Pages

Sunday, 12 March 2023

Journalistic Spinelessness

I've been following the Gary Lineker-refugee bill controversy in the UK for the last three days with an attention I usually reserve for football tournaments or prestige TV dramas. I'm pretty heavily on Lineker's side, even to the point of being a little tired of even his defenders saying he maybe shouldn't have compared the UK government's asylum-seekers bill to Nazi Germany: I agree with takes that the comparison is over-used and risks diluting the meaning of the Holocaust, but at the same time if you have a dystopian bill like the one the UK Home Office is pushing, you have to be able to describe it accurately.

More interesting than the question of what language to use is how the BBC has reacted to the whole thing. Beyond people pointing out all the times that freelance BBC presenters have expressed right-wing sympathies, the move to suspend Lineker for not apologizing shows how terrified the corporation is of criticism from right-wingers.

It's partly justified, because there's a large, right-wing print industry (mostly led by Rupert Murdoch-owned outlets but not exclusively) that pounces on any misstep by the BBC. On top of that, Conservative party ministers have been contributing to this atmosphere for years as well, by threatening to privatize it or seating sympathetic administrators on its various management boards.

But there's also a sense of a crisis that didn't have to happen: for one thing, they didn't have to suspend him, and more importantly, they didn't have to then lie that he'd "agreed to step back" from presenting duties. They could have weathered a few days of criticism and then the raging beast that is alt-right social media would have moved on to something else. And for another, that inchoate mass of rageful protoplasm that is the alt-right wouldn't be happy with anything the BBC does, just because they see it as in thrall to the left in whatever it does.

This is a problem that other news outlets face. The New York Times has come in for criticism of its lukewarm handling of culture-war and white-nationalism stories in the last few years, because it's seen as moderating its positions to avoid criticism from bad-faith actors on the right. It even went so far as to ban its journalists from appearing on Rachel Maddow's show on MSNBC, for fear that alt-right outlets would use it as evidence of how far left the Times has gone.

Except: the Ben Shapiro's and Breitbarts and whoever else are going to say that about the Times no matter what it does. And, as a commentator pointed out on Twitter, this ban just gave the Times's rivals, like the Washington Post, all the speaking slots on Maddow's show that would have gone to the Times. This meant that the Post could talk about its own reporting, and essentially promote itself, while the Times cowered in its offices and pissed off the people who would normally be supporting it.

Both these cases get at the point that, in many cases, centrism is just as problematic as airing extreme views. What's the "centrist" approach to issues like abortion or the death penalty? Do you advocate for only half of women's or LGBTQ rights, or do you air equal amounts of pro-Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter reporting?

Some people (probably on the right, and certainly not very sophisticated) insist that if a reporter's viewpoint is in the article, then the reporter has failed. That's probably okay for human interest pieces (although this NYT restaurant review will never not be hilarious), but the act of reporting demonstrates where the outlet's and the reporter's interests lie: a paper that doesn't believe climate change is real won't report on it. An article should probably not be a harangue, but if we're reporting that climate scientists believe the increase in strong hurricanes and droughts is caused by global warming, then that's probably because we agree with that position.

Most importantly, trying to hew to a too-centrist approach risks amplifying voices you shouldn't: if it's raining outside, do you "balance" the meteorologist's opinion with someone who says that it's not, in fact, raining? Or it risks confusing the issue by presenting two sides to stories that don't really have two sides.

It's easy for me to say the BBC and the NYT should grow some spine and report honestly, because the culture is such that they're probably inundated with threats all the time. But when they make self-defeating decisions like these, like suspending possibly the most-loved man in Britain for saying what the legitimate opposition party hasn't found the balls to say, then maybe it's time they re-evaluated some editorial choices?

Thursday, 9 March 2023

We Need More Cars Like in Europe

Just last weekend I got back from my yearly trip to Italy, which I undertook during February so that my dad and I could go skiing. As another deviation from the normal routine, I rented a car this time, one with an automatic transmission, so that I could take on some of the driving duties (I can technically drive manual, but I'm not comfortable doing it yet on European mountain roads).

The car I got was a Volkswagen Golf, which came with almost all the bells and whistles. Keyless ignition, which kept tripping my dad and I up, Apple CarPlay, lane assist, and even that functionality where the dashboard shows you the road signs near you. It beeped whenever I got too close to something in front or in back, but didn't have a backup camera, which is a little confusing on my car here but would have been nice paired with those proximity sensors.

It was a good car, though, and we agreed that it was extremely fun to drive. The pickup on it was monstrous, as I proved on the last morning when I had to overtake a big rig truck on a two-lane country road. It went from about 70kph to about 117kph in a couple of seconds, with nary a complaint from the engine, and I was out in front of the truck long before we got to the curve and any oncoming traffic.

A few of the levers and buttons were over-engineered and confusing to use, and the dashboard itself was curiously uninformative on matters like how much diesel I had in the tank or how far we'd driven. The only thing it showed was the range, which is the actual subject of today's blog.

