Pages

Sunday, 12 July 2020

Catching up on Avatar The Last Airbender

Finally catching Avatar: The Last Airbender on Netflix, and it feels like just what I've needed in this lockdown period.

I missed it the first time around, though I've been hearing people talk about it for years. I listened to Janet Varney's podcast, the JV Club, for a bunch of years, where she spoke to people about her role on the successor show, The Legend of Korra, and as I've gotten into ATLA I've come to understand about 20% more of the memes flying around the internet nowadays.

I'm not sure how much I love the animation style, as I'm generally iffy on Western artists using the Japanese anime/manga style, but because I like the style overall, I don't let it bother me too much. What I do love about it, though, is the fluidity with which they animate the action sequences - when characters are fighting you can see that they've taken advantage of actual martial arts consultants to depict the forms and movements. And on top of that, the frame rate is impressively smooth, more like a high-level Disney movie at times than a standard anime.

The other thing I love is the storytelling. The characters are impressively well-drawn, both the good guys and the bad guys, and some gain more depth as the series goes on. The best example here is Prince Zuko, who shows up in the first episode as The Baddie, but we soon learn that he's not enjoying the best reputation at home in the Fire Nation, and over time we see him make choices to become a much more complicated character.

And as I was telling my girlfriend, it benefits from surprising emotional resonance, such as when Aang has to grapple with the deaths a century earlier of his friends and mentors at the Air Temple, or in Iroh's Tale in season two, where we see Prince Zuko's Uncle Iroh grieving his son, who died years earlier in the Fire Nation's endless war of conquest.

The storytelling doesn't talk down to the kids who were meant to form its audience, and without being excessively mature it manages therefore to appeal to adults (at least, to this adult). In that it reminds me of some of the best episodes of Batman: The Animated Series or Justice League/Justice League Unlimited.

The other thing it has in common with those shows is its voice director, Andrea Romano, who reliably finds some great talents to voice the characters. One notable character that I've just started to encounter (I'm most of the way through Season 2) is Long Feng, who's voiced by Clancy Brown, channeling his role in the DCAU shows as Lex Luthor. The other notable thing is that, even though the main voice cast isn't Asian, the show does give a lot of great roles to Asian actors, most notably the late Mako in the role of Uncle Iroh.

I questioned the use of anime style for the animation earlier, but I do love the Asian influence overall, in the language, locales and general design. Reading the Wikipedia page I saw that the creators initially wanted to have the Fire Nation as stand-ins for the Japanese, but I'm glad they blended them more with other Asian cultures - both because of wanting to avoid the negative backlash from Japanese-American and Japanese viewers, but also because stories like this tend to resonate better when you're not trying to match each character, faction or style to a direct analogue from the real world.

By not basing the Fire Nation exactly on the Japanese, it became easier for the producers to take the characters, both individually and as a group, in directions that made sense for the narrative, rather than being locked into following actual Japanese history. And the same goes for all the other characters and factions, even when they look a lot like Chinese, Korean or Inuit cultures.

As I say, I'm a little more than halfway through. The show is so entertaining, and flows so well from episode to episode, that it's easy for me to binge several at a time, and therefore I expect to finish it pretty soon. I'm looking forward to seeing how Aang's quest ends, and I'm hoping that Netflix will make Korra available for streaming someday soon (bizarrely, the last time I checked there wasn't much of it available on DVD for rental).

Sunday, 5 July 2020

Manchester United Starting to Come Good

So it only took more than a year, but it looks like Manchester United is finding its level. The team is undefeated in the league since the restart, and indeed undefeated since 22 January, when they lost 2-0 to Burnley.

The main reason for the uptick in form seems to have been the signing of Bruno Fernandes from Sporting in Portugal, during the January transfer window. This tactical analysis is from before he signed, but casts an eye on how he'd fit into the United team, and it seems to be borne out by the facts since his arrival at Old Trafford.

But beyond the numbers on the pitch, what's interesting is that manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer even made this transfer. It's not excessive to state how precarious his position was by the time the January transfer window rolled around - a couple of pundits on the Guardian Football Weekly had even predicted at the start of this season that he'd be sacked by November, such was the drop in form after his appointment as permanent manager at the end of last season.

