Well, that went south quickly, didn't it?
I last posted to this blog two weeks ago, when the Bay Area and the state of California hadn't yet locked down to slow the spread of the virus. Since then, in fairly rapid succession, my company made us all start working from home, the Bay Area counties enacted a shelter in place order and then the whole state followed suit.
In that last post I was already talking about avoiding crowded places, and that hasn't changed - in fact, even if I wanted to go somewhere crowded I'd have trouble, unless I end up at the supermarket on a particularly busy day. But in the meantime I'm just trying to avoid going stir crazy while I sit out the lockdowns and virus and all that.
It's probably no surprise that work days are the easiest to cope with (and it helps that I'm one of those lucky people who are able to work from home). I'm expected to be on call for the stuff we're doing, at specific times on Monday through Friday, and that makes it easy to not spin my wheels wondering what to do next.
The main thing I've had to keep in mind is exercise - not just getting up from my desk to oil my joints, but also getting out of the house for a walk once or twice a day. The fresh air and sunlight (when we have it - it's been oddly cold and rainy, even for here) are necessary, as is the time to let my brain unspool without external stimulation from music or podcasts or work meetings.
What's a little more difficult is keeping busy on the weekends. Or, rather than "keeping busy", the question is how do I avoid feeling like I've wasted my time? A thing I noticed very soon after I moved here in late 2013 is that weekends passed more quickly than they did in London, but with notably less payoff. There, I would hop out to the center of town and find some lunch, hang out in the museums and peruse the bookstores.
Here those options were a little less available, because most of the good museums are up in San Francisco, which requires an hour's drive to get to. I made do, but of course for the moment the museums I'm a member of are all closed, and I don't want to go up there to risk getting sick anyway. So my range is circumscribed to a radius of a couple of miles, which takes in the stores I shop at to stock up on essentials and my normal walking or running routes.
Apart from that, I've been trying to make sure that I get errands done around the house, while also balancing goof-around time. Yesterday I reserved an hour for writing - and got through correcting a manuscript that's been on my desk for a while; then I reserved an hour for cleaning - and after unloading the dishwasher and taking out the trash I finally tackled the snowdrifts of mail that have been building up for (literally) years at this point. And I reserved a guilt-free hour each for reading, watching TV and playing video games, because I have a fair backlog of all of those to get through.
Of course, I'd trade some of that productivity for having my girlfriend here, as I told her on our FaceTime call last night. Which brings me to the other thing that I've been doing a bit more of: getting in touch with friends and family and checking in.
My sweetie and I have our daily check-in, whether on text or on FaceTime, but I've been calling my parents more (my dad's in Italy, but ironically I feel he's the safest of us all) and trying to stay in touch with my sisters more too. I've also tried to text some friends a bit more often, though that's more bittersweet as I can't actually go and see them.
The other question I'm dancing around is how long this will all last, and whether it's all sustainable. When I was unemployed and freelancing two years ago, there were a few days when it all got to me and I couldn't muster much interest to either look for permanent jobs or drum up more freelance work. Luckily I haven't descended to those depths during this time, in part because I only have the weekends to wallow, but I don't think I'm saying anything too controversial by hoping that things resolve themselves soon - ideally without too much undue chaos or loss of life.
The hope is that we start to see cases dropping off soon, and start to see the restrictions relax. Because, frankly, while I have a fair stash of toilet paper (thanks to my wonderful, prepared girlfriend), it's not infinite and I can't beat the panicky assholes who are hoarding it for no reason.
But apart from that, as I say, I'm trying to be productive, and I figure that's the best any of us can do at the moment.
Stay safe out there!
Sunday, 22 March 2020
Sunday, 8 March 2020
Europe's Centrifugal Force Threatens to Make it Irrelevant
Even though I don't live in a place that's been locked down by the coronavirus, I've been taking precautions like avoiding crowded places, and this has meant a lot of long walks have replaced my gym sessions this weekend. Naturally when I go for these walks I think a lot of deep thoughts, and so today I chewed over a question that's been bothering me for about 15 years: Is Europe setting itself up for irrelevancy?
The root of this question is a conversation I had in my very first week at journalism school, when I engaged one of my fellow students on her thoughts on China. I don't know how we got there, but she was very in favor of China's rise, and predicted that Europe would be irrelevant in the coming century. This was kind of blasphemous to me, in part because I was (and still am) an advocate of Western liberal democracy over China's corporatist authoritarianism.
A few months later I attended a talk at school about Latin America, and was struck by one of the journalists there saying that Latin America had made itself irrelevant. I didn't know much about the history of the region, but the idea stuck with me.
In any case I kept both those thoughts in mind for years, so that when I got to that book I've referenced before, The Nordic Theory of Everything by Anu Partanen, something in my brain dredged them up.
As I've said, I'm keen as any leftie to remake the US in the image of a Nordic social democracy, but something about Partanen's tone struck me as off. It took a while to realize that she was completely leaving out China (and Asia generally) from her analysis. That is to say, yes, it would be great if the US would guarantee healthcare, parental leave, good-quality education and so forth, but the big Asian economies aren't moving in that direction - so is it really a prerequisite for competing in the future?
Probably, but then Europe has other problems beyond this complacency (which is, by the way, very Nordic). That's been brought home to me by the discussion around the role of Huawei in delivering 5G.
Europe is, oddly, probably better placed than the US to deliver 5G network infrastructure, because it's home to two companies that build such equipment: Ericsson and Nokia (also both Nordic, funnily enough). That said, Huawei is enormous, and already in most operators' networks worldwide, giving it a head start of years compared with those two... and an even wider head start over any US competitors.
This hasn't stopped the US from raising concerns about whether Huawei's equipment is trustworthy - concerns that at least a bit valid, even if the administration is acting on them in a pretty ham-handed way. Yet the US's position is weakened by the fact that, as noted, neither Ericsson nor Nokia (nor both in concert) is ready to position themselves as a counter-weight to Huawei. Without getting into the merits of the "race for 5G" (which I think is a stupid talking point), any country that refuses to use any Huawei equipment risks delivering an inferior network experience, at greater expense and over a longer time.
So where does Europe's supposed irrelevancy come in here? The fact is that European companies haven't been able to grow to the scale of US or Chinese companies. This could be because of the regulatory environment (i.e. the fact that a regulatory environment exists in Europe, whereas it doesn't in China or the US), or it could be because both China and the US are more willing to let companies grow monstrously big to "compete on a global level".
The EU on its own is comfortably larger than the US, and if you add in non-EU European countries you'd add a further 100 million inhabitants... and that's without including Russia. But what I believe hamstrings it in this sphere is the still very fragmented state of business - there are a number of pan-European firms, but they tend to be smaller than US counterparts... or owned by them.
And the situation in tech is worse. I don't believe that Europe is a tech wasteland, because there are some notable companies that have come from there. The problem is that Microsoft has bought all of them (a slight exaggeration, but still).