When I picked up the car from the rental agency, its range hovered around 950 kilometers to about 1,010, or between 590 and 627 miles. This might be because it was a diesel, which typically gets better mileage than gas-powered cars, but either way, it beats the hell out of the nearly 400-mile range my Honda HR-V here in California gets.

The other notable thing about the Golf is that in the ten days I had it, we only took it to the gas station twice, and one of those was just a top-up on the final day to ensure that we brought it back with a full tank of gas. Technically, we could have skipped the first trip to the gas station, because my dad was worried that the stations along the freeway to the airport would be more expensive, but it proved not to be the case.

So to sum up, the Golf boasted a longer range than my own car, survived a road trip to the mountains and back without needing a fill-up, and accelerated more quickly and smoothly than my own car. This last is because it had about 100 horsepower more than my car.

The thing that really got to me, though, was that fuel consumption: I'd be interested to take the Golf on road trips of similar length to what I do in my car, but I have a hard time imagining circumstances where I could drive my Honda for nearly two weeks without needing to buy gas. I'm proud enough of its range that could get it from the Bay Area to LA on a single tank of gas, though whenever I drive down to Southern California I always fill up on the way. But that performance simply doesn't compare with the Golf's.

And by the way, it's not only this wonder-vehicle from Volkswagen that has great mileage. My dad has a Fiat Panda, one of those toy cars that are super common in Europe because they're great for city driving. Last year we calculated the mileage it had gotten on its latest tank of gas, and we came up with about 67 mpg. And here I was impressed that my Honda ekes out 42 mpg when I drive it down the length of the Central Valley.

I understand that the comparisons probably aren't too useful. The Panda has a manual transmission, lacks a lot of the electronics of my Honda, and is also pretty dinky in comparison. Yet it still gets about 50% better mileage than my car, a number that most American drivers could only dream of.

We're in the midst of an environmental crisis, where governments are trying to shift consumers away from gas- and diesel-powered cars in favor of electric vehicles, which are way cleaner to run, even if they end up being powered by dirty electricity. The fact that gas prices are so high, due to the war in Ukraine (among other factors), is providing another impetus for consumers to explore buying EVs, and to the credit of American consumers, we do seem to be going down that road more quickly than in Europe, or at least Italy.

On the other hand, European cars have always been a bit more fuel-efficient than American cars, in part because Europeans tend to buy smaller. You see very few monstrously huge SUVs or pickup trucks in Europe, because in addition to the higher fuel costs you'd have a devil of a time parking the damn things. So the average vehicle consumes less, which means drivers aren't in such a hurry to shift to hybrids or EVs.

And yet, a couple of months ago I was annoyed to learn that the latest model of the HR-V would have a hybrid option in Europe, but not here. It might be surprising, given that I drive a crossover SUV, but I do care about gas mileage, and having the option to reduce my trips to the gas station would be welcome. I just get annoyed that because most Americans don't seem to care, I don't get that option.

It's probably folly to sit and wish that the US were more like Europe in every respect, but this is one area where it could be achievable. European fleets are more efficient and smaller in part because gas prices are so much higher than here - I'm not suggesting that gas should cost as much here as it does in Italy, but Europe's high gas taxes have clearly spurred a lot more innovation toward fuel efficiency. Political opposition from Republicans aside, the Biden administration could easily mandate higher gas mileage throughout the US fleet.

None of this is to suggest that we shouldn't be moving toward EVs - they seem to make sense, and I'd have considered buying one myself the last time I was in the market for a new car. What stopped me was the upfront cost and the lack of range among non-Tesla models. Ironically, even though I don't have a long commute, I do think I'm more likely than many American drivers to drive long distances. But for all that I wasn't ready to go electric, a hybrid would have been a great option for me, if only it had been available.

Sunday, 5 February 2023

Finally Catching Up with The Last of Us

One of my resolutions every year is to play through some of my backlog of video games that I've acquired since 2014, for various systems. Like most people's resolutions, this one never quite survives past about March, although I'm pleased that I've stuck to the corollary resolution, which is not to buy too many new games (or systems).

The truth is that I'm not great at finishing games. When they had eight levels, simple graphics and gameplay, and didn't feature a lot of cutscenes, I could just about manage it, but at some point I guess I get bored of them and want to see what's going on with another game. With an older game, like the original Megaman series on the NES, if I revisit a game years later then at least it's not such a time investment to just start again at the beginning.

Which brings me to The Last of Us. When I bought it in early 2014, it came as a bundle with my PS3 and it was one of several titles I had my eye on because of the buzz I'd been hearing at the time. Back then, I managed the prologue but never got past the tutorial in the game proper. I moved on, instead, to other games for the system. Some I finished, like Assassin's Creed 2 and Arkham City and the Mass Effect Trilogy, while others I've dipped into again, like Skyrim, or restarted more than once, like Dragon Age Inquisition. And of course, there's also Assassin's Creed 4, which I've never even played (maybe later this year I'll write a blog about how great that one is, but don't bet on it).