He'd seemed to grab the players' attention in his first few games, winning an impressive streak in the league and coming back from an inauspicious first leg in the Champions League to beat Paris St-Germain. He'd even gotten some good form out of Paul Pogba, whose inconsistency under Jose Mourinho must have contributed to his sacking and Solskjaer's appointment.

But then Pogba went AWOL again this season, with a long-term ankle injury, and a 4-0 defeat of Chelsea notwithstanding, United spent the first few months of the campaign looking like they were in crisis again. But for every poor result, they managed to rescue Solskjaer with a win (or at least a creditable performance) right after, and so he hung on, indeed long past when Mauricio Pochettino was sacked by Spurs and replaced by Mourinho.

Manchester United is a bit of a weird club. It's one of the richest, if not the absolutely most profitable, in the world. Yet despite that, the stadium grows increasingly shabby and the football takes a back seat to the sponsorship deals - though these deals, ironically, are probably what left United in such good shape to weather the coronavirus shutdown without putting players or staff on furlough.

In a way, that lack of interest in the footballing side of being a football club may also have saved Solskjaer - he wasn't picking too many fights with the players or overseeing too many embarrassing defeats, so the owners might have been happy to keep him in place until someone better came along. You see this attitude a lot in the Premier League at the moment, where owners like Mike Ashley are happy to let their clubs (in this case Newcastle) rot as long as they stay in the top division.

But I think it's also interesting that Solskjaer had the vision for how he wanted the team to play (a thing that wasn't always clear as they went into their decline after his appointment) and was able to buy the player he wanted to make that vision a reality. There was a sense, reading the football pages in the last months of 2019, of him being a little isolated and not entirely in charge. The idea that Pogba might still be at the club by the end of the season tended to be met with laughter.

Still, it's clear that Solskjaer knew how he wanted the team to play, and found the player who could do that, either on his own or, as the manager must have preferred, in partnership with Pogba. In one stroke, Solskjaer strengthens his team, and also puts his star midfielder on notice that he can get by without him - depending on Pogba's level of professionalism, that either lights a fire under him to work harder, or indicates that he's working with a manager who knows what he's doing.

And in the meantime Fernandes has scored 6 goals in 9 appearances, plus 5 assists to boot, linking up with Marcus Rashford and Anthony Martial quite well.

I suspect Pogba is still likely to leave during the next transfer window, though it's notable he hasn't followed the example of Leroy Sané, who jumped ship from Manchester City mid-season to go back to Germany. If Juventus wants Pogba back, or one of the Spanish giants, or even PSG, it's hard to imagine him not making the leap. But Fernandes seems to have filled the gap left by Pogba's season-long injury quite impressively, and he looks like he'll be a good replacement if Pogba leaves.

The other point to think about is the speed with which clubs replace managers. United famously endured a poor start to Alex Ferguson's tenure in 1986, but stuck with him and were rewarded by the most dominant display in English football history (he says with possibly unwarranted confidence). As I mentioned last week, United has won 29 trophies in the past 30 years (not counting Community Shields), and several of those have also come in the years since Ferguson retired, though notably they haven't won the league since then.

One hesitates to say that Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is the next manifestation of Sir Alex Ferguson, but you can appreciate his role in how football writers are starting to entertain the prospect of United challenging for the title next season. If that does happen, it'll probably cement the disciples of Ferguson at the club forever, for better or worse; though it feels equally likely that things go desperately wrong for Solskjaer again and that this time he doesn't survive the slump.

It also makes me wonder again about a point from Soccernomics, by Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski, where they argue that the manager is actually not as relevant to the success of a team as we think. They have a new edition out, and I feel like I need to revisit it to see how that suggestion of theirs squares with the experience of managers like Solskjaer, Mourinho or Claudio Ranieri, not to mention super-managers like Pep Guardiola or Jürgen Klopp in the last five years.

Sunday, 28 June 2020

Putting the Microscope on Liverpool, 2019-20 Premier League Champions

Well, it took some doing, but Liverpool finally clinched their title on Thursday, with Chelsea's defeat of Manchester City. It's not quite the fairy tale that Leicester's title win consisted of, but it's a pretty exciting achievement, given Liverpool's dominance this season and the long wait since their previous league title.