Where the political fragmentation hurts Europe, even despite the presence of the European Union, is that certain things are still done in a certain way in Italy, compared with Germany, compared with France, and so on. Certain countries' labor markets are more flexible and dynamic than those elsewhere, so all the young people leave their home countries and go to the places where they'll find jobs. This creates a high degree of noise to signal for any budding entrepreneurs, while also starving their home countries of the experience needed to build an innovation ecosystem.
And because I'm a whining Remoaner, it's worth pointing out that leaving the EU won't fix this issue, but rather make it worse. It's not pro-EU propaganda to point out that companies want to do business in a harmonized environment, and when multiple countries harmonize their environments it becomes easier to conduct that business.
To summarize, the problem for Europe is creating enough space for innovative companies to flourish without all decamping to the Silicon Valley (this is a two-fer of self-interest for me, because it makes Europe more dynamic and it keeps loads of Europeans from coming here to the Bay Area and putting even more strain on it). Part of the problem is being able to scale a company to a point where it can compete globally, and the other part is simply having room in the market to do things in tech - for example, who needs another search engine when everybody just uses Google?
This assumes that having large companies is the only measure of success, which to be clear I don't believe. Germany's economy is built on an enormous number of small and medium-sized enterprises that act as suppliers to big ones, for example in the car industry. But having enough small companies creating goods that are in demand is an important prerequisite.
I don't believe that European countries are setting themselves up well to do that. Too many of them are still too protectionist (for example France and its insistence on farming subsidies), while attempts to limit movement from outside the EU, or from the EU into Britain, won't help the underlying causes of population movement.
In fact, if we take a look at the history of Latin America, there was a time when countries like Argentina, Brazil and Chile were much more active internationally. However, they fell into a period of economic nationalism, political populism and military rule, which caused them to fall behind the countries of Europe. Folks in the global north may know of Eva Peron from Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical Evita, but in truth her husband's regime made Argentina ungovernable, and ripe for the military takeover that blighted the country for decades.
As Europe splits off into different populist or nationalist camps, whether in Hungary, Poland or the UK, they should look at the history of Latin http://frad-lab.blogspot.com/2020/03/how-scandinavian-design-and-social.htmlAmerica and avoid the pitfalls those companies hit, to avoid the same fate.
The root of this question is a conversation I had in my very first week at journalism school, when I engaged one of my fellow students on her thoughts on China. I don't know how we got there, but she was very in favor of China's rise, and predicted that Europe would be irrelevant in the coming century. This was kind of blasphemous to me, in part because I was (and still am) an advocate of Western liberal democracy over China's corporatist authoritarianism.
A few months later I attended a talk at school about Latin America, and was struck by one of the journalists there saying that Latin America had made itself irrelevant. I didn't know much about the history of the region, but the idea stuck with me.
In any case I kept both those thoughts in mind for years, so that when I got to that book I've referenced before, The Nordic Theory of Everything by Anu Partanen, something in my brain dredged them up.
As I've said, I'm keen as any leftie to remake the US in the image of a Nordic social democracy, but something about Partanen's tone struck me as off. It took a while to realize that she was completely leaving out China (and Asia generally) from her analysis. That is to say, yes, it would be great if the US would guarantee healthcare, parental leave, good-quality education and so forth, but the big Asian economies aren't moving in that direction - so is it really a prerequisite for competing in the future?
Probably, but then Europe has other problems beyond this complacency (which is, by the way, very Nordic). That's been brought home to me by the discussion around the role of Huawei in delivering 5G.
Europe is, oddly, probably better placed than the US to deliver 5G network infrastructure, because it's home to two companies that build such equipment: Ericsson and Nokia (also both Nordic, funnily enough). That said, Huawei is enormous, and already in most operators' networks worldwide, giving it a head start of years compared with those two... and an even wider head start over any US competitors.
This hasn't stopped the US from raising concerns about whether Huawei's equipment is trustworthy - concerns that at least a bit valid, even if the administration is acting on them in a pretty ham-handed way. Yet the US's position is weakened by the fact that, as noted, neither Ericsson nor Nokia (nor both in concert) is ready to position themselves as a counter-weight to Huawei. Without getting into the merits of the "race for 5G" (which I think is a stupid talking point), any country that refuses to use any Huawei equipment risks delivering an inferior network experience, at greater expense and over a longer time.
So where does Europe's supposed irrelevancy come in here? The fact is that European companies haven't been able to grow to the scale of US or Chinese companies. This could be because of the regulatory environment (i.e. the fact that a regulatory environment exists in Europe, whereas it doesn't in China or the US), or it could be because both China and the US are more willing to let companies grow monstrously big to "compete on a global level".
The EU on its own is comfortably larger than the US, and if you add in non-EU European countries you'd add a further 100 million inhabitants... and that's without including Russia. But what I believe hamstrings it in this sphere is the still very fragmented state of business - there are a number of pan-European firms, but they tend to be smaller than US counterparts... or owned by them.
And the situation in tech is worse. I don't believe that Europe is a tech wasteland, because there are some notable companies that have come from there. The problem is that Microsoft has bought all of them (a slight exaggeration, but still).
Where the political fragmentation hurts Europe, even despite the presence of the European Union, is that certain things are still done in a certain way in Italy, compared with Germany, compared with France, and so on. Certain countries' labor markets are more flexible and dynamic than those elsewhere, so all the young people leave their home countries and go to the places where they'll find jobs. This creates a high degree of noise to signal for any budding entrepreneurs, while also starving their home countries of the experience needed to build an innovation ecosystem.
And because I'm a whining Remoaner, it's worth pointing out that leaving the EU won't fix this issue, but rather make it worse. It's not pro-EU propaganda to point out that companies want to do business in a harmonized environment, and when multiple countries harmonize their environments it becomes easier to conduct that business.
To summarize, the problem for Europe is creating enough space for innovative companies to flourish without all decamping to the Silicon Valley (this is a two-fer of self-interest for me, because it makes Europe more dynamic and it keeps loads of Europeans from coming here to the Bay Area and putting even more strain on it). Part of the problem is being able to scale a company to a point where it can compete globally, and the other part is simply having room in the market to do things in tech - for example, who needs another search engine when everybody just uses Google?
This assumes that having large companies is the only measure of success, which to be clear I don't believe. Germany's economy is built on an enormous number of small and medium-sized enterprises that act as suppliers to big ones, for example in the car industry. But having enough small companies creating goods that are in demand is an important prerequisite.
I don't believe that European countries are setting themselves up well to do that. Too many of them are still too protectionist (for example France and its insistence on farming subsidies), while attempts to limit movement from outside the EU, or from the EU into Britain, won't help the underlying causes of population movement.
In fact, if we take a look at the history of Latin America, there was a time when countries like Argentina, Brazil and Chile were much more active internationally. However, they fell into a period of economic nationalism, political populism and military rule, which caused them to fall behind the countries of Europe. Folks in the global north may know of Eva Peron from Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical Evita, but in truth her husband's regime made Argentina ungovernable, and ripe for the military takeover that blighted the country for decades.
