly in situations where it would otherwise be easy to just be unpleasant. Like any such impulse, it can also sometimes go a little overboard - I remember being at a concert at Stern Grove in San Francisco last year, where a woman sitting in front of me was not only helping people climb up along her little stretch of ground where she was sitting with her friends, but was also insisting (repeatedly) slogans like how we're all in this together, or wanting to help out, or some such.

That might come off as snobbish, but I appreciated the impulse, even though I could see her patience wearing thin with all the people trying to climb past throughout the afternoon (we were listening to an orchestra play a bunch of pieces by Sibelius, so it was a fairly long concert).

And at the risk of sounding even more snobby, on the internet there seems to be a performative aspect to it, where people compete to show how much some simple (or elaborate) act of kindness that they've read about hits them in the feels.

If I'm criticizing anything about this radical kindness thing, it's that - but at the same time I don't want to criticize too hard because it just seems churlish to get annoyed at people going out of their way to be nice to others.

I guess what trips me up about this impulse, and the buzz surrounding the Mr. Rogers documentary, is how it really is a reaction - it could be the media inflating bad news to generate more clicks, or maybe things really are so bad, but it does feel like our leaders are particularly venal at the moment, and business is more cutthroat than ever, all against a backdrop of casual cruelty and environmental collapse. With that in mind, why shouldn't people - especially younger people - decide to take a stand by loudly proclaiming they're for everything Wall Street and Silicon Valley and the government seem to be ignoring?

Overall, the real negative that I can see here is that things have gotten so bad that such stances really are necessary. Lest we forget, there are concentration camps for refugee children on our southern border, and administration officials are arguing that these kids don't need soap, toothpaste or blankets.

That said, it's not just here. In Japan there's a growing group of people called hikikomori, who are effectively modern-day hermits - effectively people who have opted out of the rat race of Japanese society and refuse to leave their homes or see their families. There are also "herbivores" or "grass-eating men", who have opted out of looking for romantic partners entirely - or at least out of traditional expectations of masculinity in Japan.

But it's notable that this reaction in Japan is against a specific cultural expectation (get your salaryman job, marry someone, and do just as all other men have been doing since the end of the Second World War), whereas in the US it's against a feeling of rampant unpleasantness. Or to put it another way, hikikomori are looking for a different way of life, whereas in America we're just getting sick of people being shitty - which has never really been an expected "way of life".

So that's why I believe Won't You Be My Neighbor got so much attention when it came out, despite - or because of - the fact that Fred Rogers was an ordained minister and probably quite conservative in many ways. Though his conservatism probably manifested in quieter ways than that of today's Republicans. Much like I said last year or so, that the MeToo movement might not have gained so much traction if a person with accusations of sexual assault and harassment hadn't gained the White House, the Mr. Rogers documentary might not have gained so much traction if there weren't this sense of cruelty pervading American life right now.

Or maybe it would have been a big (ish) movie no matter who's president? Nostalgia was probably a big part of its appeal, too. Still, I think there are grounds for my argument, and I'd be interested in seeing if there really has been more thought for radical kindness since 2016.

We could use it, to be honest.

Monday, 10 June 2019

So Many Endings, Even More Spoilers

I've been tempted to do a rundown of all the endings I've watched lately: Game of Thrones, Avengers: Endgame, X-Men: Dark Phoenix, even Chernobyl. Some have been well done, others... well, not bad exactly, but maybe not the most satisfying conclusions to their respective sagas. I don't know if I have a grand unifying theory of endings to give here, but I suppose I can tease out some commonality if I go through them all, so...

I'm not one of those who were offended by the denouement of GoT. I covered my thoughts about the thought of it ending back in April, when the first episode had just aired and the dust hadn't yet settled.  I then spent three weeks in Europe unable to watch the final half of the season (or rather, focused more on wrapping up Star Trek: Discovery). Because I was still perusing sites like the AV Club, I got the sense that crazy things were happening, and I was right.