Now, when I say it's not a fairy tale, it's not to take away from Liverpool's absolute dominance this season, especially given how close they came to winning last season. However, even if they don't have the financial clout of a Gulf petro-state behind them, Liverpool are far from a scrappy newcomer to the Premier League - though it's worth remembering that Leicester's win was also bankrolled by some pretty deep pockets.

In fact, in the 30 years since Liverpool last won the league title, they've won 15 trophies (including this season's Premier League). Most of those were FA or League Cups, but notably they won the Champions League twice during that period, including last season, and the Europa League at some point as well.

To put this trophy haul into context, Liverpool lags behind both Manchester United (29 trophies during the same period) and Chelsea (20), but ahead of both Arsenal (13 trophies) and Manchester City (11). Liverpool have won fewer league titles than any of those competitors, in part because of United's dominance for the better part of three decades under Alex Ferguson bringing 13 Premier League titles. But Liverpool and United are tied for most Champions Leagues won, at 2 apiece, while City and Arsenal haven't won any European titles in that time.

Comparing trophies under their current managers shows that most of Manchester City's trophies (6 out of 11) have come under Pep Guardiola, compared with 4 for Liverpool under Jürgen Klopp. This number is fitting, when you consider that until 2008 City weren't the powerhouse that they are now. But it's also worth remembering that for all the domination of Guardiola's City in the last few seasons, he still hasn't won a Champions League since 2011, with Barcelona.

Because Guardiola's arrival at City coincided with Klopp's first full season at Liverpool, it's also possible to compare their league standings for the past four seasons. Other than 2017-18, when City steamrolled all before them to win the league with 100 points and 106 goals, having won 32 out of 38 games, Liverpool have nipped at City's heels every season, most notably last year, when they squandered a lead in mid-season to end just one point behind City.

To put it another way, in their two most recent title-winning seasons, Manchester City averaged 2.6 points per game, compared with the 2.6 and 2.0 points per game that Liverpool managed in 2018-19 and 2017-18, respectively. This season (which is still incomplete), Liverpool have clinched the title with 2.8 points per game, compared with 2.0 from City. Those numbers may change with the remaining seven matches each team has to play, of course.

The secret to Liverpool's success seems also to have come in the transfer market. It's hard to compare the money spent on signings by Klopp and Guardiola, because you can massage the totals and averages to reflect whatever you like. But it seems clear that Manchester City under Pep Guardiola have bought more players - so far, so uncontroversial.

On the other hand, of the 8 notable first-team signings that Liverpool have made, the most expensive has been Virgil van Dijk, for £75 million, which makes him more expensive than any of Guardiola's signings at City. Liverpool's second-highest transfer fee paid was £66.8mn for goalkeeper Alisson, which also beats any of the signings that Guardiola has made.

You can't argue that Guardiola has gone for a policy of galacticos, because the teams he's built over the past few seasons have dominated pretty comprehensively in both the seasons they won, and the quality in the Premier League is such that just sticking a bunch of expensive attackers in a side won't net you much. But the preponderance of attacking midfielders and wingers and creative players shows Guardiola's preference in terms of players, whereas Klopp's purchases seem to have involved rather a gradual tinkering to shore up the weak points in his team each season.

Alisson is a great example. After errors from goalkeeper Loris Karius cost Liverpool the Champions League in 2018, Klopp went and bought a replacement in Alisson, from Roma, the team that possibly gave Liverpool the biggest scare en route to the final that season. This is after having picked up van Dijk to shore up the defense, so it's clear that a key part of Klopp's strategy for building a winning team has involved strengthening the back line.

In fact, not only has Klopp made four of Liverpool's five most expensive signings, but the other two after van Dijk and Alisson are either central or defensive midfielders: Naby Keïta for £45mn and Fabinho for £33mn, respectively. It's not to say that Klopp favors a stodgy, defensive style of play - but it's notable their average goals conceded declined from 1.1 goals per game in 2016-17, Klopp's first full season in charge, to 0.6 goals per game in 2018-19. Manchester City, by the way, did the exact opposite from last season to this - conceding just 0.6 goals per game en route to winning the title, vs conceding 1.1 goals per game (so far) this season to place second.