As Europe splits off into different populist or nationalist camps, whether in Hungary, Poland or the UK, they should look at the history of Latin http://frad-lab.blogspot.com/2020/03/how-scandinavian-design-and-social.htmlAmerica and avoid the pitfalls those companies hit, to avoid the same fate.
Sunday, 1 March 2020
How Scandinavian Design and Social Democracy are Linked
I found myself thinking about Scandinavia again on my walk today. Specifically, I thought about the architecture, and the design more generally, and the way we've fetishized it here in the US for several decades. And then I wondered whether that interest in Scandinavian design and architecture is connected to the progressive love for Scandinavian social democratic politics.
A google search for the furniture chain here in the Bay Area also turns up a showroom in New York that closed in 2014, but effectively they date back to the 1950s and 1960s, when Americans were apparently crazy for stuff from Europe, as it smacked of sophistication (per Bill Bryson and his book, The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid). My memory of the retail chain here in the Bay Area is of my parents shopping for furniture there (and it being super expensive).
Somewhere along the line clean, functional lines and blond wood became catnip for people who vote progressive. My theory is that this love for Scandinavian design is what came first, but that as the right wing here in the US became more nativist and xenophobic the left held up its love of Scandinavia as the perfect photo-negative to stand in opposition.
This isn't at all scientific, of course, or a ground-breaking idea. But I think the fact that the love for Scandinavian design came first might be. And moreover, the eye-rolling that it prompts among people on the right or even among the more bien-pensant types is clearly a reaction to generations of lefties telling us how everything would be great if we were just more like Sweden, Norway and Denmark. And let's throw in Finland, even though as a Finno-Ugric speaking country we have to expand our designation to "Nordic" to include it.
I have my own love-hate relationship with this type of thinking. On the one hand I can't get enough of books where some foreigner moves to the Nordics and gets all dewy-eyed at the social democracy and supposed happiness. On the other, I get a little frustrated how I and my fellow lefties just invoke Danish or Finnish family leave policies without understanding how they work or what kind of infrastructure is involved with delivering them. Both are likely the reasons why I devour the type of book referenced above: I want to live in that kind of (seemingly) effortless simplicity and I want to understand how they've actually implemented it.
It also doesn't help when the books explaining that implementation are so self-satisfied. A book that's affected my thinking quite heavily in the last year or so is The Nordic Theory of Everything, by Finnish journalist Anu Partanen, in which she explains her culture shock at moving to the US to be with her new husband, and how backward we are in things like delivering healthcare and providing education.
I'm on-board with arguments like that, but given how frustrated I was with her didactic tone, I find myself having to dole out arguments based on her book very carefully, lest I turn off the people I'm trying to persuade.
But what does this have to do with my original thesis, about Scandinavian design? The point that probably a lot of my fellow lefties miss (or forget) is that the best examples of this design are intended to be democratic and available to everyone. A womb chair from Saarinen designs may run you to over a thousand dollars online, but the Finnish architect Alvar Aalto designed housing for veterans returning from the Winter War in the 1940s and for workers at various companies and factories throughout Finland.
This is perhaps a roundabout way of saying that if we want to valorize these ideas from Scandinavia, we need to emphasize how they benefit everyone, without taking for granted that normal voters will just automatically see the benefits of single-payer healthcare or generous family leave. Americans have been abused (for instance) by the corporate and Byzantine healthcare system for so long that they're mistrustful of any change that potentially makes it more difficult for them to get healthcare.
Add to that the constant drumbeat of "socialism = evil" and "Europe = socialist", and it's easy to see why even supposed progressives like Pete Buttigieg evince a sort of Stockholm syndrome for our existing system (btw, do you see what I did there?).
If we agree with Le Corbusier's argument that a house is a machine for living, then you could say that Scandinavian architecture and design are machines that just work, no fuss and no muss. If we want to take it a step further and import their healthcare systems and general organization of society, we need to emphasize that simplicity first and foremost. Then maybe we'll have a chance to sell more Americans on the concept.
A google search for the furniture chain here in the Bay Area also turns up a showroom in New York that closed in 2014, but effectively they date back to the 1950s and 1960s, when Americans were apparently crazy for stuff from Europe, as it smacked of sophistication (per Bill Bryson and his book, The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid). My memory of the retail chain here in the Bay Area is of my parents shopping for furniture there (and it being super expensive).
Somewhere along the line clean, functional lines and blond wood became catnip for people who vote progressive. My theory is that this love for Scandinavian design is what came first, but that as the right wing here in the US became more nativist and xenophobic the left held up its love of Scandinavia as the perfect photo-negative to stand in opposition.
This isn't at all scientific, of course, or a ground-breaking idea. But I think the fact that the love for Scandinavian design came first might be. And moreover, the eye-rolling that it prompts among people on the right or even among the more bien-pensant types is clearly a reaction to generations of lefties telling us how everything would be great if we were just more like Sweden, Norway and Denmark. And let's throw in Finland, even though as a Finno-Ugric speaking country we have to expand our designation to "Nordic" to include it.
I have my own love-hate relationship with this type of thinking. On the one hand I can't get enough of books where some foreigner moves to the Nordics and gets all dewy-eyed at the social democracy and supposed happiness. On the other, I get a little frustrated how I and my fellow lefties just invoke Danish or Finnish family leave policies without understanding how they work or what kind of infrastructure is involved with delivering them. Both are likely the reasons why I devour the type of book referenced above: I want to live in that kind of (seemingly) effortless simplicity and I want to understand how they've actually implemented it.
It also doesn't help when the books explaining that implementation are so self-satisfied. A book that's affected my thinking quite heavily in the last year or so is The Nordic Theory of Everything, by Finnish journalist Anu Partanen, in which she explains her culture shock at moving to the US to be with her new husband, and how backward we are in things like delivering healthcare and providing education.
I'm on-board with arguments like that, but given how frustrated I was with her didactic tone, I find myself having to dole out arguments based on her book very carefully, lest I turn off the people I'm trying to persuade.
But what does this have to do with my original thesis, about Scandinavian design? The point that probably a lot of my fellow lefties miss (or forget) is that the best examples of this design are intended to be democratic and available to everyone. A womb chair from Saarinen designs may run you to over a thousand dollars online, but the Finnish architect Alvar Aalto designed housing for veterans returning from the Winter War in the 1940s and for workers at various companies and factories throughout Finland.
This is perhaps a roundabout way of saying that if we want to valorize these ideas from Scandinavia, we need to emphasize how they benefit everyone, without taking for granted that normal voters will just automatically see the benefits of single-payer healthcare or generous family leave. Americans have been abused (for instance) by the corporate and Byzantine healthcare system for so long that they're mistrustful of any change that potentially makes it more difficult for them to get healthcare.