The premiere of the TV show on HBO is what impelled me to try the game again. It's co-created by Craig Mazin, who co-hosts the Scriptnotes podcast and who created Chernobyl, also for HBO and one of the best TV shows I've seen in recent years. I actually started a new file of The Last of Us on the weekend the first episode was due to air, and I've managed to stick to playing it a couple of hours per weekend, then watching the show that evening.

What's funny is that those two hours each week have been enough to keep up with the show, at least so far.  The first episode started with the collapse of civilization and ended with Pedro Pascal's character, Joel, killing a soldier in front of Bella Ramsey's Ellie, which was about the point I got to on that Sunday. The following week I saw the ultimate fate of Joel's partner, Tess, and the week after I got to explore Bill's Town in the game, before watching the story of Bill and his husband Frank on TV.

I'm probably not going to be able to keep that cadence, both because of other things I have going on (like a trip to Europe later this month) and because the show is diverging from the game in order to tell its story in ways that are appropriate for TV. But so far it's been a really fun way of following along with both.

As for how I like them, well, the TV show has become a must-watch for me on Sunday nights. The lead actors are a good pairing on their own merits (and it's probably best that I don't have years of playing the game to bias me against them) and the aesthetics of the show are really well thought out, from the abandoned cityscapes to the design of the infected, especially the Clickers.

Meanwhile, the game's grown on me as I've learned how to play it. Certain parts have been frustratingly difficult, but eventually I've gotten through them, helped at times by online walkthroughs. I like the possibilities offered by gathering resources, which lets you upgrade your gear and your character, but the gameplay can be a little frustrating, since the PS3 controller has so many buttons that it's easy to forget which one you're mashing. It's pretty much a given that in a fight with a Clicker, I'll press the button to punch it instead of the button to stab it, and end up getting eaten by the bastard.

Still, it looks good and is entertaining, so what more do I need? My one concern is how I'll play the sequel, The Last of Us Part 2, since it's only on PS4. I've picked up a few mini consoles and the Nintendo Switch since I bought my PS3, but a new PS4 or PS5 feels like an unnecessary purchase if I'm not going to devote time to playing any games for it. But that's a ways off, so in the meantime I can just focus on finishing the game in front of me.

If you haven't played it or watched the show, I'd totally recommend playing them side-by-side, like I'm doing now. It's given me a greater appreciation for the storyline and the design, and it's helped keep my interest in the game (at least until the next time I want to binge a tower defense game on my iPad).

Friday, 13 January 2023

Bluetooth Headphone Face-Off: Sony wins on sound, but Beats win on usability

I can't stop buying headphones. Since 2018 I've bought three sets for myself, received one set for my birthday and bought or advised on the purchase of two more. I thought I was cured when I bought my Sony WH-1000XM4 over-ear headphones in 2021, to celebrate getting a new job, but just last week I picked up a set of refurbished Beats Fit Pro earbuds, because they were on sale at Woot.com for $100, or half of what I'd pay for new ones at the Apple Store.

It's not like I need them. My M4s give me good noise cancelling for writing, while my first-gen AirPods connect easily to just about every one of my devices. But I persuaded myself that what I really needed was a pair of earbuds for working out, even though I don't listen to music while running and I don't go to the gym at the moment.

On the other hand, now that I've had a chance to play with them, I'm glad I got them. They may have edged out my AirPods, but I thought it would still be worthwhile to do a comparison of all three on certain aspects that I've found are important. So without further ado:

Fit

This refers to how they fit in my ear, or over it, and to how well they stay in place. With regard to the former, the AirPods are clear winners. They fit into the ear canal so nicely that after a while I don't even notice they're there. Their shape doesn't create the vacuum needed for noise cancellation, but that's actually a plus for me (which makes it even weirder that I got the Beats ones, but more on that below).

On the negative side, the ease of putting them in means they also fall out easily. I haven't lost them or had them fall out while walking, but I am constantly checking and adjusting them. Not only that, but when I did go to the gym pre-pandemic, I'd wear them while walking on the treadmill and the sweat would make them fall out more easily.

The Sony M4s (as I'll be calling them from here on) fit over the ears, so the band over my head helps keep them in place. They do create a bit of vacuum, but because it's over the full ears it's not so noticeable. They also stay in place nicely if I'm walking around with them on, but the weight of them makes that less desirable (and I'm a bit self-conscious walking around with them).

The Beats Fit Pros have that earbud tip that I usually hate putting in, but it makes sense for the noise cancellation. Unlike the AirPods, I'm aware that I'm wearing them at all times, but on the other time, I can trust that they'll stay put. I went out walking while wearing them this morning, and I appreciated not having to constantly adjust them. 

One of the reasons I got them was also the wings that are meant to hold them in place in the ear, and those are comfortable enough. If I do find that they're bothering my outer ear, I can adjust them and solve it that way. I have only two complaints: the feeling of ear pressure when they're in noise-cancelling mode; and the fact that when I used my phone settings to test their fit, it said it couldn't get a good fit on my left ear. I'll have to mess with the ear tips a bit, but hopefully I'll be able to fix that.