None of this is meant to take away from Liverpool's achievement, since they've won with a record seven games to spare, and currently stand 23 points ahead of City. But it's clear that Liverpool's win has come on the end of years of meticulous planning, getting the team composition exactly right, to then be able to steamroll the rest of the league, and fairly mercilessly too.

As ever, the question is what next season will hold. Leicester ended up flopping a bit after their title-winning season (which incidentally, I consider now to be ill-starred since that summer Britain voted to leave the EU and the US elected Donald Trump). But Leicester's achievement, while mighty, came at a time that the biggest clubs were all in disarray, with Mourinho self-destructing at Chelsea, and both City and Arsenal's managers at the time unable to eke out any more from their players at the time. Leicester ended up having a torrid time, sacking Claudio Ranieri mid-season (and then eventually sacking his replacement afterwards, and the replacement for him), and only this season have emerged as a credible Top 4 side, if not title challenger.

It'd be a surprise if Liverpool had the same difficulties. True, City's defense isn't the same since their captain, Vincent Kompany, left, but they're still a formidable team. Rather, this win stands in a continuum with the previous seasons, where they improved measurably each season. At the very least, it's easy to expect them to place in the Champions League spots again, though there's always the danger of the team tiring out the way Dortmund did in Klopp's last season in Germany.

Time will tell, as I always say. But in the meantime, congratulations to the reigning European, world and now English champions, Liverpool FC.

Sunday, 21 June 2020

Mission Impossible vs The Fast and the Furious

I've come to realize over the last couple of years that the true line dividing our society is that between those who enjoy the finer things in life - a good drink, talks with friends, Vin Diesel driving a car off the Burj al-Arab - and those who live lives devoid of joy. Those, in short, who prefer the Mission Impossible movies.

Forget left vs right, atheism vs belief, or Coke vs Pepsi. Our culture is riven by the war between those who prefer the adventures of Dominic Toretto, Han and Ludacris vs watching Tom Cruise jump off of stuff. I think you can tell from the preceding paragraphs where I fall in this important question.

Now, it's worth saying that I've watched almost all of the Mission Impossible movies, and am indeed taking a quick break from watching Fallout, the most recent of the series. I expect once I've finished this essay I'll go back to it (only 45 minutes to go, joy), but in the meantime, please be prepared for SPOILERS:

So why have I watched all the Mission Impossible movies? I dunno - maybe it's a certain masochistic completionism, or maybe I keep hoping there'll be something to love in them. The trailers always look impressive, and I can't deny that the stunts really are amazing. In Fallout, for example, Henry Cavill and Tom Cruise skydive out of an airplane INTO A THUNDERSTORM and land in Paris. Mid-jump, Cavill gets knocked unconscious and Cruise has to save him in mid-air.

Fairness compels me to note that this is probably a better set-piece than my favorite Fast & Furious one, which is the sequence in Fast 5 where they drag that safe through Rio. It's also better than the sequence in FF6, where they're on that enormous plane that's taking off for ages and both Han and Giselle (seemingly) die to save the world... and that's a pretty darn good action sequence.

I guess my objection to the MI movies is that I still haven't forgiven the series for the first three movies. The first, which came out when I was in high school, was an okay bit of fluff, with Tom Cruise jumping around and doing crazy stuff, and it was fine, I guess? Though I disapproved of the ending twist where the guy who'd been running the team in the old TV show turned out to be the bad guy (which is why Jon Voight played the character and not Peter Graves).

The second remains my least favorite movie ever, and probably damaged John Woo's career here in the west. The characters, down to their names, were stupid and obnoxious, and to top it all off, a cat jumped under my car as I drove home afterwards - while I won't imply there's a causal relationship here, it certainly makes you think.

(Btw, I seem to remember seeing the cat hop back into the bushes along the road afterwards in my mirror, so I'm hoping it didn't actually get killed. But still - fuck that movie)

MI3 I don't even remember, because it's one of the few films I ever fell asleep while watching. Granted, I was jet lagged, but it's hardly an endorsement, is it?