Add to that the constant drumbeat of "socialism = evil" and "Europe = socialist", and it's easy to see why even supposed progressives like Pete Buttigieg evince a sort of Stockholm syndrome for our existing system (btw, do you see what I did there?).
If we agree with Le Corbusier's argument that a house is a machine for living, then you could say that Scandinavian architecture and design are machines that just work, no fuss and no muss. If we want to take it a step further and import their healthcare systems and general organization of society, we need to emphasize that simplicity first and foremost. Then maybe we'll have a chance to sell more Americans on the concept.
Sunday, 23 February 2020
A Little Hatred by Joe Abercrombie
Another book review here, and another sequel to a well-loved fantasy trilogy from decades past. This time it's A Little Hatred by Joe Abercrombie, his first foray into the world of the First Law since Red Country, and his first trilogy in that world since Last Argument of Kings, the book that wrapped up that trilogy. Another similarity to Empire of Grass and the Lost King of Osten Ard trilogy is that this book picks up around thirty years after the previous trilogy ended, allowing readers to catch up with the characters from the previous books, as well as their offspring.
Unlike Tad Williams's trilogy, I haven't re-read the First Law, or the three standalone novels Abercrombie wrote after those (Best Served Cold, The Heroes and Red Country). This shouldn't imply any judgement on the quality, incidentally - Memory Sorrow and Thorn may rank as one of my favorite series ever, but I've long extolled the virtues of Joe Abercrombie, and I've eagerly snapped up every one of his books as they've come out, apart from the short story collection Sharp Ends.
The reason I bring it up, though, is that this lack of familiarity affected my reading of the book, to an extent. The First Law trilogy can be thought of as analogous to the original Star Wars trilogy, while the three standalones are like Rogue One, Solo and the Mandalorian - outrigger novels that take place in the same world but don't exactly advance the plot or require much prior knowledge. Rather, these more recent books allowed Abercrombie to shift pieces around to prepare for this latest trilogy, entitled The Age of Madness.
However, by not re-reading the previous books I'm a little at sea about who certain characters are. There are callbacks to The Heroes or Best Served Cold, but I'm left wondering if most of the characters whose POVs I'm reading were in those earlier ones (other than Caul Shivers, of course). If you're getting ready to read A Little Hatred, I'd recommend skimming through the previous ones.
Fitting for a writer who epitomizes the "grimdark" sub-genre, to the extent that his Twitter handle is Lord Grimdark (even if he's a little bemused by all the fuss and the epithet attaching to him), the book starts out dark. There's violence, swearing, dodgy sex scenes - everything that characterized his previous books, so if that's what you're after you'll be pleased. It started out a little tough to read, perhaps because I knew I'd be lending my copy to my dad after I finished, but as the book goes on the plot takes shape, allowing Abercrombie to go into more than eviscerations and heads being crushed (lots of those, btw).
Other reviewers have singled out the setting, so I'll do that too, and note that it's fun to see a sort of industrial revolution type of backdrop. The wizard Bayaz, central to the First Law, seems to be involved in a great leap forward to an industrial society and the resulting human misery. This is another area where Abercrombie pulls no punches, depicting not only the horrors of completely untrammeled capitalism but also the madness of the uprising that occurs when one city's workers are pushed too far.
Ignoring the speed with which his secondary world moves from invading "vikings" to dark satanic mills, it allows Abercrombie to tell a story that feels a lot more relevant to the world we're living in than one where we're expected to continue rooting for hereditary government and the divine right of kings. I'd even go so far as to say that perhaps this is a story only a British writer (and a northern English one, at that) could write, since the excesses of the industrial revolution are ingrained into the British soul much more than they are here in the US.
I called Empire of Grass an almost perfect sequel, since it expanded upon the previous trilogy in intriguing ways. It's maybe a little early to say whether The Age of Madness does the same, because I've read just one of the books so far, compared with the two from Tad Williams. It is however, a very good re-entry to the world of the First Law - I may have felt a bit at sea with identifying the characters, but that also made it a good introduction for completely new readers, and the really important stuff is alluded to in ways that make me remember what happened before.
More to the point, there's the feeling of a great big world that Abercrombie can't wait to introduce us to, when we get to Book 2 and Book 3. I just hope we'll get to find out more about what's going on with Bayaz and the infernal bankers of Valint and Balk.
The other thing I'd like to point to is the characterizations. None of the main POV characters is completely great, but nor are they completely awful. Savine dan Glokta's reaction to the uprising is not shocking or overly cliche, and Crown Prince Orso's motivations when he's sent to deal with the uprising are fascinating - he'll be a fun character to watch as we get to the sequels.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Joe Abercrombie is probably one of the best stylists in fantasy fiction at the moment. If he's not quite as lyrical as Guy Gavriel Kay or Neil Gaiman, he's certainly one of the best at putting you in the scene. That it's rarely a pleasant scene is beside the point - we'd be lucky if half the writers of fantasy were as good as him.
Unlike Tad Williams's trilogy, I haven't re-read the First Law, or the three standalone novels Abercrombie wrote after those (Best Served Cold, The Heroes and Red Country). This shouldn't imply any judgement on the quality, incidentally - Memory Sorrow and Thorn may rank as one of my favorite series ever, but I've long extolled the virtues of Joe Abercrombie, and I've eagerly snapped up every one of his books as they've come out, apart from the short story collection Sharp Ends.
The reason I bring it up, though, is that this lack of familiarity affected my reading of the book, to an extent. The First Law trilogy can be thought of as analogous to the original Star Wars trilogy, while the three standalones are like Rogue One, Solo and the Mandalorian - outrigger novels that take place in the same world but don't exactly advance the plot or require much prior knowledge. Rather, these more recent books allowed Abercrombie to shift pieces around to prepare for this latest trilogy, entitled The Age of Madness.
However, by not re-reading the previous books I'm a little at sea about who certain characters are. There are callbacks to The Heroes or Best Served Cold, but I'm left wondering if most of the characters whose POVs I'm reading were in those earlier ones (other than Caul Shivers, of course). If you're getting ready to read A Little Hatred, I'd recommend skimming through the previous ones.
Fitting for a writer who epitomizes the "grimdark" sub-genre, to the extent that his Twitter handle is Lord Grimdark (even if he's a little bemused by all the fuss and the epithet attaching to him), the book starts out dark. There's violence, swearing, dodgy sex scenes - everything that characterized his previous books, so if that's what you're after you'll be pleased. It started out a little tough to read, perhaps because I knew I'd be lending my copy to my dad after I finished, but as the book goes on the plot takes shape, allowing Abercrombie to go into more than eviscerations and heads being crushed (lots of those, btw).
Other reviewers have singled out the setting, so I'll do that too, and note that it's fun to see a sort of industrial revolution type of backdrop. The wizard Bayaz, central to the First Law, seems to be involved in a great leap forward to an industrial society and the resulting human misery. This is another area where Abercrombie pulls no punches, depicting not only the horrors of completely untrammeled capitalism but also the madness of the uprising that occurs when one city's workers are pushed too far.