Connection

I've also noticed differences in how easily they connect to my other devices and how well they stay connected. I've connected each of them via Bluetooth to my iPhone, iPad, MacBook Air and Apple TV. You'd think the AirPods would score highly here, but surprisingly they don't, even despite the ecosystem advantage. They pair relatively easily with each of the devices, though it took a while to get them paired with the Apple TV. Once they pair, though, they drop the connection pretty easily. I've noticed it mostly on my phone, where sometimes the connection fails mid-sentence while I'm listening to a podcast.

The worst, however, is on my laptop. They require an extra step, of going to the settings menu and choosing them for my audio output. This setting just drops out at random from time to time while I'm wearing them, even though they maintain the connection. This happens less often on the iPad or Apple TV, but it's particularly bad on the iPhone, since they're meant to go with you and should therefore be reliable.

The Sony M4s have the most reliable connection, but with an asterisk: I mostly use them with the cord plugged into my laptop or iPad. This makes them way more reliable, but also less portable. Because they're not Apple devices, there's a little extra trouble to connecting them via Bluetooth, and they don't seem to like connecting that way to my laptop. On the other hand, they connect just fine to the Apple TV.

The best overall are the Beats. Right out of the box they connected straight away to just about everything that was in reach. They even did so on the laptop, and don't require me to choose them for audio output, nor do they drop the Bluetooth connection. Even if I wander out of range, they connect right up again when I go back to my laptop. The only time they dropped the connection was when I was listening to a podcast on my phone and set a timer; when the timer rang, they dropped the connection.

Sound

I need to do a full test of how music and voices sound on each of my headphones, but even without doing a full test I've seen a bit of a difference among all three. The other part of this section is noise cancelling, which doesn't apply to my AirPods.

To be fair, all three sets of headphones sound good, certainly compared to the older, wired headphones that came with various devices over the years. One way I measure that is by how loud I have to set my devices' volumes when I'm connected to the headphones. When using the AirPods I have to set the volume on my laptop to its lowest setting, while when I wear the Sony M4s I have to reduce the volume even further, by lowering it in the app I'm listening to: this is the same whether it's on YouTube, Apple Music or Spotify. The Beats, on the other hand, don't sound as good at such low volumes, though maybe this is because of the issue with the fit on the left ear.

Turning to noise cancelling, my impression is that it's better on the Sony M4s than the Beats, both because of the fit issue and because the Sony ones cover my ears completely. The effect also seems to be more subtle with the Beats: when I turn on noise cancelling it blocks out the constant hum of my fridge and the nearby road, while the Sony headphones feel like they cut out the world. Noise still gets through, but not as clearly as when I wear the Beats.

The real test will be next time I fly. I wore the Sony M4s on the plane last summer and was impressed by how much engine noise they cut out. I'll be curious to see how the Beats fare on planes.

The only other thing to note with the Beats is Apple's spatial audio, which they're compatible with. I didn't notice it much when I listened to Apple Music on my laptop, but when I went walking with them I put on some music with spatial audio and there was a clear difference. Specifically, if I turned my head then the music concentrated in the earbud that was facing toward where my body was facing. To put it another way, if I turned to the left, the music sounded like it was coming from my right earbud.

It's kind of a neat trick but not the surround sound I was expecting. Maybe I need to try it again when I connect them to my Apple TV.

Battery

In normal use all three sets seem equally long-lived, though the Sony M4s may have the longest battery life. That could be because they're physically larger, meaning they can hold a larger battery. It could also be that I use them slightly less because they're larger and more unwieldy, whereas the AirPods and the Beats get more use during the day because they're easier to connect and I can move farther from my laptop with them.

The one extreme case where the Sony M4s have done clearly better than the AirPods is on long video calls. I regularly play Dungeons & Dragons, for sessions lasting 3 hours, via video calls on Discord. I usually use the Sony headphones for noise cancelling, and they always hold up well for the entire three hours. For one session I wasn't able to use them, so I tried the AirPods, and they lost their charge after a short time, meaning I had to switch to another set of headphones. I haven't had that happen again, but I'm curious if the Beats would work for as long.

Other stuff

The AirPods have the smallest, most portable case, which is nice, but it also feels more flimsy than that of the Beats. The Beats also have a stronger magnet in their case, which snaps them in place for charging. The case for the Sony M4s, meanwhile, is huge and unwieldy, but that makes sense because they're over-ear headphones, so can't be as small as the earbuds.

Both the Sony headphones and the Beats charge via USB-C, which is nice for most people, but because I'm so locked into the Apple ecosystem I actually find it nice that I can use Lightning cables for the AirPods. This means I can use one charging cable for my phone, tablet, iPod and AirPods, whereas the other headphones require another, special cable that doesn't go with all of my other chargers and power banks.

Verdict

For audio quality and noise cancelling, the winners have to be the Sony M4s. They're a little heavier and more unwieldy, but the sound is clearer and I suspect they block out more noise than the Beats. They're not great for walking around, but they're also not terrible at it, and at least I can trust that they won't fall out.

For everyday use, I'd say the Beats have overtaken the AirPods. They may be a little less comfortable, but I never have to worry about them falling out while I walk, or even while I'm lying down. They also connect to all my other devices more easily, which makes them more convenient and quicker to get started using.

The AirPods will probably remain best for listening to stuff while I'm lying in bed or watching TV or generally staying still. Their sound quality is good considering that they don't have noise cancelling and so don't have to create a vacuum in my ear canal. I also appreciate the comfortable fit, though that fit is probably why they slide out of my weirdly shaped ears.

Sunday, 8 January 2023

2022 in the Rearview Mirror

Another year done and dusted, and I'm not sure what to think of this one. On the work front, it was pretty good, as I got more used to how things work at my job and wrote a few reports and blogs that I'm fairly proud of. On the personal side, it's been a process of returning to normalcy as I got more confident with doing things outside the house and coping with the risks of the pandemic. 

There are still things I'm not interested in doing, like going to the gym (although the minute I think it's not a high-risk activity I want to jump straight onto a treadmill), and there are things that I can see my way to doing but haven't yet, like going to the movies. That said, all my avenues to watch movies on streaming are fulfilling my needs so far, so maybe what I need is to buy a bigger TV.

As far as eating at restaurants, I've actually done that to varying degrees this year, reasoning that a particularly good meal or good company is worth the risk of getting Covid. Though I'm quite proud of not having gotten it, and it'd be great to go through this whole pandemic having avoided it - but we'll see.

In terms of my goals and interests and pursuits, it's felt like a mixed bag. I finished my first novel in quite a few years, but then stalled pretty hard on the revisions for it and haven't really written much new stuff since then. One reason for this lack of productivity was games, both video and tabletop, which pulled my focus away from working; another was the telecoms-related blogs I was writing elsewhere, which broke my rhythm when working on other stuff. I'm quite proud of some of those blogs, but think I'll be taking a break from them for the time being (unless I get a nice idea to pursue).

Dating was a bit of a mixed bag, but the important thing is that I got back onto the apps and met a couple of ladies. The important point for me this year will be getting out to more social stuff: not even to meet women but to learn new skills and get into more social situations. I keep putting off my "Practice Spanish" meetup, but that was always okay to check out, and it was useful for sharpening up my Spanish, so maybe this year I'll go back.

Fitness was hampered by not going to the gym, as it limited the types of workouts I could do. Even the ones I could do, like running on the street, were a bit limited by the weather: I don't like to go running if it's rainy and dark, or if it's too hot.

One area where I thought I made some good strides this year was in traveling. Apart from the three drives down to my mom's house in Southern California, I also got in a ski trip with my dad and my first flight to Italy since the start of the pandemic. Both were good for calibrating my sense of what's okay to do outside the house, and the Italy trip reawakened my desire to travel the world. I'd like to get to Australia this year, for example, so hopefully I'll be able to swing that.

In terms of media consumed, very little stands out. Among TV shows, the only standouts were Andor on Disney+ and We Own This City on HBO Max, though watching season 1 of Fargo on DVD (from Netflix) was also quite fun - it's just not a new thing from this year. I also really liked Star Trek Lower Decks and Strange New Worlds, both of which did good new things with Trek that have been missing from Discovery and Picard (which I felt fumbled its second season, if not as badly as Disco).

There was also Sandman, of course, which I talked about here. The main thing that came out of that was that I bought the collected editions and reread the comics. It's funny how I appreciate the stories and themes a little better, or at least differently, now that I've lived a bit compared to when I first discovered them at 13 or 14 years old.

As far as movies, even less stands out. The one film that does is Everything Everywhere All at Once, which hit a lot of my sweet spots of topics and themes that interest me. Michelle Yeoh and Ke Huy Quan were particularly great, especially given the different types of characters they had to play. Much of the rest of what I saw was Marvel or DC tie-ins, and those mostly kept to the average level of quality, with none over a B+ or below a C-. Dishonorable mention went to Black Adam, which wasted a number of ideas about American power and authoritarianism, as well as characters like Dr. Fate and Hawkman and the Justice Society in general.

For podcasts, I liked My Year in Mensa and All-Star Super-Fan, though the latter I technically discovered in 2021. Still, I love that they get some great writers to talk about Superman, and it soundtracked some good drives this year.

I also want to reiterate my appreciation for the History of Rome podcast, which finally demystified Roman history, especially in the Imperial phase. My new party trick is listing all (or at least most) of the emperors from Augustus to Theodosius... though maybe I need to go to better parties?

What about the coming year?

I don't know yet what'll characterize 2023 for me, but I want to spend more time cooking more elaborate dinners than just a chicken breast in the oven with a side of salad. I already said that I hope to travel more this year, and one thing I'd like to do more of is work remotely in fun, new places. I want to spend more time reading new books, but I'm also aiming to reread my collection of Paul Theroux travel books. I also hope to spend more time encountering exciting new music, especially since I now have a few months of free access to Apple Music because I bought a pair of Beats earbuds.

More than anything, though, I plan for 2023 to be the year of getting back in shape, getting out of the house, and fixing up medical complaints that have bothered me for a while. The cooking is in aid of that, but I feel I made some progress in 2022 so I want to keep up that momentum this coming year. I'm hoping to come out of 2023 feeling excited and invigorated, but of course, that feeling will come from me, not from external signifiers of success. But those external signifiers never hurt either!

Monday, 2 January 2023

RIP Pele

No sooner do I publish a blog talking about who's the greatest player of all time, than I have to revisit this question because Pelé, one of the game's greatest players ever, has passed away. There was some preparation for this one, because it was announced during the World Cup that he was moving to palliative care for his cancer. He'd been ill for a while, unfortunately, but it was heartening to see, after that announcement, that he held on and communicated to the fans that he was still hanging on. So as I say, it wasn't too much of a surprise that he did then pass away, though of course it's still desperately sad to see one of the greats of the game departing.

In my previous post, talking about who was the greatest player of all time, I talked about how Pelé was the most visible figure even to people who didn't know anything about football. The way I phrased it might have sounded like I had some hipster alternative for the game's greatest player, but I don't want it to be taken dismissively: after all, Pelé was known outside of football because he was a breakout star who symbolized the game and the glamor and romance of the World Cup. In that respect, he's probably even more influential than my pick for most influential, Johan Cruyff.

I also have to confess that I didn't really have much of a sense of Pelé the player because he retired long before I started following the game. I learned about him when I did, of course, even as early as 1994, but unlike Diego Maradona, Pelé came before I was able to hear about relatives in Italy raving about him. Not only that, but some of his game footage doesn't exist anymore, if it ever did: like the very first batch of Dr Who episodes, a lot of those games have been lost forever.

Yet when I did get to see what was there, I couldn't deny it was amazing. One afternoon, for example, I caught the movie of the 1970 World Cup at my grandma's house back in 1998 or 1999, and was transfixed. Along with his teammates, he entertained and played to the crowds while winning possibly the greatest tournament ever.

Since Pelé's passing, I've read a few articles and listened to a few podcasts about his legacy. I think the thing that's stuck with me most from those is how he was seen in the global struggle for civil rights. Specifically, the Guardian compared him to Muhammad Ali, although unlike Ali, Pelé seems to have been in some ways more ambivalent about his place as a symbol. They pointed out that he certainly wasn't outspoken about Brazil's military government, though he later regretted his silence on that topic.

I can't speak to that, especially given the controversies around the Qatar World Cup or the 1978 Argentina World Cup, which I'm reading about currently in a book about Argentine football (Angels with Dirty Faces, by Jonathan Wilson). For someone who lives under a dictatorship like Brazil or Argentina in those years, it's probably not as simple to criticize the government as it is for foreigners outside the country, and if he considered doing so, Pelé must have worried about his family and friends in Brazil, as well as his sponsorships and playing contract. 

Nobody's perfect, and nobody makes the right decision in every case. Yet Pelé symbolized the joy of the jogo bonito, the beautiful game, and every football fan in the world from 1958 to the early 1980s knew who he was. Writing this post, I've had in my head that image of him being carried aloft after winning the 1970 World Cup. He was relatively old by then, 12 years on from his debut in the 1958 Sweden World Cup, but he'd just been part of a team that had dominated the tournament like no other. Even after coming out of retirement he was that good, and so, regardless of whether you think he was the greatest player, he was certainly the King, and we won't see someone like that again.

Sunday, 18 December 2022

World Cup 2022: El GOAT

In the end, it could only be this. Messi, the past decade's candidate for greatest of all time, against Mbappé, the coming decade's candidate for greatest of all time. Messi scored once and helped create a second, and we thought that was that. Then, with ten minutes left in the game, Mbappé conjured a couple of pieces of magic to take the game to extra time. Messi scored again to win it, once and for all, but at the death Argentine nerves frayed and gave France a penalty, which Mbappé scored to take the game to penalties. And even the shootout was a thriller, as pretty much all of them have been this World Cup: France first (Mbappé, of course), then Argentina (Messi, of course), then two misses from France and three scores from Argentina...

And the cup's been won by a non-European team for the first time in 20 years. At the same time, we got a classic match, probably the first good final in... certainly as long as I've been watching football. And the first final-game hat-trick since 1966, scored by (who else?) Mbappé.

I had slightly mixed feelings going into this match, since both teams' talismanic players are employed by Paris St-Germain, which is owned by Qatar, which is, of course, the host. Whichever team won, it'd be a propaganda/soft power win for Qatar. At the same time, you could forget the background for a moment, the unhinged speeches and hollow justifications from various functionaries of the game, and just enjoy two teams playing really good football.