If I have one complaint about the end of GoT, it's the rushed nature of certain things. Specifically, the bit where Daenerys torches King's Landing, and Jon Snow then has to kill her and the (surviving) nobles give the throne to Bran, the one person least likely to fuck everything up. All of these things, taken singly and indeed altogether, work, more or less. I just feel like it was all a bit rushed, which is odd considering that the season consisted of six 90-minute movies, effectively. But on the other hand, they could have cut them down to 60 minutes, developed the story a bit more, and given us ten episodes to digest the Siege of Winterfell, the sack of King's Landing, and all the fallout.

The other question is how much of this will be in the books, if they ever come out. The AV Club's "Experts" review touches on this, suggesting that the ending GRRM comes up with may not be this exact set of events, though it'll likely be the same emotional resonances, i.e. the main characters turning their backs on the past and finally forging their own futures, though with great regrets behind them. And the review notes, which I didn't notice at the time, how little Jon Snow had to do with anything apart from stabbing Dany. Hopefully in the books he's a bit more instrumental.

Contrast that with Endgame. I won't deny that Infinity War left me a little cold at the end. I knew the Snap was going to happen, because it's the starting point of the Infinity Gauntlet crossover from the 90s, so paradoxically the fact that they ended it there wasn't as much of a shock for me as it was for probably 99% of people watching.

On the other hand, I don't know how they fixed things in the comics, other than Adam Warlock ended up splitting the Infinity Stones among a bunch of weirdoes and having some sort of adventures that didn't last long. This means that Endgame had the capacity to surprise me, which probably helped me enjoy it so much.

Endgame also did a good job of calling back to previous movies in the series, bringing a number of ideas and characters back to tie them into the present - it even made me appreciate Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 1, which I'd thought was so much gibberish at the start. And while looking back it also did a good job of pointing us toward the future, by inserting a new dynamic into Starlord and Gamora's romance, passing the shield and armor to successors of Captain America and Iron Man, and basically bringing back most of the box office draws like Black Panther.

Though I'm not ashamed to say that, as Ant-Man became the catalyst for solving the Snap, possibly the thing I'm looking to most is another film for him.

Then there's Dark Phoenix. Unlike the others, it's not exactly meant to be an ending, but the fact that Disney now owns the characters' film rights means this series is likely done. I remain a little ambivalent about that, because while the quality hasn't been as great as the MCU films, it has been fun to see some of the storylines and deep-bench characters show up, especially in the sub-series that started with First Class.

But if anything, the real ending for the X-Men movie series was Logan, given how it put a capstone on that character's journey and on mutants overall. If Dark Phoenix sits in that timeline, then it's even more of a downer because what we can expect is a sad, sad end for all these characters.

Though I still appreciate cool-dean Professor X, as played by James McAvoy, and his dynamic with Michael Fassbender's Magneto. Seeing Patrick Stewart opposite Ian McKellen in those roles was, of course, brilliant, but this set of movies did a good job of showing their frenemy-ship as it developed over the decades. Even if their ridiculous longevity was starting to wear a little thin.

I'm also ambivalent about the X-Men going forward, because I always thought they sat a little awkwardly in the wider Marvel universe, and each subsequent X-Men movie is going to either have to incorporate the Avengers or neutralize them in some way. Though I'm curious how the roles will be recast, if at all - they might use the multiverse teased in Into the Spider-Verse and the upcoming Spider-Man: Far From Home, to show the mutants occupying a separate Earth that they only visit when there's some planet-shattering... well, crisis, I guess you'd call it.

Which actually brings me to Arrow! I'd almost forgotten about it, since Chernobyl's the thing I've finished most recently (that might needs its own post). I just wrapped up watching season 7 of Arrow, and I have to appreciate the way they approached it - I read early in the season that the showrunners decided to treat it as a final season, which meant they could go a little crazy and kill or otherwise remove a bunch of characters (or bring them back; hi, Roy!).

It wasn't the most satisfying season of TV, especially because the previous season of Arrow had been a sort of return to form, but I appreciated the high drama of it all, as Oliver discovered a long-lost sister who turned out to be evil. It'll be interesting to see how the next season, which really will be the last and will run for only ten episodes, wraps up Oliver Queen's story.

It's interesting, looking back at all these, how much superhero stuff I watch, and how much it's come to dominate the landscape. Back in 2008, you'd have guessed Batman would be the thing to dominate, with the Dark Knight, but Marvel arguably did a better job by focusing on a second-string character like Iron Man - the very fact he's considered one of the big guys of Marvel is pretty much due to that movie.

And it's interesting to think that GoT, the one thing here not based on a comic, became as big a cultural phenomenon, given its origins as a niche fantasy novel. The way for Game of Thrones may have been opened by the Lord of the Rings trilogy, but even that couldn't compete as a cultural touchstone, given how many references to Khaleesi and Jon Snow I encounter in non-nerd settings. It's also opened the way for other adaptations, albeit of works that aren't always as accomplished as GRRM's work.

The 2010s, at any rate, have been dominated by these two colossi, and it'll be interesting to see in the decade to come what takes their place.

Sunday, 2 June 2019

Champions League 2019: Game of Narratives

Well, another Champions League final is in the bag, and Liverpool's won out over Spurs to claim the title, a year after getting defeated at this stage by Real Madrid. Real were at the end of their imperial phase of three titles in a row, and four of the last five tournaments, though we didn't know it then: when the Galácticos were still celebrating that win Zinedine Zidane was still a few days off from quitting, out of the blue, and Cristiano Ronaldo was still a month or so off from jumping ship for Juventus.

What a different 2018-19 for Real and Liverpool, though. It's been a clear season of rebuilding for Real Madrid, given the debacle of hiring Julen Lopetegui out from under the Spanish national team's nose on the eve of the World Cup last summer - he lasted not very long at all, and his replacement, Santiago Solari, also exited unceremoniously when Real dropped out of three tournaments in the same week, only for Zidane to come back.

Liverpool, on the other hand, shored up in all the right places after last season, particularly given that two of the goals they conceded came from goalkeeping blunders. While he didn't have much to do yesterday, at least until the 80th minute, Alisson showed his worth by being confident between the sticks, effectively banishing the memory of Loris Karius's mistakes/rubbery wrists. And Virgil van Dijk has come in for repeated praise all season, showing just how important he's been to Liverpool as they ran Manchester City close for the title.

It's funny to say, but winning the Champions League is almost a consolation for Liverpool after missing out on the Premier League title by a single point. It would have been even more perfect if they'd been facing off against Man City in yesterday's match, but of course that would have been a completely different game. Certainly if Liverpool had been so profligate in their passing against City, they might not be celebrating today.

Spurs had, probably, the better of most of the game - their buildup play was good, and they pressed strongly against Liverpool throughout, which implies that they won the midfield battle. Where they came up short, over the 90 minutes, was in front of goal, which is probably an indicator of how unready Harry Kane was to come back. Worse, it might indicate what kind of experience he'll have at the Nations League on Thursday.

So where does everyone go from here? For Liverpool, this hopefully means even more strengthening of the squad, and challenging again for the title. Though it's fair to say that, given the lead they frittered away over the course of the winter, there might be a mental aspect that Jürgen Klopp needs to work on next season, more than any changes in personnel.

On the other hand, Spurs will definitely need to strengthen. The fact that they held onto fourth place (with its Champions League spot) as well as getting to the final without having brought in any players speaks well to the setup and to Mauricio Pochettino's management, but this coming season will definitely be one where if they stand still they'll fall behind. And that's if Poch hangs around north London - the Real Madrid and Juventus jobs look to be sown up but there should be no shortage of clubs willing to give him the financial support that Spurs have had to be more careful about providing while they got their new stadium up and running.

It's too early to predict who'll win next year's Champions League, but it's a fair bet that it'll once again be contested by two sides from the top 4 countries - Ajax may have come within a whisker of being the first non-English, Spanish, Italian or German team to reach the final since 2004, but they've effectively cemented their role as a feeder club for Barcelona, given that starlet Frenkie de Jong was already on his way there when his team knocked out Madrid in the quarters. Others will be sure to follow him out the door this summer, particularly if the Netherlands do well in the Nations League.

Barcelona, Juventus and Man City will likely fall short in some capacity, since they've contrived to fall short most years (if not every year) recently. Much has been made of Pep Guardiola's mental block in the knockout stages of the tournament, though it's reassuring that even a Death Star full of cash and the greatest tactical mind in football can't deliver this trophy (at least, not since he last won it with Barcelona in 2011).

And that's without looking at the other English clubs - but none of them really look like challenging either. So the 2020 Champions League trophy could very well go back to Liverpool. The question will be whether Real Madrid have sorted out their problems enough to claim back the title they consider their own.

Sunday, 26 May 2019

Season 2 Syndrome: More Star Trek Discovery, More Spoilers

It's been a frenetic few weeks of watching culturally significant TV shows and movies, to avoid too many spoilers and so forth, so while I could be finishing Game of Thrones and reviewing that, or giving my thoughts on Avengers: Endgame (which I quite enjoyed!), here I am, talking about Season 2 of Star Trek: Discovery. Those others will just have to wait, I suppose.

Like with the first season, I watched S2 on Netflix abroad, during my vacation. This time I watched it all in one go, effectively, over the course of three weeks, instead of splitting it between two stints abroad that were several months apart. It doesn't really have anything to do with the show's quality, but although it's nice to be able to watch all of Disco on a single three-week vacation, it makes my viewing a little frenetic. I could solve that by paying for CBS All Access, but...

Look, I'm just going to have to say it: this was a pretty disappointing season of TV. Instead of fixing or course-correcting the negative stuff from last season, the writers doubled down on their inexpert use of existing Trek tropes and their unwillingness to develop the secondary characters. And to make matters worse, they took Tilly, a character I'd singled out for praise in the first season, and turned her almost as annoying as Burnham.

There were some good aspects, of course. Even without the callbacks to the Menagerie and the Cage, it was great to see Captain Pike show up here, with Anson Mount doing a really good job of playing a good, old-fashioned Trek captain. As the hosts of Mission Log Live note, he's fairly influential but also really underdeveloped (and IMO, especially the horrible treatment he gets in the JJ Abrams movies). Here we get to see him shown as a character different from Kirk and Picard and the rest, but also able to stand up among that crowd as a good leader and a caring mentor.

This makes Michael Burnham's regression to obnoxiousness even more frustrating. It was sort of exciting to read before S1 came out that this show would focus on a crewmember other than the captain, "for once". That should have been a red flag, because if we're honest, despite the captain getting top billing in each previous show, Trek has never been focused solely on them. Kirk may have been in almost every TOS and TAS, but TNG and DS9 in particular were happy to range around the crew and introduce us to them, develop their characters, etc, so that when something happened we'd give a shit.

(More on this in a second)

The problem with Disco is that Burnham turns out to be a horrible character to hang an entire show on. She improved a bit last season, but here I found the scenes with her dragging so... fucking... much. It may not even be that she's so bad herself, but it's clearly a mistake to make everything so dependent on her, and require all these big emotional scenes to go through her.

The other character that got too much screen time, as I said, was Tilly. Last season, I said, she was the conscience of the show, reminding the crew of Starfleet's values at the moments when they were most likely to abandon those values. This season, appropriately enough, Mission Log Live ran a poll asking listeners if she was turning into Wesley Crusher 2.0. It's like whoever wrote her this season heard, possibly from someone who themselves hadn't watched the show, that she was awkward and chatty, so they had her hijack scenes instead of contribute to them.

But as far as characterization the show's greatest crime this season was against Airiam. Since early in S1 we've seen this random robot lady on the Discovery's bridge, doing whatever. We gathered at some point what her name was, and her gender, but never spent any time with her (because for whatever reason we had to be following Burnham). Then this season the alien probe infects her with a virus, so that she's set up as a potential threat. So far, so good.

It's at this point that the writers decide to fill in her backstory (kind of). We gather that she used to be fully human, and that she was in some kind of shuttle crash that killed her husband and left her in this state. Also, apparently, she was friends with Burnham and all the other characters we don't know anything about. And then they throw her out an airlock. The crew treats this as a tragedy, but why should we, the audience, give a fuck? The writers had no interest in her before this, so again, why should we? The funeral for her was bad enough, but the bad looks the crew throws at the woman who comes to take Airiam's place are just the stupidest piece of writing since Season 2 of Voyager.

One other negative, and then I'll get back to positives. There wasn't anything wrong with the Red Angel storyline per se, but the moment it appeared in the window of the Ba'ul ship were Saru and his sister were, I knew it was going to be Burnham in that suit. This was all but confirmed when Spock tried to mind-meld with it, and in his mind it changed to Burnham.

The writers might have thought they were being clever pulling the bait-and-switch where they looked like revealing that the Red Angel was actually Burnham's mom (yay, Kima from the Wire!), but then in the final episode they confirm that, yep, it was her all along, going back in time to the exact moments they needed her. Like the Airiam thing above, it's not that this is just shitty storytelling, it's also manipulative - the writers clearly have a low opinion of the audience if this is the kind of trick they play on us. Good writing isn't about being against the viewer, it's about being on their side, leading them through rather than leading them on, and not pulling pointless twists out of nowhere.

But let's get back to some positives. Once again, the show looks great, though especially in the pod-racing sequence in the first episode, and the battle sequence in the last, it feels like covering up for the myriad failings of the plot. I've already mentioned how much I enjoyed seeing Pike, but strangely I was really moved by the episode "If Memory Serves", which starts with footage from the Menagerie, complete with paper flowers and Spock in a turtleneck. For once it felt like Disco was in conversation with the previous shows, rather than using tropes its writers had heard might have appeared in the show before. If it violates canon to have Spock and Burnham travel to Talos IV, then at least it was done in a way that respects the show's history - not something you can say often about Disco.

Another positive is that ending - er, in the sense of what S3 promises, rather than the fact this whole mess mercifully came to an end. The ship and the crew travel almost a thousand years into the future, as a way to defeat the evil AI. It doesn't make loads of sense on reflection, but whatever. It promises a new milieu for the show, unencumbered by the timeline and having to maintain technology appropriate to TOS-era Trek. And it should just be interesting to see the galaxy's evolution, since so many fans have been asking for Trek that comes after TNG, DS9 and Voyager.

That said, as with all positive things there are negatives to this part of Disco, too. The main one is that  business about telling the survivors they can never speak of Burnham, Control or the spore drive again. To mix some Simpsons metaphors in here, if Burnham is Poochie ("Whenever he's off-screen, the other characters should stop and ask, Where's Poochie?"), then this whole season is Armen Tamzarian - right down to the threat of launching them out of Springfield if they mention him again.

And am I really expected to believe that Discovery's stuck in the future forever? This is a show where accidents with everyday technology like transporters could send you into the past (or, you know, the Mirror Universe), so surely in S3 the writers will fuck it up again so badly that they'll find some hand-wavey way to get them back in the original timeline.

Maybe this is all too relentlessly negative a review. I kept watching, of course, because I wanted to see what happened. And escaping to the future was definitely a curveball, in a season that lacked them. In any case, I'm on social media a whole lot less, so I'll see if I can avoid the buzz about the next season, which I think might have put expectations for this one too high.

But in the meantime, Disco has failed to move up in my estimation since last season. If anything it's gone down a bit - quality-wise it's now behind some of the best parts of Enterprise for me, if still ahead of Voyager. And as a "Star Trek show", with all that entails, it really hasn't done much in that area this season either. I ended last season's review on a hopeful note, but this time I'm only hopeful that the show gets its act together - and that it holds my interest enough to be split over multiple overseas trips. Another season like this and I really won't be interested in paying for CBS All Access.