Ignoring the speed with which his secondary world moves from invading "vikings" to dark satanic mills, it allows Abercrombie to tell a story that feels a lot more relevant to the world we're living in than one where we're expected to continue rooting for hereditary government and the divine right of kings. I'd even go so far as to say that perhaps this is a story only a British writer (and a northern English one, at that) could write, since the excesses of the industrial revolution are ingrained into the British soul much more than they are here in the US.
I called Empire of Grass an almost perfect sequel, since it expanded upon the previous trilogy in intriguing ways. It's maybe a little early to say whether The Age of Madness does the same, because I've read just one of the books so far, compared with the two from Tad Williams. It is however, a very good re-entry to the world of the First Law - I may have felt a bit at sea with identifying the characters, but that also made it a good introduction for completely new readers, and the really important stuff is alluded to in ways that make me remember what happened before.
More to the point, there's the feeling of a great big world that Abercrombie can't wait to introduce us to, when we get to Book 2 and Book 3. I just hope we'll get to find out more about what's going on with Bayaz and the infernal bankers of Valint and Balk.
The other thing I'd like to point to is the characterizations. None of the main POV characters is completely great, but nor are they completely awful. Savine dan Glokta's reaction to the uprising is not shocking or overly cliche, and Crown Prince Orso's motivations when he's sent to deal with the uprising are fascinating - he'll be a fun character to watch as we get to the sequels.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Joe Abercrombie is probably one of the best stylists in fantasy fiction at the moment. If he's not quite as lyrical as Guy Gavriel Kay or Neil Gaiman, he's certainly one of the best at putting you in the scene. That it's rarely a pleasant scene is beside the point - we'd be lucky if half the writers of fantasy were as good as him.
Sunday, 16 February 2020
Election 2020: Don't Lose Sight of the Big Picture
I've touched on my worries about the US pulling out of this death spiral it's currently in, but as that was in the context of seeing how likely it was to follow the example of the UK, I thought it would be worthwhile to write a post on what's happening right now, with the primaries.
Specifically I'm worried about how divided the Democrats are. Despite worries in the media of social media echo chambers, I'd say I have a pretty diverse range of Democratic viewpoints among my Facebook friends and Tweeps (defined here as the people I follow and/or who follow me). There are some who are dyed-in-the-wool for Pete Buttigieg–
OK, I can't finish that sentence without laughing, because who can actually be viciously partisan for Mayor Pete? But it's undeniable that some of my social networks are at least not entirely repelled by him or the centrist/establishment wing of the Democratic Party. At least they're calling into question the whole "Republican-lite" narrative that the more left wing of the party is lobbing at anybody who dares to question the orthodoxy of Medicare-for-all (which, incidentally, I think is a pretty good idea - Medicare for all, I mean, not the questioning).
Then there's that cohort, which considers Bernie Sanders the only candidate who can actually beat Donald Trump and who considers it a bit offensive that anybody should doubt that. Luckily they're cool with Elizabeth Warren, who's my preferred candidate, though I wish she'd go back to talking about corruption and being a wonk, which is, I believe, what let her ride the crest to where she is. Though she's doing so badly in the primaries at the moment that I don't think she'll make it to Super Tuesday.
I have some very close friends and family members in this cohort, so I don't want to be mean, but I do suspect they're the ones who are going to cost us the election, if Sanders fails to get the nomination and they decide not to vote at all. This isn't an idle threat: one such FB friend posted something recently calling Buttigieg a fascist and suggesting he's as bad as Donald Trump. While this is plainly laughable, the comment thread was full of people agreeing with him. One person questioned that narrative, but I fear that questioning will fall on deaf ears.
The plain truth is this, as elucidated by my girlfriend: this is not an election of Joe Biden vs Pete Buttigieg vs Bernie Sanders vs whoever else. This is an election of a Republican incumbent controlled by Russia, vs Democratic challengers who are not. Let me repeat that:
ONE PARTY'S CANDIDATE IS CONTROLLED BY RUSSIA. THOSE FROM THE OTHER PARTY ARE NOT.
This is the single most important consideration. If you think of it in terms of emergency room triage, the Democrats (all wings) are arguing about whether or not to treat the patient's broken leg, while ignoring that the patient is bleeding to death. And yes, I'm targeting my criticism at so-called moderate or centrist Democrats too, because they're also threatening to stay home if Sanders or Warren get nominated.
If this isn't enough to get you to vote for whoever the Democrats choose, then at least these partisans, whichever side they're on, need to vote down-ticket, to ensure that as many Senate and House seats (not to mention judiciary and state-level positions) go to the Democrats, because even if, by some miracle, the Democrat wins the electoral college, they will be hamstrung by a Senate majority that represents a small minority of Americans.
We can argue all we want about Medicare-for-all or Medicare-for-all-who-want it, but if the Democrats don't carry the executive and legislative branches, then there will be Medicare for none. No Medicaid. No Social Security.
If it feels like I'm targeting the left wing of the party here, then it's because I want this wing - which I consider my own wing - to build better arguments for its policies than they've been doing so far. I worry - nay, I shit bricks - when I read that trade unions are against Sanders's healthcare policy. Why hasn't he explained it to them better? Why is the default position that the policy is right but the voters are wrong?
I want single-payer healthcare not because of some ideological need to get closer to socialist utopia, but because I think it has better outcomes, a more fair system of rationing and because it's good for everyone - families, workers and even businesses. But my worry is that the idea gets tainted by being explained badly - or have we already forgotten how Hillary Clinton's attempt to rejig healthcare foundered in the 90s when her husband was president?
Now, when it comes to Mike Bloomberg, I remain slightly skeptical that I want to vote for him - after all, he literally is a Republican (at least, he was while mayor of New York City). More than that, he oversaw the dramatic widening of NYC's income inequality, to a level similar to that in Sierra Leone, and still (STILL) champions stop-and-frisk, a system that not only entrenches racial profiling in policing, but DOES NOT FUCKING WORK.
And yet.
He's not controlled by Russia, is he?
In the unlikely event he gets the nomination, I might just vote down-ticket.
But that's the point: vote. FUCKING VOTE. IN NOVEMBER. Even if the Democrats lose their damn minds and nominate Biden or Klobuchar or that guy from Starbucks. If you live in a safely blue state, like I do, VOTE DOWN TICKET. If you don't live in a blue state, then vote for the fucking Democrat, whether that's Sanders, Biden, Buttigieg or Bloomberg.
Vote for the Democrat whether they're black or white, straight or gay, male or female, rich or poor, left-wing or moderate. But vote for them - because four more years of Trump will make it harder to get healthcare or economic justice or racial justice for anyone.
Don't hand the Republicans another victory like 1972 (520 electoral votes for Nixon to 17 for George McGovern) or like 1984 (525 for Reagan vs 13 for Mondale). Don't hand them that victory because your preferred candidate, whether Sanders or Buttigieg or whoever, didn't win the nomination.
Specifically I'm worried about how divided the Democrats are. Despite worries in the media of social media echo chambers, I'd say I have a pretty diverse range of Democratic viewpoints among my Facebook friends and Tweeps (defined here as the people I follow and/or who follow me). There are some who are dyed-in-the-wool for Pete Buttigieg–
OK, I can't finish that sentence without laughing, because who can actually be viciously partisan for Mayor Pete? But it's undeniable that some of my social networks are at least not entirely repelled by him or the centrist/establishment wing of the Democratic Party. At least they're calling into question the whole "Republican-lite" narrative that the more left wing of the party is lobbing at anybody who dares to question the orthodoxy of Medicare-for-all (which, incidentally, I think is a pretty good idea - Medicare for all, I mean, not the questioning).
Then there's that cohort, which considers Bernie Sanders the only candidate who can actually beat Donald Trump and who considers it a bit offensive that anybody should doubt that. Luckily they're cool with Elizabeth Warren, who's my preferred candidate, though I wish she'd go back to talking about corruption and being a wonk, which is, I believe, what let her ride the crest to where she is. Though she's doing so badly in the primaries at the moment that I don't think she'll make it to Super Tuesday.
I have some very close friends and family members in this cohort, so I don't want to be mean, but I do suspect they're the ones who are going to cost us the election, if Sanders fails to get the nomination and they decide not to vote at all. This isn't an idle threat: one such FB friend posted something recently calling Buttigieg a fascist and suggesting he's as bad as Donald Trump. While this is plainly laughable, the comment thread was full of people agreeing with him. One person questioned that narrative, but I fear that questioning will fall on deaf ears.
The plain truth is this, as elucidated by my girlfriend: this is not an election of Joe Biden vs Pete Buttigieg vs Bernie Sanders vs whoever else. This is an election of a Republican incumbent controlled by Russia, vs Democratic challengers who are not. Let me repeat that:
ONE PARTY'S CANDIDATE IS CONTROLLED BY RUSSIA. THOSE FROM THE OTHER PARTY ARE NOT.
This is the single most important consideration. If you think of it in terms of emergency room triage, the Democrats (all wings) are arguing about whether or not to treat the patient's broken leg, while ignoring that the patient is bleeding to death. And yes, I'm targeting my criticism at so-called moderate or centrist Democrats too, because they're also threatening to stay home if Sanders or Warren get nominated.
If this isn't enough to get you to vote for whoever the Democrats choose, then at least these partisans, whichever side they're on, need to vote down-ticket, to ensure that as many Senate and House seats (not to mention judiciary and state-level positions) go to the Democrats, because even if, by some miracle, the Democrat wins the electoral college, they will be hamstrung by a Senate majority that represents a small minority of Americans.
We can argue all we want about Medicare-for-all or Medicare-for-all-who-want it, but if the Democrats don't carry the executive and legislative branches, then there will be Medicare for none. No Medicaid. No Social Security.
If it feels like I'm targeting the left wing of the party here, then it's because I want this wing - which I consider my own wing - to build better arguments for its policies than they've been doing so far. I worry - nay, I shit bricks - when I read that trade unions are against Sanders's healthcare policy. Why hasn't he explained it to them better? Why is the default position that the policy is right but the voters are wrong?
I want single-payer healthcare not because of some ideological need to get closer to socialist utopia, but because I think it has better outcomes, a more fair system of rationing and because it's good for everyone - families, workers and even businesses. But my worry is that the idea gets tainted by being explained badly - or have we already forgotten how Hillary Clinton's attempt to rejig healthcare foundered in the 90s when her husband was president?
Now, when it comes to Mike Bloomberg, I remain slightly skeptical that I want to vote for him - after all, he literally is a Republican (at least, he was while mayor of New York City). More than that, he oversaw the dramatic widening of NYC's income inequality, to a level similar to that in Sierra Leone, and still (STILL) champions stop-and-frisk, a system that not only entrenches racial profiling in policing, but DOES NOT FUCKING WORK.
And yet.
He's not controlled by Russia, is he?
In the unlikely event he gets the nomination, I might just vote down-ticket.
But that's the point: vote. FUCKING VOTE. IN NOVEMBER. Even if the Democrats lose their damn minds and nominate Biden or Klobuchar or that guy from Starbucks. If you live in a safely blue state, like I do, VOTE DOWN TICKET. If you don't live in a blue state, then vote for the fucking Democrat, whether that's Sanders, Biden, Buttigieg or Bloomberg.
Vote for the Democrat whether they're black or white, straight or gay, male or female, rich or poor, left-wing or moderate. But vote for them - because four more years of Trump will make it harder to get healthcare or economic justice or racial justice for anyone.
Don't hand the Republicans another victory like 1972 (520 electoral votes for Nixon to 17 for George McGovern) or like 1984 (525 for Reagan vs 13 for Mondale). Don't hand them that victory because your preferred candidate, whether Sanders or Buttigieg or whoever, didn't win the nomination.
Sunday, 9 February 2020
Empire of Grass by Tad Williams is an Almost Perfect Sequel
Just finished Empire of Grass a week or so ago, the latest book in The Last King of Osten Ard, Tad Williams's sequel trilogy to Memory, Sorrow and Thorn. MST has long been one of my favorite fantasy series, and I've re-read the books several times, always with great enjoyment. Indeed, my paperback copies are jealously hoarded, especially now that I've had Tad himself sign almost all of the volumes, each at a different author event where I met him.
I always appreciated the conversation that MST tried to have with JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings - a conversation it has more successfully than other series like Terry Brooks's Shannara or Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time. Like many of those books MST is based on the search for a magical maguffin, this time in the shape of three powerful swords - though I've always loved the unexpected way he approached that trope.
Last King of Osten Ard looks like it's aiming to have that same conversation, but with its own predecessor trilogy. Instead of the happy(ish) ending holding through, we see how the actual governance of the realm has panned out in the thirty years since To Green Angel Tower ended. A lot of the reviews I've read of the books so far laud this aspect, how Simon's turned out to be not actually that good a ruler after all, and I have to agree it makes for good drama.
But I think my favorite part of this new trilogy is how it expands on the concepts we saw in the earlier books, especially the culture of the Norns. Beginning in the prequel novella The Heart of What Was Lost, Williams fleshed their culture out beyond the "evil elves" we saw in MST, depicting a culture of casual cruelty, rigid caste and paranoia at every level. In some ways it reminds me of his depiction of Hell in the Bobby Dollar series, where life was a daily grind of ever-more horrible things being done by whoever was in power to whoever was below them.
Norn culture is a little less chaotic than that, but it feels like a continuation of the same ideas, especially the casual way the Norns treat human and non-human life.
This is why in my title I call it "almost perfect" - it doesn't ignore what happened before, doesn't retcon it, but rather fills in the gaps very well. Another example is his description of the Tinukeda'ya, the delvers and niskies of MST: here they're depicted as a race so malleable that we realize we've been seeing versions of them in previous stories that we didn't even recognize as such. The giants, kilpa and ghants of MST turn out to be Tinukeda'ya as well, which is a neat idea.
I do have a small criticism. Certain threads and storylines verge on the predictable, like Miriamele's time in the snake pit of Nabban, where you can tell that there's going to be a tragedy of some kind. When it climaxes it's different than expected, but there's still a lingering frustration that the characters haven't cottoned on to what's going on when it's so clear to us, the readers.
Another example is the storyline of Unver, and the coming war of his grasslander tribes against the settled peoples of Osten Ard - though there it's more a feeling of suspense at knowing where Williams has placed all this characters and wanting to see how things play out.
But if you can tell where broad strokes of the story are going, Williams still manages to surprise in the particulars. For example he resolves the question of where Prince Josua's children, Derra and Deornoth, are in the first volume, The Witchwood Crown, and does so in very satisfying ways. He doesn't resolve the question of Josua's whereabouts in this volume, but the search illuminates the intervening span of years between trilogies in interesting ways.
Another example is the way he resolves the storyline in Nabban, which sets up a greater tragedy to befall the characters in the next volume - and after all, over the whole trilogy hangs that name, the "last" king of Osten Ard. You sense that it's all building to a crescendo that won't be as happy or neatly tied up as Memory, Sorrow and Thorn - but I trust Tad Williams enough that I know it'll be entertaining.
I always appreciated the conversation that MST tried to have with JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings - a conversation it has more successfully than other series like Terry Brooks's Shannara or Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time. Like many of those books MST is based on the search for a magical maguffin, this time in the shape of three powerful swords - though I've always loved the unexpected way he approached that trope.
Last King of Osten Ard looks like it's aiming to have that same conversation, but with its own predecessor trilogy. Instead of the happy(ish) ending holding through, we see how the actual governance of the realm has panned out in the thirty years since To Green Angel Tower ended. A lot of the reviews I've read of the books so far laud this aspect, how Simon's turned out to be not actually that good a ruler after all, and I have to agree it makes for good drama.
But I think my favorite part of this new trilogy is how it expands on the concepts we saw in the earlier books, especially the culture of the Norns. Beginning in the prequel novella The Heart of What Was Lost, Williams fleshed their culture out beyond the "evil elves" we saw in MST, depicting a culture of casual cruelty, rigid caste and paranoia at every level. In some ways it reminds me of his depiction of Hell in the Bobby Dollar series, where life was a daily grind of ever-more horrible things being done by whoever was in power to whoever was below them.
Norn culture is a little less chaotic than that, but it feels like a continuation of the same ideas, especially the casual way the Norns treat human and non-human life.
This is why in my title I call it "almost perfect" - it doesn't ignore what happened before, doesn't retcon it, but rather fills in the gaps very well. Another example is his description of the Tinukeda'ya, the delvers and niskies of MST: here they're depicted as a race so malleable that we realize we've been seeing versions of them in previous stories that we didn't even recognize as such. The giants, kilpa and ghants of MST turn out to be Tinukeda'ya as well, which is a neat idea.
I do have a small criticism. Certain threads and storylines verge on the predictable, like Miriamele's time in the snake pit of Nabban, where you can tell that there's going to be a tragedy of some kind. When it climaxes it's different than expected, but there's still a lingering frustration that the characters haven't cottoned on to what's going on when it's so clear to us, the readers.
Another example is the storyline of Unver, and the coming war of his grasslander tribes against the settled peoples of Osten Ard - though there it's more a feeling of suspense at knowing where Williams has placed all this characters and wanting to see how things play out.
But if you can tell where broad strokes of the story are going, Williams still manages to surprise in the particulars. For example he resolves the question of where Prince Josua's children, Derra and Deornoth, are in the first volume, The Witchwood Crown, and does so in very satisfying ways. He doesn't resolve the question of Josua's whereabouts in this volume, but the search illuminates the intervening span of years between trilogies in interesting ways.
Another example is the way he resolves the storyline in Nabban, which sets up a greater tragedy to befall the characters in the next volume - and after all, over the whole trilogy hangs that name, the "last" king of Osten Ard. You sense that it's all building to a crescendo that won't be as happy or neatly tied up as Memory, Sorrow and Thorn - but I trust Tad Williams enough that I know it'll be entertaining.
Thursday, 30 January 2020
We Need to Talk About Baby Yoda: Thoughts on the Mandalorian
Just finished the Mandalorian this weekend, as my girlfriend and I have had our attention pulled from Disney+ by her DVDs of Boston Legal and by the first season of Project Blue Book. But we got on the Baby Yoda bandwagon fairly early, and I'd say we've enjoyed the show a lot - especially in light of what the movies have been serving up.
In fact, it's probably fair to say that the Mandalorian is the best Star Wars to come out since Rogue One, or possibly even since the original trilogy (since Rogue One, as much as I love it, suffers from some serious character problems).
I haven't devoted an entire blog to it, but I was quite disappointed by Episode 9. The first hour is a headache-inducing mass of set pieces, with plot points pulled out of nowhere to satisfy the filmmakers' need to move the plot along. I'm reminded of critiques I used to get on my own writing, where beta readers would accuse me of placing characters in certain situations because the plot demanded it, rather than it being organically driven by the characters themselves.
I've seen other instances of it since then, but this is potentially one of the worst - the Emperor Palpatine, who hasn't appeared in any of the sequel trilogy films until now, just announces his return to the galaxy. Off-screen.
Why? Because JJ Abrams needs him to.
The Last Jedi was also a bit frustrating for me, as it wastes a bunch of characters and has to be walked back by Rise of Skywalker, even if I could appreciate the swing for the fences.
And Solo was fine, though not necessarily ground-breaking. I also find it hard to forgive the filmmakers for how they came up with Han's last name.
So, you could say that the public's been waiting for a nice, enjoyable, non-divisive Star Wars movie or show or, well, anything. And we've got that in the shape of the Mandalorian.
If we accept that Star Wars has always been an exercise in remixing tropes and visuals from other movies and genres, then it's not such a large leap to suggesting that the most successful Star Wars movies are those that wear its influences most proudly. Episode 4 is a prime example, with kissing princesses (who are also pretty dab hands with a blaster), swinging across chasms and fighter battles lifted straight from World War II movies as its clearest "homages" to what's gone before.
Westerns, samurai movies and Dune are also heavily in the mix, as we see in that movie and in the next two films in the original trilogy. Rogue One also wears its influences pretty proudly, and the Mandalorian joins this tradition by clearly being a space western, just as clearly as Firefly was.
Like Clint Eastwood's spaghetti westerns, the main character swaggers onto the screen with barely a word, no hint of his name or face or background. We spend the first episode learning about what he does for a living, watching him move toward the moment where he has to decide whether to follow his principles or his quest for more beskar steel. Though let's be honest, it's easy to follow your principles when they involve saving an adorable Baby Yoda from being blasted by an assassin droid.
