Coming back to live in the town where I grew up carries some odd associations with it. I drive by certain spots, and my thoughts turn to the music I was listening to or the comics or books I was reading. I think I've mentioned this in the past few years, since moving back from London, but it's been thrown into sharper relief in the past six weeks, as I've switched from working out at the gym to running or walking in my old neighborhood.
I passed through different parts of the old neighborhood on two occasions today. The first was this morning, when I went on my run that took me past my old house and my old elementary school. The second was on a big walk after lunch, when I passed the elementary school again and walked around the houses of friends from those years.
As I thought about afternoons spent playing Star Tropics at one friend's house, it struck me (as it frequently does) how much replaying games or re-experiencing certain media is more an attempt to recapture the feeling of experiencing those things for the first time.
Not only that, but this nostalgia affects what I write. I'm aware of tics and idiosyncrasies that come straight from the comics and science fiction novels I was reading in high school, and I'd say the past few years have been a never-ending attempt to purge these tics from the way I tell my stories.
Or maybe I shouldn't be so quick to completely purge them - part of what informs a person's personality is the conversation they have as adults with the lessons they drew from media they experienced as kids. As a teenager I wanted more space battles and more questioning of Gene Roddenberry's vision from Star Trek; as a man in middle age I get tired of the bombast of shows like Discovery and want to get back to stories about how smart and well-intentioned people tackle problems like adults.
At the same time, it feels odd to write that I'm "a man in middle age", because the teenager (or child), as I was then, never feels so far from the surface. Part of it is dismay at the passage of time, and the thought that I get ever closer to decay and irrelevance and oblivion, but part is also cognitive dissonance that the "I" encompasses such a different person now compared with back then.
Paradoxically I might not feel this disconnect so clearly if I'd stayed in Palo Alto the entire time, or if I'd come straight back after college. My suspicion is that the disconnect is more marked, and appears in such specific places, because I'm confronted with triggers to these memories for the first time since I formed them. And in the case of spots I pass more frequently, it's become my habit to think about how those places reminded me of the video game or book or comic, which brings up memories of the thing again.
It's a reminder of how the brain forms grooves and your thoughts fit along those grooves quite easily, whether you like it or not. What's funny is that it also happens with new stuff I experience now - certain things remind me of working out in or wandering around London, despite there not being any explicit link. These memories then trigger thoughts of specific things I used to do or friends I used to hang out with, and as I return to the piece of media (for example a YouTube video) I'm reminded of the place or person I was thinking of the last time I watched it.
Brains are weird.
At any rate, it's a funny phenomenon that I think back to the Legion of Superheroes whenever I pass by the first condo complex my dad lived in after he and my mom split up, or that I think of the Quick Man level from Megaman 2 whenever I walk by the community center where I used to play kids' league basketball. I suppose you could call them both traumatic experiences, in their own way (basketball gave me nightmares for years afterwards), but it's interesting how the brain creates full snapshots of memories, and the weirdest triggers bring them back.
Proust, of course, wrote about this at length in A La Recherche du Temps Perdu, but we can only imagine what he'd have had to say about a reboot of his favorite comic series or the feeling of finally beating one of Megaman 2's toughest bosses. In the absence of his thoughts on these topics, I can only say that it's not always bitter to get back to that child-mind, or to see the continuity of my own sense of self between then and now. The question is whether I'll feel the same about the shows and books and whatever that I'm experiencing now, when I revisit them in twenty years' time.
Or maybe I'll just still be thinking of Megaman 2?
Sunday, 19 April 2020
Sunday, 12 April 2020
The Start of the Story: John Le Carre's The Night Manager
One of the best distractions from the terrors of my own to-read shelf is the bookshelves in the living room that contain my dad's books. There are obscure trashy fantasy novels alongside ponderous histories of Venice and the Silk Road, and there are Italian literary masterpieces alongside British mystery novels from the early twentieth century.
And then there are all the John Le Carré novels my dad has collected over the decades. Last year, on a whim, I picked up the Night Manager, because I'd seen the first episode (or two, I can't remember now) of the TV show when it came out in 2015 or so. I remembered the mood and the visuals, and how menacingly well-cast Hugh Laurie was as Richard Roper, the worst man in the world.
And now that I've gone back and watched the show, I wanted to look at the start of the novel and see if there were any lessons to take away from it - overall it's not my favorite of his books, but that initial section covers a lot of sins. And the story is probably more relevant now than when he published it, back in 1993, since we're a lot more conscious of the Faustian bargains governments make with the super-rich of various countries.
Where the show starts in Cairo, taking good advantage of the atmosphere of the Arab Spring to set the table for the meeting between Roper and Jonathan Pine in Switzerland years later, the book starts on that night in Switzerland. And where the show demonstrates what a consummate professional Jonathan is by having him calmly tell a guest during gunfire that the drinks in the hotel bar are free, the opening scene in Switzerland demonstrates that by describing how he's turned out in ways designed to appeal to the richer clients.
Coming back to my last post on "world-building", way back in 2015 when I had just re-read Hyperion by Dan Simmons, then I marveled at how Simmons packed all his themes into the first paragraph, and then played them out over the course of four books. Here Le Carré presents a different trick, of drawing in great detail the world that Jonathan lives in at the start of the story.
Meister's Hotel in Zurich is a world unto itself, after the fashion of the great old establishments of Europe. It's populated by the eccentrics that always populate Le Carré's books, such as Herr Kaspar, the concierge whose toupee was his stand of dignity against an overbearing client; or Frau Loring, who "had been Herr Meister's nanny, and as rumor had it, Herr Meister's father's mistress". It's also a building with its own stories to tell, like the grill room that Herr Meister has got it into his head to build, surpassing the understanding of the rest of the staff.
Because Jonathan is the night manager, per the title, the prose reflects the silence of his life at Meister's, and that in turn reflects the sense of a man hiding from life. To underscore the point, one of the letters he reads while waiting for Roper's party to arrive is from a guest with whom he had some form of potentially romantic relationship, but to whom he was emotionally distant. And to underscore that silence, and that feeling of being cut off, Roper arrives during the middle of a snowstorm, an apparition materializing from the outside world wreathed in quiet white.
And then Roper enters, and the story begins. The story, in this case, being the arrogance of the moneyed classes, the way they live a life apart from everyone else and the way that nothing - not bad weather, nor being out of the lobster salad - impinges on them getting what they want. Not even laws against selling arms to terrorists and mercenaries.
In a way the show is more successful than the book at depicting this. That might be because the flavor of rich bastard is more recognizable (Roper is first seen giving what looks like a TED or Davos talk on Youtube), and because the show takes place against the backdrop of Tahrir Square. And also it's the advantage that visual media have over prose, which has to spend a lot of words explaining and describing and suggesting all of the things that TV just shows you in a single frame.
That's not to say the book is bad. It suffers from a hundred-page stretch that the show dispenses with in about 15 minutes, but both do a good job of showing the corrupting influence of money, and how in the post-Soviet world capitalism became amoral. We live in a world where, instead of having to burnish your reputation the way the robber barons of the 1800s did, just the act of having money makes you Someone. This is down to the official bodyguards and the artfully ruffled but still upper-class younger girlfriend.
And it's not even about a clash between old money and nouveau riche, though Roper himself is proud of having come from humbler circumstances. Rather, his entry at Meister's shows the unthinking disruption that Roper's class inflicts - doesn't matter if we arrive in a snowstorm, the chasseurs will still be there to roll out the red carpet, because the old guard has lost its money and power, and can't exclude people like Roper anymore.
The book addresses Jonathan's past in Cairo much more openly than the show. In the show, he leaves his time in Cairo out of his CV, which makes him better able to disguise who he is. In the book, he tells Roper straight away that his previous job was in Cairo, but in the end it doesn't matter, because Roper's not the sort to remember the night manager in a hotel where he had a woman murdered for sharing out his arms deals.
Again, The Night Manager doesn't pack all its themes into its first paragraph the way Hyperion does. There's a reference to the Gulf War, which had just started, and the repercussions it has on both the stock market and the bookings at Meister's could signal the shockwaves that Roper's arrival has on Jonathan's somnolent life in Switzerland. But I see the section at Meister's more as Le Carré setting the table, showing us the rules of the world Jonathan has lived in as an employee of the better hotels, before plunging him, and us, into the far murkier world of arms deals and illicit sanction given thereto by governments in the name of catching "bigger fish".
You could argue that the fall of the USSR deprived thriller writers like John Le Carré of their subject matter. James Bond, for one, was never the same after 1991. The Night Manager was his first novel after that, and it's fair to say that it was the first sign of the direction he would take for the next few books, more enraged at the misdeeds of the moneyed classes than worked up by the Cold War.
What makes it impressive, if disheartening, is the way that message resonates even louder today than it did then, when the West was still basking in the glory of its victory over communism.
And then there are all the John Le Carré novels my dad has collected over the decades. Last year, on a whim, I picked up the Night Manager, because I'd seen the first episode (or two, I can't remember now) of the TV show when it came out in 2015 or so. I remembered the mood and the visuals, and how menacingly well-cast Hugh Laurie was as Richard Roper, the worst man in the world.
And now that I've gone back and watched the show, I wanted to look at the start of the novel and see if there were any lessons to take away from it - overall it's not my favorite of his books, but that initial section covers a lot of sins. And the story is probably more relevant now than when he published it, back in 1993, since we're a lot more conscious of the Faustian bargains governments make with the super-rich of various countries.
Where the show starts in Cairo, taking good advantage of the atmosphere of the Arab Spring to set the table for the meeting between Roper and Jonathan Pine in Switzerland years later, the book starts on that night in Switzerland. And where the show demonstrates what a consummate professional Jonathan is by having him calmly tell a guest during gunfire that the drinks in the hotel bar are free, the opening scene in Switzerland demonstrates that by describing how he's turned out in ways designed to appeal to the richer clients.
Coming back to my last post on "world-building", way back in 2015 when I had just re-read Hyperion by Dan Simmons, then I marveled at how Simmons packed all his themes into the first paragraph, and then played them out over the course of four books. Here Le Carré presents a different trick, of drawing in great detail the world that Jonathan lives in at the start of the story.
Meister's Hotel in Zurich is a world unto itself, after the fashion of the great old establishments of Europe. It's populated by the eccentrics that always populate Le Carré's books, such as Herr Kaspar, the concierge whose toupee was his stand of dignity against an overbearing client; or Frau Loring, who "had been Herr Meister's nanny, and as rumor had it, Herr Meister's father's mistress". It's also a building with its own stories to tell, like the grill room that Herr Meister has got it into his head to build, surpassing the understanding of the rest of the staff.
Because Jonathan is the night manager, per the title, the prose reflects the silence of his life at Meister's, and that in turn reflects the sense of a man hiding from life. To underscore the point, one of the letters he reads while waiting for Roper's party to arrive is from a guest with whom he had some form of potentially romantic relationship, but to whom he was emotionally distant. And to underscore that silence, and that feeling of being cut off, Roper arrives during the middle of a snowstorm, an apparition materializing from the outside world wreathed in quiet white.
And then Roper enters, and the story begins. The story, in this case, being the arrogance of the moneyed classes, the way they live a life apart from everyone else and the way that nothing - not bad weather, nor being out of the lobster salad - impinges on them getting what they want. Not even laws against selling arms to terrorists and mercenaries.
In a way the show is more successful than the book at depicting this. That might be because the flavor of rich bastard is more recognizable (Roper is first seen giving what looks like a TED or Davos talk on Youtube), and because the show takes place against the backdrop of Tahrir Square. And also it's the advantage that visual media have over prose, which has to spend a lot of words explaining and describing and suggesting all of the things that TV just shows you in a single frame.
That's not to say the book is bad. It suffers from a hundred-page stretch that the show dispenses with in about 15 minutes, but both do a good job of showing the corrupting influence of money, and how in the post-Soviet world capitalism became amoral. We live in a world where, instead of having to burnish your reputation the way the robber barons of the 1800s did, just the act of having money makes you Someone. This is down to the official bodyguards and the artfully ruffled but still upper-class younger girlfriend.
And it's not even about a clash between old money and nouveau riche, though Roper himself is proud of having come from humbler circumstances. Rather, his entry at Meister's shows the unthinking disruption that Roper's class inflicts - doesn't matter if we arrive in a snowstorm, the chasseurs will still be there to roll out the red carpet, because the old guard has lost its money and power, and can't exclude people like Roper anymore.
The book addresses Jonathan's past in Cairo much more openly than the show. In the show, he leaves his time in Cairo out of his CV, which makes him better able to disguise who he is. In the book, he tells Roper straight away that his previous job was in Cairo, but in the end it doesn't matter, because Roper's not the sort to remember the night manager in a hotel where he had a woman murdered for sharing out his arms deals.
Again, The Night Manager doesn't pack all its themes into its first paragraph the way Hyperion does. There's a reference to the Gulf War, which had just started, and the repercussions it has on both the stock market and the bookings at Meister's could signal the shockwaves that Roper's arrival has on Jonathan's somnolent life in Switzerland. But I see the section at Meister's more as Le Carré setting the table, showing us the rules of the world Jonathan has lived in as an employee of the better hotels, before plunging him, and us, into the far murkier world of arms deals and illicit sanction given thereto by governments in the name of catching "bigger fish".
You could argue that the fall of the USSR deprived thriller writers like John Le Carré of their subject matter. James Bond, for one, was never the same after 1991. The Night Manager was his first novel after that, and it's fair to say that it was the first sign of the direction he would take for the next few books, more enraged at the misdeeds of the moneyed classes than worked up by the Cold War.
What makes it impressive, if disheartening, is the way that message resonates even louder today than it did then, when the West was still basking in the glory of its victory over communism.
Sunday, 5 April 2020
Make It So: Spoiler-Filled Thoughts on Star Trek Picard
So what would it take to get me to subscribe to CBS All Access, you ask? It turns out a global pandemic did the trick.
I took advantage of their offer of a free month, and in about a week managed to binge the whole ten episodes. When I saw the first few trailers, I was worried that it would be a Star Trek-flavored retread of Logan, in which Patrick Stewart reappears with a brain illness, helps a mysterious girl to safety, and dies in the attempt.
So...
Look, there's no way around it, those things all happen in Picard. But I'm happy to report that unlike Logan, this is his story, so his death is decidedly not very permanent and doesn't occur midway through. I'm less happy to report that this impermanence is foreshadowed pretty quickly.
Overall, I'd call it a good show. Not a great one, necessarily, but it seems to have avoided some of the key pitfalls that made season 2 of Discovery so infuriating. It does suffer from the same problems of gratuitous violence and swearing that make it come off less grown-up than juvenile, and it retreads some of the same conflicts as Disco, such as the corruption at the heart of the Federation and the conflict between organic and synthetic life.
Taking that first point about the corrupt Federation, I considered doing a whole blog about it, but I'll try and knock it out here. What occurred to me while watching this is that every era of Trek has approached the inviolability of the Federation according to the age it's in. For all that we consider the 60s to be a time of counter-culture, TOS was a very conservative and straight-laced show (racial and gender inclusion notwithstanding). If we take the Federation as America, you can look at the Federation in the 60s as either the idealized America, or an acknowledgement of what America could be if it solved its problems.
TNG started when the Cold War was in its final years, and the USSR collapsed during the show's run, so that when DS9 and Voyager came along the US was the sole remaining superpower. This is reflected both in the fact that the Auld Enemy, the Klingons, are now the allies of the Federation, and in the portrayal of the Federation way as the "best" way. Voyager sticks to this narrative a lot more, while DS9 questions it by introducing Section 31, the "dirty tricks" division of Starfleet.
Discovery and Picard arrive at a time when America's faith in itself is at perhaps its lowest ever, and I think that's reflected in the increased role that Section 31 has, especially in Season 2. For Picard it manifests in the widespread infiltration of Starfleet by the Romulans, and by the acknowledgement that the universe is a scary place so they have to take actions inconsistent with their ethos to preserve their citizens' living standards.
Notably, though, this topicality also means Picard examines income inequality on Earth in the 25th century, by having him live in a French chateau while his ally Raffi lives in a trailer in Vasquez Rocks, California. It's not explored much further, but the fact that the two characters are shown living so differently is noteworthy, since up to now Trek has always just waved some of those economic questions away (most infamously for me, by having Ensign Harry Kim from Voyager living in downtown San Francisco - as if).
Picard also examines the effect of his personality on the people around him, such as how his quest to save the Romulans put him at odds with Starfleet, while trying to root out Romulan infiltration caused Raffi to lose her family in a haze of substance abuse. We're used to seeing him as the undisputed moral beacon of TNG, a role he played well, so it was interesting to see that role questioned.
On the negative side, Picard suffers from the same predictability that dogged Disco. Once an element is introduced, you can see immediately how it will play out. The most egregious example is the synthetic body that's just lying there when Picard and co arrive on Coppelius. Once you hear that it's awaiting a brain transfer, you know that's where he's going to end up - and of course, that's exactly what happens.
It's hard to call the writers lazy or out of touch with Star Trek, but it's also hard to escape the feeling that maybe their reach exceeds their grasp here - or at least, you suspect they might be able to tell a more nuanced story if they weren't also trying to stuff in explosions and action scenes every episode or two. On the other hand, I have to appreciate that they avoided the big climactic ship battle that Disco went for, by having Picard deliver one of his usual speeches and saving the day.
So overall, Picard works, even if it doesn't quite hit the heights of DS9 or of TNG at its best. It gives us time with the characters, to catch up with them after decades away (and wash away the bitter taste of Nemesis), and it gives them moments of joy - like the episode where Picard and Soji take refuge with Riker and Troi on their idyllic planet. Most importantly, the plot fits much better with the main character, in contrast to Disco, which was saddled with an uninteresting main character (Michael Burnham) and compounded the problem by trying to tie every plot point back to her.
So I'll be looking forward to what they do with Season 2. It'd be nice to see him catch up with other characters, like Geordie, Worf, Dr Crusher and even Wesley. I do hope that we can move on from the organic vs synthetic life plot line, of course.
I still think I'll cancel my subscription to All Access by 23 April, though. I've found very little I want to watch on it beyond Trek...
I took advantage of their offer of a free month, and in about a week managed to binge the whole ten episodes. When I saw the first few trailers, I was worried that it would be a Star Trek-flavored retread of Logan, in which Patrick Stewart reappears with a brain illness, helps a mysterious girl to safety, and dies in the attempt.
So...
Look, there's no way around it, those things all happen in Picard. But I'm happy to report that unlike Logan, this is his story, so his death is decidedly not very permanent and doesn't occur midway through. I'm less happy to report that this impermanence is foreshadowed pretty quickly.
Overall, I'd call it a good show. Not a great one, necessarily, but it seems to have avoided some of the key pitfalls that made season 2 of Discovery so infuriating. It does suffer from the same problems of gratuitous violence and swearing that make it come off less grown-up than juvenile, and it retreads some of the same conflicts as Disco, such as the corruption at the heart of the Federation and the conflict between organic and synthetic life.
Taking that first point about the corrupt Federation, I considered doing a whole blog about it, but I'll try and knock it out here. What occurred to me while watching this is that every era of Trek has approached the inviolability of the Federation according to the age it's in. For all that we consider the 60s to be a time of counter-culture, TOS was a very conservative and straight-laced show (racial and gender inclusion notwithstanding). If we take the Federation as America, you can look at the Federation in the 60s as either the idealized America, or an acknowledgement of what America could be if it solved its problems.
TNG started when the Cold War was in its final years, and the USSR collapsed during the show's run, so that when DS9 and Voyager came along the US was the sole remaining superpower. This is reflected both in the fact that the Auld Enemy, the Klingons, are now the allies of the Federation, and in the portrayal of the Federation way as the "best" way. Voyager sticks to this narrative a lot more, while DS9 questions it by introducing Section 31, the "dirty tricks" division of Starfleet.
Discovery and Picard arrive at a time when America's faith in itself is at perhaps its lowest ever, and I think that's reflected in the increased role that Section 31 has, especially in Season 2. For Picard it manifests in the widespread infiltration of Starfleet by the Romulans, and by the acknowledgement that the universe is a scary place so they have to take actions inconsistent with their ethos to preserve their citizens' living standards.
Notably, though, this topicality also means Picard examines income inequality on Earth in the 25th century, by having him live in a French chateau while his ally Raffi lives in a trailer in Vasquez Rocks, California. It's not explored much further, but the fact that the two characters are shown living so differently is noteworthy, since up to now Trek has always just waved some of those economic questions away (most infamously for me, by having Ensign Harry Kim from Voyager living in downtown San Francisco - as if).
Picard also examines the effect of his personality on the people around him, such as how his quest to save the Romulans put him at odds with Starfleet, while trying to root out Romulan infiltration caused Raffi to lose her family in a haze of substance abuse. We're used to seeing him as the undisputed moral beacon of TNG, a role he played well, so it was interesting to see that role questioned.
On the negative side, Picard suffers from the same predictability that dogged Disco. Once an element is introduced, you can see immediately how it will play out. The most egregious example is the synthetic body that's just lying there when Picard and co arrive on Coppelius. Once you hear that it's awaiting a brain transfer, you know that's where he's going to end up - and of course, that's exactly what happens.
It's hard to call the writers lazy or out of touch with Star Trek, but it's also hard to escape the feeling that maybe their reach exceeds their grasp here - or at least, you suspect they might be able to tell a more nuanced story if they weren't also trying to stuff in explosions and action scenes every episode or two. On the other hand, I have to appreciate that they avoided the big climactic ship battle that Disco went for, by having Picard deliver one of his usual speeches and saving the day.
So overall, Picard works, even if it doesn't quite hit the heights of DS9 or of TNG at its best. It gives us time with the characters, to catch up with them after decades away (and wash away the bitter taste of Nemesis), and it gives them moments of joy - like the episode where Picard and Soji take refuge with Riker and Troi on their idyllic planet. Most importantly, the plot fits much better with the main character, in contrast to Disco, which was saddled with an uninteresting main character (Michael Burnham) and compounded the problem by trying to tie every plot point back to her.
So I'll be looking forward to what they do with Season 2. It'd be nice to see him catch up with other characters, like Geordie, Worf, Dr Crusher and even Wesley. I do hope that we can move on from the organic vs synthetic life plot line, of course.
I still think I'll cancel my subscription to All Access by 23 April, though. I've found very little I want to watch on it beyond Trek...
Sunday, 22 March 2020
Coping in Time of Crisis
Well, that went south quickly, didn't it?
I last posted to this blog two weeks ago, when the Bay Area and the state of California hadn't yet locked down to slow the spread of the virus. Since then, in fairly rapid succession, my company made us all start working from home, the Bay Area counties enacted a shelter in place order and then the whole state followed suit.
In that last post I was already talking about avoiding crowded places, and that hasn't changed - in fact, even if I wanted to go somewhere crowded I'd have trouble, unless I end up at the supermarket on a particularly busy day. But in the meantime I'm just trying to avoid going stir crazy while I sit out the lockdowns and virus and all that.
It's probably no surprise that work days are the easiest to cope with (and it helps that I'm one of those lucky people who are able to work from home). I'm expected to be on call for the stuff we're doing, at specific times on Monday through Friday, and that makes it easy to not spin my wheels wondering what to do next.
The main thing I've had to keep in mind is exercise - not just getting up from my desk to oil my joints, but also getting out of the house for a walk once or twice a day. The fresh air and sunlight (when we have it - it's been oddly cold and rainy, even for here) are necessary, as is the time to let my brain unspool without external stimulation from music or podcasts or work meetings.
What's a little more difficult is keeping busy on the weekends. Or, rather than "keeping busy", the question is how do I avoid feeling like I've wasted my time? A thing I noticed very soon after I moved here in late 2013 is that weekends passed more quickly than they did in London, but with notably less payoff. There, I would hop out to the center of town and find some lunch, hang out in the museums and peruse the bookstores.
Here those options were a little less available, because most of the good museums are up in San Francisco, which requires an hour's drive to get to. I made do, but of course for the moment the museums I'm a member of are all closed, and I don't want to go up there to risk getting sick anyway. So my range is circumscribed to a radius of a couple of miles, which takes in the stores I shop at to stock up on essentials and my normal walking or running routes.
Apart from that, I've been trying to make sure that I get errands done around the house, while also balancing goof-around time. Yesterday I reserved an hour for writing - and got through correcting a manuscript that's been on my desk for a while; then I reserved an hour for cleaning - and after unloading the dishwasher and taking out the trash I finally tackled the snowdrifts of mail that have been building up for (literally) years at this point. And I reserved a guilt-free hour each for reading, watching TV and playing video games, because I have a fair backlog of all of those to get through.
Of course, I'd trade some of that productivity for having my girlfriend here, as I told her on our FaceTime call last night. Which brings me to the other thing that I've been doing a bit more of: getting in touch with friends and family and checking in.
My sweetie and I have our daily check-in, whether on text or on FaceTime, but I've been calling my parents more (my dad's in Italy, but ironically I feel he's the safest of us all) and trying to stay in touch with my sisters more too. I've also tried to text some friends a bit more often, though that's more bittersweet as I can't actually go and see them.
The other question I'm dancing around is how long this will all last, and whether it's all sustainable. When I was unemployed and freelancing two years ago, there were a few days when it all got to me and I couldn't muster much interest to either look for permanent jobs or drum up more freelance work. Luckily I haven't descended to those depths during this time, in part because I only have the weekends to wallow, but I don't think I'm saying anything too controversial by hoping that things resolve themselves soon - ideally without too much undue chaos or loss of life.
The hope is that we start to see cases dropping off soon, and start to see the restrictions relax. Because, frankly, while I have a fair stash of toilet paper (thanks to my wonderful, prepared girlfriend), it's not infinite and I can't beat the panicky assholes who are hoarding it for no reason.
But apart from that, as I say, I'm trying to be productive, and I figure that's the best any of us can do at the moment.
Stay safe out there!
I last posted to this blog two weeks ago, when the Bay Area and the state of California hadn't yet locked down to slow the spread of the virus. Since then, in fairly rapid succession, my company made us all start working from home, the Bay Area counties enacted a shelter in place order and then the whole state followed suit.
In that last post I was already talking about avoiding crowded places, and that hasn't changed - in fact, even if I wanted to go somewhere crowded I'd have trouble, unless I end up at the supermarket on a particularly busy day. But in the meantime I'm just trying to avoid going stir crazy while I sit out the lockdowns and virus and all that.
It's probably no surprise that work days are the easiest to cope with (and it helps that I'm one of those lucky people who are able to work from home). I'm expected to be on call for the stuff we're doing, at specific times on Monday through Friday, and that makes it easy to not spin my wheels wondering what to do next.
The main thing I've had to keep in mind is exercise - not just getting up from my desk to oil my joints, but also getting out of the house for a walk once or twice a day. The fresh air and sunlight (when we have it - it's been oddly cold and rainy, even for here) are necessary, as is the time to let my brain unspool without external stimulation from music or podcasts or work meetings.
What's a little more difficult is keeping busy on the weekends. Or, rather than "keeping busy", the question is how do I avoid feeling like I've wasted my time? A thing I noticed very soon after I moved here in late 2013 is that weekends passed more quickly than they did in London, but with notably less payoff. There, I would hop out to the center of town and find some lunch, hang out in the museums and peruse the bookstores.
Here those options were a little less available, because most of the good museums are up in San Francisco, which requires an hour's drive to get to. I made do, but of course for the moment the museums I'm a member of are all closed, and I don't want to go up there to risk getting sick anyway. So my range is circumscribed to a radius of a couple of miles, which takes in the stores I shop at to stock up on essentials and my normal walking or running routes.
Apart from that, I've been trying to make sure that I get errands done around the house, while also balancing goof-around time. Yesterday I reserved an hour for writing - and got through correcting a manuscript that's been on my desk for a while; then I reserved an hour for cleaning - and after unloading the dishwasher and taking out the trash I finally tackled the snowdrifts of mail that have been building up for (literally) years at this point. And I reserved a guilt-free hour each for reading, watching TV and playing video games, because I have a fair backlog of all of those to get through.
Of course, I'd trade some of that productivity for having my girlfriend here, as I told her on our FaceTime call last night. Which brings me to the other thing that I've been doing a bit more of: getting in touch with friends and family and checking in.
My sweetie and I have our daily check-in, whether on text or on FaceTime, but I've been calling my parents more (my dad's in Italy, but ironically I feel he's the safest of us all) and trying to stay in touch with my sisters more too. I've also tried to text some friends a bit more often, though that's more bittersweet as I can't actually go and see them.
The other question I'm dancing around is how long this will all last, and whether it's all sustainable. When I was unemployed and freelancing two years ago, there were a few days when it all got to me and I couldn't muster much interest to either look for permanent jobs or drum up more freelance work. Luckily I haven't descended to those depths during this time, in part because I only have the weekends to wallow, but I don't think I'm saying anything too controversial by hoping that things resolve themselves soon - ideally without too much undue chaos or loss of life.
The hope is that we start to see cases dropping off soon, and start to see the restrictions relax. Because, frankly, while I have a fair stash of toilet paper (thanks to my wonderful, prepared girlfriend), it's not infinite and I can't beat the panicky assholes who are hoarding it for no reason.
But apart from that, as I say, I'm trying to be productive, and I figure that's the best any of us can do at the moment.
Stay safe out there!
Sunday, 8 March 2020
Europe's Centrifugal Force Threatens to Make it Irrelevant
Even though I don't live in a place that's been locked down by the coronavirus, I've been taking precautions like avoiding crowded places, and this has meant a lot of long walks have replaced my gym sessions this weekend. Naturally when I go for these walks I think a lot of deep thoughts, and so today I chewed over a question that's been bothering me for about 15 years: Is Europe setting itself up for irrelevancy?
The root of this question is a conversation I had in my very first week at journalism school, when I engaged one of my fellow students on her thoughts on China. I don't know how we got there, but she was very in favor of China's rise, and predicted that Europe would be irrelevant in the coming century. This was kind of blasphemous to me, in part because I was (and still am) an advocate of Western liberal democracy over China's corporatist authoritarianism.
A few months later I attended a talk at school about Latin America, and was struck by one of the journalists there saying that Latin America had made itself irrelevant. I didn't know much about the history of the region, but the idea stuck with me.
In any case I kept both those thoughts in mind for years, so that when I got to that book I've referenced before, The Nordic Theory of Everything by Anu Partanen, something in my brain dredged them up.
As I've said, I'm keen as any leftie to remake the US in the image of a Nordic social democracy, but something about Partanen's tone struck me as off. It took a while to realize that she was completely leaving out China (and Asia generally) from her analysis. That is to say, yes, it would be great if the US would guarantee healthcare, parental leave, good-quality education and so forth, but the big Asian economies aren't moving in that direction - so is it really a prerequisite for competing in the future?
Probably, but then Europe has other problems beyond this complacency (which is, by the way, very Nordic). That's been brought home to me by the discussion around the role of Huawei in delivering 5G.
Europe is, oddly, probably better placed than the US to deliver 5G network infrastructure, because it's home to two companies that build such equipment: Ericsson and Nokia (also both Nordic, funnily enough). That said, Huawei is enormous, and already in most operators' networks worldwide, giving it a head start of years compared with those two... and an even wider head start over any US competitors.
This hasn't stopped the US from raising concerns about whether Huawei's equipment is trustworthy - concerns that at least a bit valid, even if the administration is acting on them in a pretty ham-handed way. Yet the US's position is weakened by the fact that, as noted, neither Ericsson nor Nokia (nor both in concert) is ready to position themselves as a counter-weight to Huawei. Without getting into the merits of the "race for 5G" (which I think is a stupid talking point), any country that refuses to use any Huawei equipment risks delivering an inferior network experience, at greater expense and over a longer time.
So where does Europe's supposed irrelevancy come in here? The fact is that European companies haven't been able to grow to the scale of US or Chinese companies. This could be because of the regulatory environment (i.e. the fact that a regulatory environment exists in Europe, whereas it doesn't in China or the US), or it could be because both China and the US are more willing to let companies grow monstrously big to "compete on a global level".
The EU on its own is comfortably larger than the US, and if you add in non-EU European countries you'd add a further 100 million inhabitants... and that's without including Russia. But what I believe hamstrings it in this sphere is the still very fragmented state of business - there are a number of pan-European firms, but they tend to be smaller than US counterparts... or owned by them.
And the situation in tech is worse. I don't believe that Europe is a tech wasteland, because there are some notable companies that have come from there. The problem is that Microsoft has bought all of them (a slight exaggeration, but still).
Where the political fragmentation hurts Europe, even despite the presence of the European Union, is that certain things are still done in a certain way in Italy, compared with Germany, compared with France, and so on. Certain countries' labor markets are more flexible and dynamic than those elsewhere, so all the young people leave their home countries and go to the places where they'll find jobs. This creates a high degree of noise to signal for any budding entrepreneurs, while also starving their home countries of the experience needed to build an innovation ecosystem.
And because I'm a whining Remoaner, it's worth pointing out that leaving the EU won't fix this issue, but rather make it worse. It's not pro-EU propaganda to point out that companies want to do business in a harmonized environment, and when multiple countries harmonize their environments it becomes easier to conduct that business.
To summarize, the problem for Europe is creating enough space for innovative companies to flourish without all decamping to the Silicon Valley (this is a two-fer of self-interest for me, because it makes Europe more dynamic and it keeps loads of Europeans from coming here to the Bay Area and putting even more strain on it). Part of the problem is being able to scale a company to a point where it can compete globally, and the other part is simply having room in the market to do things in tech - for example, who needs another search engine when everybody just uses Google?
This assumes that having large companies is the only measure of success, which to be clear I don't believe. Germany's economy is built on an enormous number of small and medium-sized enterprises that act as suppliers to big ones, for example in the car industry. But having enough small companies creating goods that are in demand is an important prerequisite.
I don't believe that European countries are setting themselves up well to do that. Too many of them are still too protectionist (for example France and its insistence on farming subsidies), while attempts to limit movement from outside the EU, or from the EU into Britain, won't help the underlying causes of population movement.
In fact, if we take a look at the history of Latin America, there was a time when countries like Argentina, Brazil and Chile were much more active internationally. However, they fell into a period of economic nationalism, political populism and military rule, which caused them to fall behind the countries of Europe. Folks in the global north may know of Eva Peron from Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical Evita, but in truth her husband's regime made Argentina ungovernable, and ripe for the military takeover that blighted the country for decades.
As Europe splits off into different populist or nationalist camps, whether in Hungary, Poland or the UK, they should look at the history of Latin http://frad-lab.blogspot.com/2020/03/how-scandinavian-design-and-social.htmlAmerica and avoid the pitfalls those companies hit, to avoid the same fate.
The root of this question is a conversation I had in my very first week at journalism school, when I engaged one of my fellow students on her thoughts on China. I don't know how we got there, but she was very in favor of China's rise, and predicted that Europe would be irrelevant in the coming century. This was kind of blasphemous to me, in part because I was (and still am) an advocate of Western liberal democracy over China's corporatist authoritarianism.
A few months later I attended a talk at school about Latin America, and was struck by one of the journalists there saying that Latin America had made itself irrelevant. I didn't know much about the history of the region, but the idea stuck with me.
In any case I kept both those thoughts in mind for years, so that when I got to that book I've referenced before, The Nordic Theory of Everything by Anu Partanen, something in my brain dredged them up.
As I've said, I'm keen as any leftie to remake the US in the image of a Nordic social democracy, but something about Partanen's tone struck me as off. It took a while to realize that she was completely leaving out China (and Asia generally) from her analysis. That is to say, yes, it would be great if the US would guarantee healthcare, parental leave, good-quality education and so forth, but the big Asian economies aren't moving in that direction - so is it really a prerequisite for competing in the future?
Probably, but then Europe has other problems beyond this complacency (which is, by the way, very Nordic). That's been brought home to me by the discussion around the role of Huawei in delivering 5G.
Europe is, oddly, probably better placed than the US to deliver 5G network infrastructure, because it's home to two companies that build such equipment: Ericsson and Nokia (also both Nordic, funnily enough). That said, Huawei is enormous, and already in most operators' networks worldwide, giving it a head start of years compared with those two... and an even wider head start over any US competitors.
This hasn't stopped the US from raising concerns about whether Huawei's equipment is trustworthy - concerns that at least a bit valid, even if the administration is acting on them in a pretty ham-handed way. Yet the US's position is weakened by the fact that, as noted, neither Ericsson nor Nokia (nor both in concert) is ready to position themselves as a counter-weight to Huawei. Without getting into the merits of the "race for 5G" (which I think is a stupid talking point), any country that refuses to use any Huawei equipment risks delivering an inferior network experience, at greater expense and over a longer time.
So where does Europe's supposed irrelevancy come in here? The fact is that European companies haven't been able to grow to the scale of US or Chinese companies. This could be because of the regulatory environment (i.e. the fact that a regulatory environment exists in Europe, whereas it doesn't in China or the US), or it could be because both China and the US are more willing to let companies grow monstrously big to "compete on a global level".
The EU on its own is comfortably larger than the US, and if you add in non-EU European countries you'd add a further 100 million inhabitants... and that's without including Russia. But what I believe hamstrings it in this sphere is the still very fragmented state of business - there are a number of pan-European firms, but they tend to be smaller than US counterparts... or owned by them.
And the situation in tech is worse. I don't believe that Europe is a tech wasteland, because there are some notable companies that have come from there. The problem is that Microsoft has bought all of them (a slight exaggeration, but still).
Where the political fragmentation hurts Europe, even despite the presence of the European Union, is that certain things are still done in a certain way in Italy, compared with Germany, compared with France, and so on. Certain countries' labor markets are more flexible and dynamic than those elsewhere, so all the young people leave their home countries and go to the places where they'll find jobs. This creates a high degree of noise to signal for any budding entrepreneurs, while also starving their home countries of the experience needed to build an innovation ecosystem.
And because I'm a whining Remoaner, it's worth pointing out that leaving the EU won't fix this issue, but rather make it worse. It's not pro-EU propaganda to point out that companies want to do business in a harmonized environment, and when multiple countries harmonize their environments it becomes easier to conduct that business.
To summarize, the problem for Europe is creating enough space for innovative companies to flourish without all decamping to the Silicon Valley (this is a two-fer of self-interest for me, because it makes Europe more dynamic and it keeps loads of Europeans from coming here to the Bay Area and putting even more strain on it). Part of the problem is being able to scale a company to a point where it can compete globally, and the other part is simply having room in the market to do things in tech - for example, who needs another search engine when everybody just uses Google?
This assumes that having large companies is the only measure of success, which to be clear I don't believe. Germany's economy is built on an enormous number of small and medium-sized enterprises that act as suppliers to big ones, for example in the car industry. But having enough small companies creating goods that are in demand is an important prerequisite.
I don't believe that European countries are setting themselves up well to do that. Too many of them are still too protectionist (for example France and its insistence on farming subsidies), while attempts to limit movement from outside the EU, or from the EU into Britain, won't help the underlying causes of population movement.
In fact, if we take a look at the history of Latin America, there was a time when countries like Argentina, Brazil and Chile were much more active internationally. However, they fell into a period of economic nationalism, political populism and military rule, which caused them to fall behind the countries of Europe. Folks in the global north may know of Eva Peron from Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical Evita, but in truth her husband's regime made Argentina ungovernable, and ripe for the military takeover that blighted the country for decades.
As Europe splits off into different populist or nationalist camps, whether in Hungary, Poland or the UK, they should look at the history of Latin http://frad-lab.blogspot.com/2020/03/how-scandinavian-design-and-social.htmlAmerica and avoid the pitfalls those companies hit, to avoid the same fate.
Sunday, 1 March 2020
How Scandinavian Design and Social Democracy are Linked
I found myself thinking about Scandinavia again on my walk today. Specifically, I thought about the architecture, and the design more generally, and the way we've fetishized it here in the US for several decades. And then I wondered whether that interest in Scandinavian design and architecture is connected to the progressive love for Scandinavian social democratic politics.
A google search for the furniture chain here in the Bay Area also turns up a showroom in New York that closed in 2014, but effectively they date back to the 1950s and 1960s, when Americans were apparently crazy for stuff from Europe, as it smacked of sophistication (per Bill Bryson and his book, The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid). My memory of the retail chain here in the Bay Area is of my parents shopping for furniture there (and it being super expensive).
Somewhere along the line clean, functional lines and blond wood became catnip for people who vote progressive. My theory is that this love for Scandinavian design is what came first, but that as the right wing here in the US became more nativist and xenophobic the left held up its love of Scandinavia as the perfect photo-negative to stand in opposition.
This isn't at all scientific, of course, or a ground-breaking idea. But I think the fact that the love for Scandinavian design came first might be. And moreover, the eye-rolling that it prompts among people on the right or even among the more bien-pensant types is clearly a reaction to generations of lefties telling us how everything would be great if we were just more like Sweden, Norway and Denmark. And let's throw in Finland, even though as a Finno-Ugric speaking country we have to expand our designation to "Nordic" to include it.
I have my own love-hate relationship with this type of thinking. On the one hand I can't get enough of books where some foreigner moves to the Nordics and gets all dewy-eyed at the social democracy and supposed happiness. On the other, I get a little frustrated how I and my fellow lefties just invoke Danish or Finnish family leave policies without understanding how they work or what kind of infrastructure is involved with delivering them. Both are likely the reasons why I devour the type of book referenced above: I want to live in that kind of (seemingly) effortless simplicity and I want to understand how they've actually implemented it.
It also doesn't help when the books explaining that implementation are so self-satisfied. A book that's affected my thinking quite heavily in the last year or so is The Nordic Theory of Everything, by Finnish journalist Anu Partanen, in which she explains her culture shock at moving to the US to be with her new husband, and how backward we are in things like delivering healthcare and providing education.
I'm on-board with arguments like that, but given how frustrated I was with her didactic tone, I find myself having to dole out arguments based on her book very carefully, lest I turn off the people I'm trying to persuade.
But what does this have to do with my original thesis, about Scandinavian design? The point that probably a lot of my fellow lefties miss (or forget) is that the best examples of this design are intended to be democratic and available to everyone. A womb chair from Saarinen designs may run you to over a thousand dollars online, but the Finnish architect Alvar Aalto designed housing for veterans returning from the Winter War in the 1940s and for workers at various companies and factories throughout Finland.
This is perhaps a roundabout way of saying that if we want to valorize these ideas from Scandinavia, we need to emphasize how they benefit everyone, without taking for granted that normal voters will just automatically see the benefits of single-payer healthcare or generous family leave. Americans have been abused (for instance) by the corporate and Byzantine healthcare system for so long that they're mistrustful of any change that potentially makes it more difficult for them to get healthcare.
Add to that the constant drumbeat of "socialism = evil" and "Europe = socialist", and it's easy to see why even supposed progressives like Pete Buttigieg evince a sort of Stockholm syndrome for our existing system (btw, do you see what I did there?).
If we agree with Le Corbusier's argument that a house is a machine for living, then you could say that Scandinavian architecture and design are machines that just work, no fuss and no muss. If we want to take it a step further and import their healthcare systems and general organization of society, we need to emphasize that simplicity first and foremost. Then maybe we'll have a chance to sell more Americans on the concept.
A google search for the furniture chain here in the Bay Area also turns up a showroom in New York that closed in 2014, but effectively they date back to the 1950s and 1960s, when Americans were apparently crazy for stuff from Europe, as it smacked of sophistication (per Bill Bryson and his book, The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid). My memory of the retail chain here in the Bay Area is of my parents shopping for furniture there (and it being super expensive).
Somewhere along the line clean, functional lines and blond wood became catnip for people who vote progressive. My theory is that this love for Scandinavian design is what came first, but that as the right wing here in the US became more nativist and xenophobic the left held up its love of Scandinavia as the perfect photo-negative to stand in opposition.
This isn't at all scientific, of course, or a ground-breaking idea. But I think the fact that the love for Scandinavian design came first might be. And moreover, the eye-rolling that it prompts among people on the right or even among the more bien-pensant types is clearly a reaction to generations of lefties telling us how everything would be great if we were just more like Sweden, Norway and Denmark. And let's throw in Finland, even though as a Finno-Ugric speaking country we have to expand our designation to "Nordic" to include it.
I have my own love-hate relationship with this type of thinking. On the one hand I can't get enough of books where some foreigner moves to the Nordics and gets all dewy-eyed at the social democracy and supposed happiness. On the other, I get a little frustrated how I and my fellow lefties just invoke Danish or Finnish family leave policies without understanding how they work or what kind of infrastructure is involved with delivering them. Both are likely the reasons why I devour the type of book referenced above: I want to live in that kind of (seemingly) effortless simplicity and I want to understand how they've actually implemented it.
It also doesn't help when the books explaining that implementation are so self-satisfied. A book that's affected my thinking quite heavily in the last year or so is The Nordic Theory of Everything, by Finnish journalist Anu Partanen, in which she explains her culture shock at moving to the US to be with her new husband, and how backward we are in things like delivering healthcare and providing education.
I'm on-board with arguments like that, but given how frustrated I was with her didactic tone, I find myself having to dole out arguments based on her book very carefully, lest I turn off the people I'm trying to persuade.
But what does this have to do with my original thesis, about Scandinavian design? The point that probably a lot of my fellow lefties miss (or forget) is that the best examples of this design are intended to be democratic and available to everyone. A womb chair from Saarinen designs may run you to over a thousand dollars online, but the Finnish architect Alvar Aalto designed housing for veterans returning from the Winter War in the 1940s and for workers at various companies and factories throughout Finland.
This is perhaps a roundabout way of saying that if we want to valorize these ideas from Scandinavia, we need to emphasize how they benefit everyone, without taking for granted that normal voters will just automatically see the benefits of single-payer healthcare or generous family leave. Americans have been abused (for instance) by the corporate and Byzantine healthcare system for so long that they're mistrustful of any change that potentially makes it more difficult for them to get healthcare.
Add to that the constant drumbeat of "socialism = evil" and "Europe = socialist", and it's easy to see why even supposed progressives like Pete Buttigieg evince a sort of Stockholm syndrome for our existing system (btw, do you see what I did there?).
If we agree with Le Corbusier's argument that a house is a machine for living, then you could say that Scandinavian architecture and design are machines that just work, no fuss and no muss. If we want to take it a step further and import their healthcare systems and general organization of society, we need to emphasize that simplicity first and foremost. Then maybe we'll have a chance to sell more Americans on the concept.
Sunday, 23 February 2020
A Little Hatred by Joe Abercrombie
Another book review here, and another sequel to a well-loved fantasy trilogy from decades past. This time it's A Little Hatred by Joe Abercrombie, his first foray into the world of the First Law since Red Country, and his first trilogy in that world since Last Argument of Kings, the book that wrapped up that trilogy. Another similarity to Empire of Grass and the Lost King of Osten Ard trilogy is that this book picks up around thirty years after the previous trilogy ended, allowing readers to catch up with the characters from the previous books, as well as their offspring.
Unlike Tad Williams's trilogy, I haven't re-read the First Law, or the three standalone novels Abercrombie wrote after those (Best Served Cold, The Heroes and Red Country). This shouldn't imply any judgement on the quality, incidentally - Memory Sorrow and Thorn may rank as one of my favorite series ever, but I've long extolled the virtues of Joe Abercrombie, and I've eagerly snapped up every one of his books as they've come out, apart from the short story collection Sharp Ends.
The reason I bring it up, though, is that this lack of familiarity affected my reading of the book, to an extent. The First Law trilogy can be thought of as analogous to the original Star Wars trilogy, while the three standalones are like Rogue One, Solo and the Mandalorian - outrigger novels that take place in the same world but don't exactly advance the plot or require much prior knowledge. Rather, these more recent books allowed Abercrombie to shift pieces around to prepare for this latest trilogy, entitled The Age of Madness.
However, by not re-reading the previous books I'm a little at sea about who certain characters are. There are callbacks to The Heroes or Best Served Cold, but I'm left wondering if most of the characters whose POVs I'm reading were in those earlier ones (other than Caul Shivers, of course). If you're getting ready to read A Little Hatred, I'd recommend skimming through the previous ones.
Fitting for a writer who epitomizes the "grimdark" sub-genre, to the extent that his Twitter handle is Lord Grimdark (even if he's a little bemused by all the fuss and the epithet attaching to him), the book starts out dark. There's violence, swearing, dodgy sex scenes - everything that characterized his previous books, so if that's what you're after you'll be pleased. It started out a little tough to read, perhaps because I knew I'd be lending my copy to my dad after I finished, but as the book goes on the plot takes shape, allowing Abercrombie to go into more than eviscerations and heads being crushed (lots of those, btw).
Other reviewers have singled out the setting, so I'll do that too, and note that it's fun to see a sort of industrial revolution type of backdrop. The wizard Bayaz, central to the First Law, seems to be involved in a great leap forward to an industrial society and the resulting human misery. This is another area where Abercrombie pulls no punches, depicting not only the horrors of completely untrammeled capitalism but also the madness of the uprising that occurs when one city's workers are pushed too far.
Ignoring the speed with which his secondary world moves from invading "vikings" to dark satanic mills, it allows Abercrombie to tell a story that feels a lot more relevant to the world we're living in than one where we're expected to continue rooting for hereditary government and the divine right of kings. I'd even go so far as to say that perhaps this is a story only a British writer (and a northern English one, at that) could write, since the excesses of the industrial revolution are ingrained into the British soul much more than they are here in the US.
I called Empire of Grass an almost perfect sequel, since it expanded upon the previous trilogy in intriguing ways. It's maybe a little early to say whether The Age of Madness does the same, because I've read just one of the books so far, compared with the two from Tad Williams. It is however, a very good re-entry to the world of the First Law - I may have felt a bit at sea with identifying the characters, but that also made it a good introduction for completely new readers, and the really important stuff is alluded to in ways that make me remember what happened before.
More to the point, there's the feeling of a great big world that Abercrombie can't wait to introduce us to, when we get to Book 2 and Book 3. I just hope we'll get to find out more about what's going on with Bayaz and the infernal bankers of Valint and Balk.
The other thing I'd like to point to is the characterizations. None of the main POV characters is completely great, but nor are they completely awful. Savine dan Glokta's reaction to the uprising is not shocking or overly cliche, and Crown Prince Orso's motivations when he's sent to deal with the uprising are fascinating - he'll be a fun character to watch as we get to the sequels.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Joe Abercrombie is probably one of the best stylists in fantasy fiction at the moment. If he's not quite as lyrical as Guy Gavriel Kay or Neil Gaiman, he's certainly one of the best at putting you in the scene. That it's rarely a pleasant scene is beside the point - we'd be lucky if half the writers of fantasy were as good as him.
Unlike Tad Williams's trilogy, I haven't re-read the First Law, or the three standalone novels Abercrombie wrote after those (Best Served Cold, The Heroes and Red Country). This shouldn't imply any judgement on the quality, incidentally - Memory Sorrow and Thorn may rank as one of my favorite series ever, but I've long extolled the virtues of Joe Abercrombie, and I've eagerly snapped up every one of his books as they've come out, apart from the short story collection Sharp Ends.
The reason I bring it up, though, is that this lack of familiarity affected my reading of the book, to an extent. The First Law trilogy can be thought of as analogous to the original Star Wars trilogy, while the three standalones are like Rogue One, Solo and the Mandalorian - outrigger novels that take place in the same world but don't exactly advance the plot or require much prior knowledge. Rather, these more recent books allowed Abercrombie to shift pieces around to prepare for this latest trilogy, entitled The Age of Madness.
However, by not re-reading the previous books I'm a little at sea about who certain characters are. There are callbacks to The Heroes or Best Served Cold, but I'm left wondering if most of the characters whose POVs I'm reading were in those earlier ones (other than Caul Shivers, of course). If you're getting ready to read A Little Hatred, I'd recommend skimming through the previous ones.
Fitting for a writer who epitomizes the "grimdark" sub-genre, to the extent that his Twitter handle is Lord Grimdark (even if he's a little bemused by all the fuss and the epithet attaching to him), the book starts out dark. There's violence, swearing, dodgy sex scenes - everything that characterized his previous books, so if that's what you're after you'll be pleased. It started out a little tough to read, perhaps because I knew I'd be lending my copy to my dad after I finished, but as the book goes on the plot takes shape, allowing Abercrombie to go into more than eviscerations and heads being crushed (lots of those, btw).
Other reviewers have singled out the setting, so I'll do that too, and note that it's fun to see a sort of industrial revolution type of backdrop. The wizard Bayaz, central to the First Law, seems to be involved in a great leap forward to an industrial society and the resulting human misery. This is another area where Abercrombie pulls no punches, depicting not only the horrors of completely untrammeled capitalism but also the madness of the uprising that occurs when one city's workers are pushed too far.
Ignoring the speed with which his secondary world moves from invading "vikings" to dark satanic mills, it allows Abercrombie to tell a story that feels a lot more relevant to the world we're living in than one where we're expected to continue rooting for hereditary government and the divine right of kings. I'd even go so far as to say that perhaps this is a story only a British writer (and a northern English one, at that) could write, since the excesses of the industrial revolution are ingrained into the British soul much more than they are here in the US.
I called Empire of Grass an almost perfect sequel, since it expanded upon the previous trilogy in intriguing ways. It's maybe a little early to say whether The Age of Madness does the same, because I've read just one of the books so far, compared with the two from Tad Williams. It is however, a very good re-entry to the world of the First Law - I may have felt a bit at sea with identifying the characters, but that also made it a good introduction for completely new readers, and the really important stuff is alluded to in ways that make me remember what happened before.
More to the point, there's the feeling of a great big world that Abercrombie can't wait to introduce us to, when we get to Book 2 and Book 3. I just hope we'll get to find out more about what's going on with Bayaz and the infernal bankers of Valint and Balk.
The other thing I'd like to point to is the characterizations. None of the main POV characters is completely great, but nor are they completely awful. Savine dan Glokta's reaction to the uprising is not shocking or overly cliche, and Crown Prince Orso's motivations when he's sent to deal with the uprising are fascinating - he'll be a fun character to watch as we get to the sequels.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Joe Abercrombie is probably one of the best stylists in fantasy fiction at the moment. If he's not quite as lyrical as Guy Gavriel Kay or Neil Gaiman, he's certainly one of the best at putting you in the scene. That it's rarely a pleasant scene is beside the point - we'd be lucky if half the writers of fantasy were as good as him.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)