Did Qatar put on a good show? Yes, I think they did. The venues weren't exactly full, but it seems like things ran as they should. People had a good time, the venues were easy to reach and there weren't any instances of hooligan violence that I read or heard about (you assume the Guardian and whatever other outlets would cover it). This also might be unpopular to say, but I actually appreciate how Qatar stood up to FIFA and the sponsors and said that, no, you wouldn't be able to buy beer in the stadia after all.

Does any of that invalidate the abuses of workers that enabled this World Cup to take place? No, those worker deaths and the obfuscation and double-speak around them will remain a black mark on FIFA and the game in general. Other countries are culpable too, not least Russia, which bookended its hosting in 2018 with two separate attacks on Ukraine and has also passed law after law criminalizing the "promotion" of LGBTQ lifestyles. People have highlighted homophobic chanting in Mexico, and the overturning of Roe v Wade in the US, but none of those things invalidates the criticism of Qatar doing it, at least as long as reporters and NGOs note when other countries are doing bad stuff.

Some numbers

Turning briefly to the numbers, I've put the final touches on my spreadsheet looking at how the Western European teams have done against the rest of the world. In 2006, Western European teams took 2.59 points from their matches against the rest of the world, which remains the highest average this century (this counts penalty shootouts as draws, but games won in extra time are counted as regular wins or losses). For comparison, in 2022 they took 1.66 points per game against the rest of the world, which is actually the second lowest total, after 2002, which was also the last time a South American team won the tournament and the last time an African team went on a run past the round of 16.

That's for all Western European teams, so the likes of Wales or Belgium or Denmark, who didn't make it out of the group stage, are dragging the average down. If we look at the performance of the 5 big Western European countries - England, France, Germany, Italy and Spain - then they took 1.85 points per game against the rest of the world, which is actually the third-highest in this same period since 2002. The only tournaments where they did better were 2006, when Italy met France in the final, and 2018, when France won and England got to the semifinal.

What's impressive is that these numbers have been improving since the nadir of 2010, when they got 1.63 points per game, especially when you consider that in that period at least one of the big five has always failed to progress from the group stage. It's even more impressive when you consider that Italy hasn't even qualified for the last two World Cups. So really it's only four big teams posting these numbers, and getting better against the rest of the world since 2010. 

That seems to be a confirmation of Soccernomics's argument that the Western European football networks are helping the region dominate. They are home to the biggest, richest leagues, as well as France, which doesn't have an amazing league but which does create world class players who ply their trade in Spain and England, and less importantly in Italy and Germany (I say less importantly because the two biggest leagues are clearly the Premier League and the Primera Liga).

Colonialism vs multiculturalism

This point about the strength of the networks raises another point, about the makeup of these teams. I've seen a few people on social media talk about how these big Western European teams do well only because of colonialism. It's a persuasive argument, especially when you consider that certain French players were born in overseas departments, or have their ancestry from there. Those overseas departments may be officially part of France, but that's just colonialism too, since it means France hasn't let go of them in four or five centuries.

The other way of looking at it, though, is that these players of African or Caribbean or Middle Eastern descent demonstrate the strength of multiculturalism. French right-wing nationalists complain when the French team wins (seriously) because there are so many "black-blanc-beurre" players; at the same time, England's black players get horrific abuse on social media when they miss penalties, and also when their white colleagues miss penalties (Bukayo Saka got abused for England losing to France, even though Harry Kane missed the penalty that would have kept them in the game). But it's actually a good thing that these national teams are selecting the strongest players they can, regardless of skin color or how "French" or "English" or "German" their names are.

I think we can agree that the worst of both worlds would be for, say, France to maintain these overseas colonies, but to deny their residents, who pay French taxes, speak French and use the same currency as Metropolitan France, the opportunity to represent their country in football?

It gets more complicated when you consider the multiracial makeup of the other big Western European countries. Bukayo Saka is of Nigerian descent, but Nigeria isn't part of the United Kingdom, just of the Commonwealth. In contrast to other independent members of the Commonwealth, its currency doesn't have the English monarch (and I say that deliberately). Yet Saka was born in England and came up through its academy system, and represents his adopted country at the highest level. There are clearly colonial links, but as I say, it speaks to the willingness of the football authorities in England to look for talent outside of the traditional groups that provided players.

Most big Western European teams have opened up their selections to non-white players, both from former colonies and from immigrant populations. The big exception, however, is Italy. There have been a couple of notable exceptions, like Mario Balotelli and Moise Kean, but the first black player selected by the Italian national team was Fabio Liverani, hardly a household name, and he was only called up in 2001, long after France and England were well-integrated.

I don't think Italy's lack of multicultural players is the main or only reason why it's had so much trouble at the World Cup since 2006. It has, after all, reached two European Championship finals and won one of them, and has generally done much better at that level than in the World Cup. But Italian society is changing, with the aging of the society and the lack of opportunities driving young Italians abroad, while the country's position in the Mediterranean makes it the first port of call for many refugees and migrants. Saying that welcoming in these migrants will help in football may seem silly, but if that's the way to show Italians that people of color can benefit their society, then I think it's an avenue to explore.

Is Messi the GOAT?

I'm not even going to try to segue smoothly from that section to this, even though Lionel Messi is a migrant twice over: once when his Italian forebears came to Argentina and again when he moved to Spain to receive treatment for his hormone deficiency and to develop his footballing skills. 

But the question of whether Messi is the greatest of all time has been bandied about a lot this tournament, since it's probably his last. I don't know if winning this tournament cements that status for him, because he's associated more with his time at Barcelona, where he won everything he could possibly win and dominated Spanish football alongside Cristiano Ronaldo and Real Madrid. I wonder if winning this tournament, where he's no longer at the otherworldly heights he occupied in the previous decade, really puts him on the same level as Pele or Maradona or Zidane, who are (at least in my mind) associated more as World Cup all-time greats.

On the other hand, Messi is such a cultural force because of football that it would be odd if he'd only ever been a nearly-man footnote to the tournament, like George Best or Zlatan Ibrahimović or other great players who never won or like Best, even qualified. Winning this tournament doesn't necessarily make him the greatest player who ever lived, but it makes sure he's in the conversation.

These arguments apply to Cristiano Ronaldo, by the way. He's never won a World Cup, and now he never will, at least as a player, but he was just as much of a cultural force as Messi. You can appeal to numbers as much as you want: goals, goals per game, league titles, etc. Each has also won their regional tournament, but winning the 2022 World Cup certainly gives Messi a leg up on Ronaldo.

But what does it mean to be the greatest? Pele is the player most people think of, especially if they don't know anything else about football. He was involved in two World Cup wins, including when he came out of retirement in 1970 to play as part of possibly the greatest team the game has ever seen. Yet Ronaldo and Messi (and Neymar, and Ronaldo o fenomeno) have all surpassed certain of Pele's achievements, like international goals, appearances or career goals.

The point about everyone knowing about Pele points to another way of looking at this "greatest" debate, specifically influence. Pele became the face of football for decades, including the 1970s and 1980s' North American Soccer League, which was the previous big shot at selling soccer to American viewers before MLS. But I think the most influential player ever was Johan Cruyff, even despite (or because of) never winning the World Cup.

Cruyff became the game's biggest thinker, along with his manager Rinus Michels, and the two took the concept of Total Football from the Netherlands to Barcelona, from where it grew into the big tactical innovations in the game. This is all an abbreviated version, and to get the full picture of how tactics developed you should read Inverting the Pyramid by Jonathan Wilson and Zonal Marking by Michael Cox. But the basic point is, without Cruyff you don't get Barcelona (the concept thereof), and without Barcelona you don't get Messi.

What's next?

What's immediately next is a return to the regular season, which was interrupted by this World Cup. It seems less important than these big national questions, but it will be interesting to see how the English Premier League develops now, especially since we'll see what happens with Erling Braut Haaland, possibly the world's best player of the moment who wasn't in Qatar. Will he help Manchester City win the Champions League, or will that prize continue to elude the Gulf petrostates' teams?

At the international level, next summer we'll have the Women's World Cup, where we'll see how the rest of the world has caught up to the US. The team of 2019 may not be at the same level as last time, so will they refresh or get overtaken by other, upcoming powers?

The year after that is Euro 2024, which remains my second favorite tournament. My hope is that Italy will do well again there, and that England's progress under Gareth Southgate will also continue. Having now seen Croatia reach its second World Cup semifinal in a row, I'm also curious how they and the rest of the Eastern European teams will develop. That will depend on how well they get integrated into the existing networks around the Big 5 leagues, of course.

And finally, World Cup 2026 will mark the tournament's return to North America, the first time it'll be held here since 1994 and, really, the beginning of the modern era of football and of the World Cup. It feels a little like over-egging the pudding to hold it in three countries, all of them large enough to host a tournament on their own, especially given how 2022 was effectively held in one city. But FIFA and the media's need for spectacle is insatiable, and holding it across the US, Mexico and Canada means bringing the show to a lot of people who wouldn't otherwise get to watch it. I, for one, would like to go to matches if I'm in the US.

Anyway, that's the end of this World Cup. It's been a problematic one, but in truth, aren't they all? Without discounting the human cost, in lives lost and in dictators propped up and in corruption enabled, the fact that the World Cup comes every four years like (almost) clockwork, is a way to take stock of my life and where I am. I watched my first World Cup final in 1994 on summer vacation in Italy, and I know where I was for every single tournament since. It's given me a lot of exciting moments, like Germany's 7-1 demolition of Brazil to Italy beating France on penalties in 2006 just a month after I'd moved back to London for my first job post-grad school.

It's my favorite sporting event, and I hope to enjoy it for a long time to come. I just hope it gets less shady, and I hope Italy comes back to it.