The next few episodes take the space western thing and run with it, as he fights off assassins trying to get his prize, goes running elsewhere and gets involved in Seven Samurai-style adventures to help a peaceful village fight off raiders. And at last he gathers the folks who've helped him up until now, to face down the Empire - featuring surprisingly affecting deaths of several characters on the way.
Thinking about the show this way, it feels like storytelling - or rather, just telling a good story - is at the heart of the Mandalorian the way it hasn't been for Star Wars for... well, decades. Part of what ruins the prequels is the fact that you know what's going to happen to the characters. Part of what ruins the sequels is the feeling that Rey's story, at the final reckoning, is inessential.
The thing that made Rogue One work for me was the way it fit into the tapestry of the earlier movies - it doesn't retcon anything (at least, not to a significant degree), but rather fills in some blanks and leads into Episode 4 in quite a satisfying way, while also showing you other aspects of the universe that still fit in with what we know of Star Wars.
The Mandalorian manages this at the other end of the original trilogy, taking place after the collapse of the Empire in Return of the Jedi, but showing how the galaxy has been thrown into chaos by the death of Palpatine and the formation of the New Republic. Imperial forces are still running around, but they're a little dustier and dirtier, more warlords than Imperial officers - which feels like a cool plot development.
The Mandalorian is also probably the most sympathetic main character Star Wars has had in a while. You have to appreciate the acting job that Pedro Pascal does in the lead role, since his face is covered the whole time and his voice is mostly muffled by his helmet, taking away the two most important tools in an actor's arsenal. Yet he still conveys a range of emotion through the helmet, for example when he's tenderly taking care of Baby Yoda.
The Child (to give him his official name) is also a great addition, since he fills that time-honored niche of cute sidekick that R2-D2 and BB8 have done such a good job with since 1977. He's a marvel of digital and practical effects, and his eyes and ears are so expressive that you can't take your eyes off him whenever he's on screen. You might scoff at a grown man fawning over a cute puppet, but that contrast between hardened killer and innocent child makes for great drama (while also being a nice callback to Lone Wolf and Cub).
Given what a nice job they did with the Mandalorian, one hopes that the creative team, and especially show runner Jon Favreau, gets hired to make the next few Star Wars movies. But then, what do you expect from the director whose vision brought us the first Iron Man movie, and with it the whole MCU?
In fact, it's probably fair to say that the Mandalorian is the best Star Wars to come out since Rogue One, or possibly even since the original trilogy (since Rogue One, as much as I love it, suffers from some serious character problems).
I haven't devoted an entire blog to it, but I was quite disappointed by Episode 9. The first hour is a headache-inducing mass of set pieces, with plot points pulled out of nowhere to satisfy the filmmakers' need to move the plot along. I'm reminded of critiques I used to get on my own writing, where beta readers would accuse me of placing characters in certain situations because the plot demanded it, rather than it being organically driven by the characters themselves.
I've seen other instances of it since then, but this is potentially one of the worst - the Emperor Palpatine, who hasn't appeared in any of the sequel trilogy films until now, just announces his return to the galaxy. Off-screen.
Why? Because JJ Abrams needs him to.
The Last Jedi was also a bit frustrating for me, as it wastes a bunch of characters and has to be walked back by Rise of Skywalker, even if I could appreciate the swing for the fences.
And Solo was fine, though not necessarily ground-breaking. I also find it hard to forgive the filmmakers for how they came up with Han's last name.
So, you could say that the public's been waiting for a nice, enjoyable, non-divisive Star Wars movie or show or, well, anything. And we've got that in the shape of the Mandalorian.
If we accept that Star Wars has always been an exercise in remixing tropes and visuals from other movies and genres, then it's not such a large leap to suggesting that the most successful Star Wars movies are those that wear its influences most proudly. Episode 4 is a prime example, with kissing princesses (who are also pretty dab hands with a blaster), swinging across chasms and fighter battles lifted straight from World War II movies as its clearest "homages" to what's gone before.
Westerns, samurai movies and Dune are also heavily in the mix, as we see in that movie and in the next two films in the original trilogy. Rogue One also wears its influences pretty proudly, and the Mandalorian joins this tradition by clearly being a space western, just as clearly as Firefly was.
Like Clint Eastwood's spaghetti westerns, the main character swaggers onto the screen with barely a word, no hint of his name or face or background. We spend the first episode learning about what he does for a living, watching him move toward the moment where he has to decide whether to follow his principles or his quest for more beskar steel. Though let's be honest, it's easy to follow your principles when they involve saving an adorable Baby Yoda from being blasted by an assassin droid.
The next few episodes take the space western thing and run with it, as he fights off assassins trying to get his prize, goes running elsewhere and gets involved in Seven Samurai-style adventures to help a peaceful village fight off raiders. And at last he gathers the folks who've helped him up until now, to face down the Empire - featuring surprisingly affecting deaths of several characters on the way.
Thinking about the show this way, it feels like storytelling - or rather, just telling a good story - is at the heart of the Mandalorian the way it hasn't been for Star Wars for... well, decades. Part of what ruins the prequels is the fact that you know what's going to happen to the characters. Part of what ruins the sequels is the feeling that Rey's story, at the final reckoning, is inessential.
The thing that made Rogue One work for me was the way it fit into the tapestry of the earlier movies - it doesn't retcon anything (at least, not to a significant degree), but rather fills in some blanks and leads into Episode 4 in quite a satisfying way, while also showing you other aspects of the universe that still fit in with what we know of Star Wars.
The Mandalorian manages this at the other end of the original trilogy, taking place after the collapse of the Empire in Return of the Jedi, but showing how the galaxy has been thrown into chaos by the death of Palpatine and the formation of the New Republic. Imperial forces are still running around, but they're a little dustier and dirtier, more warlords than Imperial officers - which feels like a cool plot development.
The Mandalorian is also probably the most sympathetic main character Star Wars has had in a while. You have to appreciate the acting job that Pedro Pascal does in the lead role, since his face is covered the whole time and his voice is mostly muffled by his helmet, taking away the two most important tools in an actor's arsenal. Yet he still conveys a range of emotion through the helmet, for example when he's tenderly taking care of Baby Yoda.
The Child (to give him his official name) is also a great addition, since he fills that time-honored niche of cute sidekick that R2-D2 and BB8 have done such a good job with since 1977. He's a marvel of digital and practical effects, and his eyes and ears are so expressive that you can't take your eyes off him whenever he's on screen. You might scoff at a grown man fawning over a cute puppet, but that contrast between hardened killer and innocent child makes for great drama (while also being a nice callback to Lone Wolf and Cub).
Given what a nice job they did with the Mandalorian, one hopes that the creative team, and especially show runner Jon Favreau, gets hired to make the next few Star Wars movies. But then, what do you expect from the director whose vision brought us the first Iron Man movie, and with it the whole MCU?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)