So I resisted watching Ghost Protocol and Rogue Nation for the longest time. Eventually I did break down and watch them, and they were... fine. I suppose. But the problem is that they're so serious, and they lack the sense of fun that characterizes the FF movies. Not only that, but the first half of the series didn't really build on any of the previous films (much like the James Bond movies), and it's only in the last three films that we've had a running storyline about Tom Cruise's guilt about abandoning his wife.

Compare that with the complicated mythology that grew up around FF, where it starts as a bromance about Paul Walker and Vin Diesel, but then they keep making friends with their adversaries (e.g. the Rock and Jason Statham). The way that Michelle Rodriguez seemingly dies, then is back, and all the drama that ensues.

Now, let's not pretend either of these series is high art, of course. But when I say the MI films are silly or implausible, what I really mean is convoluted - climbing around Emirati skyscrapers or jumping through lightning storms may look good, but I'm sure there are less complicated ways of achieving your goal. The plots are weird and hard to follow, and this might sound counter-intuitive, but what drives me nuts is that if I glance away at my phone for a moment I lose track of what's happening.

When I say that the FF movies are silly, I mean they're over the top, stupid and proud of it, but they aren't making any pretense of being any more than silly actioners. Though I will say I miss when they were just heist movies, rather than a series about foiling global terrorism by driving cars at bad guys.

Anyway, I have to get back to watch the end of Fallout. I hope there'll be some good spectacle in this final 45 minutes, on a level with the car chases and sky dives of the first 90 minutes or so. But in my heart of hearts what I really want to see is Tom Cruise driving a super-car off of something high and maybe killing a helicopter with it. That's something Vin Diesel could pull off.

Sunday, 14 June 2020

Why Is It Controversial to End Racism?

This is the question that's going around on a bunch of memes at the moment, and when a friend posted it on Facebook yesterday, I had a bit of a brainstorm as to why it is. It involves pop culture and cognitive dissonance, and the endless talent for self-justification that people have for their own bullshit.

Pop culture comes into it because Hollywood has taught us what racists look like. They're either old fat Southern men, who drawl epithets casually, or they're Germans. Racism in the movies is easy to spot because people are using the N-word and burning crosses and such. It becomes an easy - even lazy - way of showing how bad the villain is. After all, when Ron Perlman's character in Blade 2 asks Wesley Snipes if he can blush, that's like a reverse Save the Cat moment, where we learn all we need to about that character.

This isn't to take away from the fact that racism really is evil, of course. When you call someone a racial slur, for example, you're taking away all of the things that make them a unique individual, basically saying it doesn't matter what you've accomplished in life, you're just a... whatever. But this gets elided in pop culture, because pop culture can't convey nuance.

And that leads to the cognitive dissonance. We're so used to seeing racism depicted in a certain way on TV and in movies, we ignore when our words or behavior are racist, because we aren't Germans or policemen from the Deep South (most of us aren't, at any rate). We've built up this righteous anger on the behalf of civil rights leaders like Martin Luther King, but it makes us smug and blinds us to the ways we're casually or even overtly racist in real life.

The most spectacular way that this manifests, by the way, is in the far-right marchers in the UK who have responded to the threat of vandalism to statues of Winston Churchill by... giving Nazi salutes? F Scott Fitzgerald would have called this a sign of a first-rate mind: being able to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still being able to function.

That depiction of racism as being done exclusively by certain people is also class warfare, by the way (you know, just for good measure). We may say or do racist things, but we don't think of ourselves as racist because we feel superior to so-called "poor white trash". This serves to perpetuate splits between poor whites and poor minorities, and allows more well-off whites to justify why they don't mix with "those people".

Of course, the description above only refers to people who aren't "openly" racist. They might tell racist jokes at the pub or something, but aren't actively campaigning for race wars or sequestering African-Americans and Jews in special "homelands" in the South. It doesn't apply to those who actually do say out loud the stuff that for most people is only ingrained racism - and yet, the so-called alt-right benefits from the stereotypes I listed above. All these young, well-groomed men who like to flash Nazi salutes at alt-right karaoke nights know that we won't take their racism seriously precisely because they aren't sweaty old fat men with Southern drawls. This is, in fact, just how the New York Times has gotten hoodwinked into running a bunch of normalizing profiles of "the well-dressed racist next door".

So next time you wonder why people are counter-protesting against Black Lives Matter, remember that they (and we in general) are only playing out this narrative that racism only comes from certain people. And as long as we aren't "those people", we're in the clear... right...?

Sunday, 7 June 2020

Sunday, 17 May 2020

Shame about the Internet

I'd been thinking of tackling the utopian topic of what kind of society I'd like to see after the whole pandemic business finishes - a more social democratic society, and one where things are less ridiculously complicated (because for some reason Americans love stupid stuff to be stupidly complex), but I decided against it.

Instead I was thinking about a topic at once less utopian, the internet, and also more utopian, i.e. how nice it'd be if it were less shitty.

I guess it's easy to complain about the ways the internet has distorted the culture worldwide - exhibit A is the Trump "presidency", which owes its existence heavily to the worst aspects of the internet, and which has given us the situation we currently face.

And it's not just here that the internet has fucked things up - misinformation on the internet generally and Facebook specifically contributed heavily to the Brexit vote in 2016 and other far-right politicians' victories in the years since. To say nothing of its success in radicalizing disaffected Muslim-background youth in Europe and leading to atrocities like the Paris attacks of 2015.

But every morning, when I fire up my laptop to do my Duolingo lessons, or when I follow along with a workout routine on YouTube, I have to remind myself of how much benefit it's brought me.

Or to put it another way, I keep trying to think how I'd be coping with boredom and so forth during this sheltering in place, if I didn't have the internet to keep me in touch with my friends and family, to keep me informed about what's happening, and to keep me entertained.

While I've gone on something of a buying spree on Kindle since the first shelter-in-place order came down, it's probably fair to say that I wouldn't be short on physical books to read. I've got my own collection here, and also my dad's, so if I don't mind re-reading certain things, I'd be fine there. Same with music, because even though I'm currently listening to John Lennon and Yoko Ono's Unfinished Music Vol. 2 on YouTube (review: don't listen to it), I have my own CD collection and iTunes library to fall back on.

TV is a slightly trickier prospect, because as a cord-cutter I really only have access to Netflix and other streamers. And there I'd find my first set of problems, because there wouldn't even be YouTube to pass the time (for instance by watching this one British nerd solve ridiculously complex sudoku puzzles).

I wouldn't be able to learn my languages on Duolingo or any of the other apps I use, including YouTube. And it'd be so much harder to keep on top of my health or finances or generally any of the other things that keep my life humming along - I don't know if this is a good thing or a bad thing, but it's fair to say that a whole ton of things are so much easier now because of it, pandemic or not.

The other important thing that I wouldn't have if not for the internet is my girlfriend, because we met online, and now that we're sequestered apart we use iMessage and FaceTime to keep in touch every day.

This whole screed isn't so much a Pollyanna-ish attempt to ignore all the disruption and chaos that the internet causes, as a reminder of all the good things that we use it for. Sure, Twitter and Facebook in particular are not just causes of our current polarization, but also actively making things more chaotic by providing a platform for all the worst kooks and grifters to either peddle falsehood or use misinformation to sow division.

But even there it's pleasing to see how my friends and family are coping on my Facebook timeline, or seeing what interesting or silly things the writers and reporters and comedians I follow on Twitter. There are bad things to all of these apps and platforms, but we can outweigh them if we make a more concerted attempt to focus on the good aspects.

This is why I get so annoyed when I see writers I like (as one example) quote-tweeting whatever idiocy the president or his enablers has vomited out into the world. If we stopped signal-boosting all these idiots, I really think they'd go away. There's no upside to retweeting those things, beyond the endorphin rush of feeling superior because you got to say something snappy to a tweet by someone who doesn't even know you exist. But they're happy because you're sharing their message with other people.

Ramit Sethi, author of I Will Teach You to be Rich (another thing I know about because of the internet) talks about improving your life by focusing on increasing the good, rather than decreasing the bad. It's not always the easiest thing to implement, but it's pretty powerful - instead of cutting out junk food, for instance, you focus on increasing the amount of healthy food you eat.

It's a good model for how we approach the internet, I'd say. Instead of rage-tweeting because some right-wing dingbat thinks Mexicans cause the coronavirus or some such nonsense, seek out the things on Facebook and Twitter that make you happy, or make you think, or even just make you laugh. Such as this: